OWNER-RAISED: lead dang va TRIEU-CHUNG (hardcode $userMemDir) thi anh chi ra GOC:
"UserMem phai ghi trong thu-muc du-an chu ko phai o C: -- cai nay lau lau drift dinh mai".
DO DUOC:
| user-memory C:\Users\<u>\.claude\projects\<slug>\memory\ | 48 file · 151,671 B | 0 git | 0 Dropbox | 0 history
| agent-memory <repo>/.claude/agent-memory/ | 82 file tracked | git | Dropbox | history
=> BAT-DOI-XUNG khong co ly-do ky-thuat nao.
RUI-RO THAT (khong phai chuyen gon-gang):
bug #53 zero-byte Write -- da MAT INDEX THAT o S45 -- xay ra DUNG tai thu-muc
KHONG CO HISTORY de phuc-hoi. Cung bug do o agent-memory => git checkout la xong.
=> lop phong-thu hien tai = "verify byte>0" = KY-LUAT NGUOI dung thay VERSION-CONTROL.
settings.json (project + user) = 0 key cau-hinh memory-path => HARNESS EP.
SE CO Y KHONG TU DOI: doi tay => harness thoi auto-inject => MAT memory khoi context
= hong nang hon bug dang co. Cho hub tra loi 1 cau: doi duoc khong, va neu khong thi vi sao?
SE KHONG ket-luan "harness sai" -- co the co ly-do dung ma SE chua thay (secret?
cross-project? per-machine?). SE chi ket-luan: rui-ro la THAT va DO DUOC.
HARDCODE = HE-QUA PHU, do chinh xac:
sinh e70c046 2026-06-18 20:44 -> va c39ba9d 2026-07-15 15:12 = SONG 27 NGAY.
Co-che KHONG phai "tai-pham nhieu lan" ma la "sinh 1 lan roi SONG SOT qua ra":
git log -S bat 8 commit nhung 5/8 co ps1/js-touched=0 (chi doc/WAL NHAC toi path);
chi 3 dong vao .ps1/.js that -- va 1 trong do la ae957c4 "double-check x2 + finalize":
mot dot DOUBLE-CHECK da so DUNG FILE do va KHONG BAT DUOC.
🟢 Doi-chung: spawn-model-audit.ps1 (W1, HOM NAY) lam DUNG san + tu ghi-chu
"NOT a hardcoded absolute path" => fleet BIET cach dung; thieu LUAT nen file cu khong ai quet.
DE-XUAT: (1) memory song trong repo (doi-xung agent-memory) (2) hoac config path
(3) hoac toi-thieu document ro "khong duoc version-control, project tu lo backup"
+ doc-lap: (4) luat no-absolute-path (spawn-model-audit = mau san) (5) khao-sat fleet.
2 LOI LEAD ghi vao request (du-lieu ve quy-trinh, khong phai loi xin loi):
(a) va trieu-chung khong hoi goc -- feedback_root_cause_over_symptom DA nam trong
memory cua lead ma lead khong tu bat ra; anh phai chi.
(b) va dung cai duoc chi, khong quet cai khac -- WAL:30 neu 1 script, lead va roi DUNG;
anh hoi moi loi ra script thu 2 cung doc user-memory. Thoat vi MAY, khong vi quy-trinh.
Email: broadcasts/outbox/ai_infra/2026-07-15-se-to-ai_infra-r6-user-memory-outside-repo.md
content_sha256 d204973b0a2358fb19da2b7a3f24431ccf7c70e1c33c2df1af41ff7caf1c31b7
SELFTEST-STAMP PASS. (KHONG sua email cu -- no da dong hash; sua = pha selftest.)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Anh chot TACH thay vi gop 1 mark -- va anh bat dung cho lead xep phang:
2 truc co NAC BANG-CHUNG KHAC HAN nhau. Gop 1 mark = LAM PHANG muc-do-chac,
ma Active-High la LENH binding => cai phang do thanh no.
MARK A -- RC-pqhuy1987-15-07-2026-15-32-20 (≙ H22 wal-defect + EOL-notice)
San-3 canonical @tiep.md §0 + TRI-ACCEPT orphan + push-guard-1-LUOT.
BANG-CHUNG MANH: 4 bo fault-inject CO RANG (San-1 2-chieu / San-3 9/9 /
push-guard 10/10 cay-git-THAT / wal-recovery 4-ca 30-assert) + 2 bay TAI-HIEN
DUOC (grep -c exit-1, dem-tong chan-push) + PUSH THAT x2 (K=0, wal:/20 11->7).
San chinh: "so trong => sach" = BUG · NHAN != CHO PHEP (run moi BAT BUOC dang-1)
· dem TRAILING trong origin/main..HEAD, CAM exit-code, CAM dem toan-lich-su (=57)
· n>0 sau 1 re-squash => STOP bao owner, CAM lap · EOL-check INFORM CAM chan push.
MARK B -- RC-pqhuy1987-15-07-2026-15-32-23 (≙ H24 lead-self-audit + H17 cadence)
roster->14 + h24_cadence + enum-DONG + counter content-addressed + RE-STAMP carry.
🔴 CAVEAT BINDING ghi THANG trong so: nac bang-chung THAP HON mark A --
2 vai CHUA CHAY lan nao (spawn-probe chung SPAWN DUOC, khong chung SOI DUOC) ·
counter=0 CHUA tick · nhip 6/15/3 = diem khoi-dau owner co-y chon, KHONG phai
"da chung-minh hieu-qua" (hub: n=1 = mocc-0) · probe phu Agent-tool registry THOI,
duong hmw.js->agentType CHUA phu.
=> "LENH ve CACH LAM, chua phai bang-chung ve HIEU-QUA".
P4 report-before-stamp: 3 tieu-chi khach-quan (pain/volume/quality) present truoc
=> anh confirm via AskUserQuestion => moi stamp. Lead KHONG tu dong dau (P4/P8).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
W5a -- harness-11-engine.md: 4 hit roster -> 0 occurrence (do bang grep -o|wc -l, KHONG grep -c).
:269 "12 sub tools:" -> "sub read-only tools:"
:322 "MOI vai roster 12" -> "MOI vai trong roster hien-hanh" + tro canonical
:332 GAP-1 "nhan ca 12 vai" -> "nhan TOAN roster" + lich-su 9->12->14 + tro canonical
:345 x2 -- BAY MEGA-LINE: sua phan "(i) Vai owner-gan" roi VAN con "VALID_ROLES = 12"
o doan SAU cua CHINH DONG DO. Sua 1 cho tuong xong = dung bay grep -c da ghi WAL 2 lan.
+ danh-sach vai khai ro la BAN SAO; nguon that = hmw.js VALID_ROLES :22-36; lech => tin hmw.js.
W5b -- scripts/governance-detectors.ps1:363 bug $userMemDir:
TRUOC: $userMemDir = 'C:\Users\pqhuy\.claude\projects\D--Dropbox-...\memory'
...nam NGAY DUOI comment ghi "Derive from this machine's project slug".
=> Comment mo-ta Y DINH; code hardcode ca path tuyet-doi LAN username. Loi noi doi
nam ngay canh dong no noi doi ve.
2 HAI CU-THE (khong phai style):
1) -RepoRoot <cay-tam> VAN doc user-memory THAT => fault-inject KHONG co lap duoc
=> teeth-test C1-wikilink bat-kha-thi => cong-cu dung de CHUNG-MINH-CO-RANG
lai khong co rang cua chinh no.
2) hardcode 'pqhuy' => may/acc khac se im lang roi xuong else-branch, va mot su
degrade IM LANG doc y het "sach".
SAU: $projectSlug = $RepoRoot -replace '[:\/_]', '-'
$userMemDir = Join-Path $env:USERPROFILE ".claude\projects\$projectSlug\memory"
VERIFY 2 CHIEU (do that, khong suy):
- slug derive tu RepoRoot that == literal hardcode cu, KHOP 100%; Test-Path = True
=> hanh-vi KHONG doi (TOTAL van 45, user-memory van duoc quet)
- -RepoRoot cay-tam => slug khac => "[note] user-memory path not reachable (...fake-repo\memory)"
=> CO LAP; ro path THAT = 0 hit.
SWEEP CUOI toan repo: 8 hit / 6 file, 0 cai thuoc nhom "doc dan-xuat khai so roster SAI
nhu su-that hien-hanh" => acceptance MOI FIX#6 DAT; nhom "chua toi luot" nay RONG sau W5.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
CHUOI BAT BUOC (v2 §3.3 + §2.4(4)): fire -> chung-kien -> ROI MOI va -> het fire.
CAM va permission-matrix TRUOC = mat chinh bang-chung detector co rang.
TRUOC (capture ra runs/<id>/W4-detector-fire-15-07-2026.md muc 1-5, fix#9c time-anchored):
MED :3 writes 60 menu but canonical=54
MED :3 writes 240 policy but canonical=216
MED :16 writes 60 menu but canonical=54
LOW :81 writes 48 policy but canonical=216
LOW :16 title-stale anchor 2026-04-30 vs 2026-07-15 (76d)
TOTAL FLAGS: 50 <- khop CHINH XAC du-bao W2 (WAL:17 "49->50, -1 cadence +2 policy")
SAU: permission-matrix 0 FLAG | TOTAL 45 | tut dung 5 | 0 flag moi (do bang `comm`, khong dem mat).
CACH VA = B1 bo so + tro canonical, KHONG doi so (doi so thi lan sau lai stale).
Dung dung loi khuyen detector tu in: "OR replace with pointer '-> docs/STATUS.md'".
CHUOI NHAN-QUA W1<->W2 chung duoc 3 detector doi trang-thai DUNG thiet-ke:
- h24_cadence: "missing => measuring NOTHING" -> "M = light_every = 6 (read from config)"
- spawn-model-audit: "expected constant missing" -> "[OK] claude-opus-4-8 = owner-ratified"
- GAP-3 policy: "policy=MISSING" -> "216" + BAT NGAY permission-matrix:3
=> truoc W2, nua policy KHONG THE fire vi STATUS khong co row Policies => detector IM,
va su im-lang do trong y HET nhu "sach". Detector khong co nguon chuan = do NOTHING.
STALE NANG HON CON-SO (tim duoc luc va, detector count-token KHONG bat duoc):
SKILL.md:20 liet "Budgets root + 3 Bg_*" nhu menu DANG SONG.
Do dia: module Budget XOA tu S61 (Mig 50); 2 hit Bg_ con lai = COMMENT BIA-MO
(MenuKeys.cs:70 + fe-{admin,user}/src/lib/menuKeys.ts:29). Code sach, chi skill con mo-ta.
=> gioi-han detector dem-so: thay "60 != 54" nhung khong thay "4 trong 60 do da bi xoa 60 phien truoc".
DUONG-GIA CAU-TRUC (khai, KHONG sua -- doi hanh-vi detector = quyen anh/W5):
lead-view-auditor.md:45 FIRE title-stale vi bang vi-du cua no chua "2026-04-30" lam MAU
minh-hoa cho class view-stale-header. Cung CO-CHE voi loi da lam acceptance FIX#6 bat-kha-thi
(:47 chua "12 sub ... roster = 14" lam vi-du). 2 detector DOC-LAP, cung 1 file, cung 1 ly-do:
VI-DU VE STALE TRONG Y HET STALE. File dinh-nghia anti-pattern tat-yeu chua mau anti-pattern.
De-xuat (khong tu lam): detector can co-che mien-tru tuong-minh cho khoi vi-du.
LEAD TU BAT 2 LOI @W4:
(a) WAL ghi "permission-matrix 6 dong" -- that la 5 (dong :70 = context, khong phai flag).
Loi dem lan thu 3 trong phien; lan nay bat TRUOC khi thanh claim gui hub.
(b) Suyt claim au canonical: grep tho MenuKeys.cs ra 64 chuoi -> SAI (dem MOI chuoi trong file,
khong phai phan-tu mang All). W2 ground dung: |MenuKeys.All|=54 (:147) x |Actions|=4 = 216.
Lead BO so cua minh, dung so W2. Bai hoc: do bang cong-cu sai con te hon khong do --
vi no ra mot con-so TRONG CO VE do duoc.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
FILE 4 fable-clone.md -- GAP#6: lane ensemble PHAI mang tier:'opus'.
Thieu => inherit lead => lead=Fable thanh N x Fable = dot quota gap N lan VA pha dung
ly-do lenh ton tai (ensemble RE de THAY 1 luot Fable dat). lead=Opus thi tier:'opus'
≡ inherit => loi VO HINH, chi lo khi Fable UP (dung loi reviewer bat @S108).
+ khai CHUA VERIFY precedence spawn-param vs frontmatter (H23 §2(2)) => DEFER phien lead=Fable.
+ grep tier:'opus' = DIEU-KIEN CAN, KHONG DU (do CHU trong file, Goodhart-able 100%).
FILE 5 agents/README.md -- bo SO khoi 8 cho (khong doi so: doi thi roster ke lai stale).
File nay chinh la VI-DU minh-hoa cho class view-stale-role-desc trong lead-view-auditor.md:47.
+ canh-bao bay glob: `ls .claude/agents/*.md` bat LUON README.md => thua 1 (R2-C1).
+ khai: doi roster = doi 2 BE-MAT DOC-LAP (agents/*.md -> registry | VALID_ROLES -> agentType).
FILE 6 fable-real-runbook.md -- 14 hit (lead bao 8 = SAI, xem duoi). + hmw.js:22-30 -> :22-36 (stale line-ref).
FILE 7 sleep-recovery-memory-l2.md -- `all` tu hardcode 9 -> DAN-XUAT TU DIA (do ra 10).
Danh-sach cung 9 da ROT office-document (them S107) suot tu do. Tro-treu: chinh doc do
da ghi "luon quet dia that" cho con-so 4/9 ngay duoi, nhung hardcode roster phia tren.
FILE 8 workflows/README.md -- TRI-ACCEPT vao ORPHAN-AUTHORITY (:19-20) + B1 pointer.
FILE 9 ACTIVE-MARKS.md -- chu-thich cho mark RC-...20-42-01 (anh CHOT: giu ban ky nguyen ven,
them chu-thich; P4/P8). "roster 12" trong than mark = anh chup luc ky, KHONG phai gioi-han.
+ STATUS.md:25 -- STALE THAT trong chinh file CANONICAL: row ghi | Sub-agents | 14 | nhung
narrative CUNG DONG ghi "ca 12 sub model: inherit" (W2 sua row, bo sot narrative).
Bay mega-line TAI HIEN: grep -c = 1 vs grep -o|wc -l = 2.
+ spec v3-PATCH -- SUA ACCEPTANCE FIX#6 (ban goc BAT-KHA-THI, tien-le WAL:29):
"0 hit song" do CA phan CO Y khop => implementation DUNG van truot. Lan thu BA cung ho
R2-C1 (ls=14) + R3-M3 (TOTAL>=46). Acceptance moi = disposition TUNG DONG theo 6 nhom.
Sweep that sau W3: 14 hit song, 0 cai la stale-can-va (vi-du co chu-dich / trich lich-su /
ban da ky / so tam / W5 chua toi luot / canonical history-delta).
LEAD TU BAT 2 LOI DEM (deu o truc dem-ve-viec-minh, -> adap-report):
(a) bao "fable-real-runbook 8 hit" -- that la 14; lay output `head -40` DA BI CAT lam so tong.
(b) bao "do lai tai-hien CHINH XAC du-bao FIX#4" roi lay trung-khop lam cho dua, trong khi
CA FIX#4 LAN LEAD deu dang do TEN FILE. Con-so dung, huong do sai.
=> khop feedback_meta_count_selfcoverage_blindspot: lead DO tot, lead DEM VE MINH thi sai.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Anh chot: dong THAT 7 orphan bang retro-harvest (khong scope, khong allowlist).
wf_5ce007c4-980, 7 lane investigator-codebase read-only, 7/7 done 0 error 1 rong.
KET QUA LAT TIEN-DE: 0/7 la viec mat. 7/7 DA XONG, chi ghi synthesis SAI CHO.
- 6 folder co "## synthesis" trong THAN run.md (dang-3)
- pe-negative-quote (S116) co ket-qua rai trong "## Stages"+"## wf run-id" (dang-4)
-- run.md:19 ghi thang "PIPELINE COMPLETE - shipped + live-verified", co ca
cicd PASS + bundle-hash + smoke 200, VAN bi xep orphan.
=> thuc-dia >=4 DANG, doc chi thua-nhan 2 => menh-de C8 (dual) CHUA DU, can tri-accept.
Goc: orphan-authority (workflows/README.md:20) hoi "da harvest chua" nhung DO TEN FILE
=> do cai DE DO, khong phai cai CAN DO. 8 duong-gia / 25 run = 32%.
Boi: 8fa2fcc message khoe "close-review run.md synthesis [H2 gate]" ma git show --stat
KHONG cham folder => H2 da soi + coi DONG, chi lech ten file.
KHONG phai convention-cu-mot-thoi-ky: cung ngay 07-12, h22-wal-adopt ghi file phang
con S112-* ghi trong run.md => thoi-quen khong nhat-quan.
Do truoc/sau: naive 13->7 | dual-accept 8->2 | 7 ton-dong -> 0.
Cach lam: COPY additive, run.md GIU NGUYEN, file moi tu khai "ban goc la CHUAN"
=> 0 rewrite history (tinh-than C8).
Lead tu nhan 3 loi (vao adap-report):
(a) bao anh "tai-hien CHINH XAC du-bao FIX#4" roi lay trung-khop lam cho dua --
con-so dung nhung CA FIX#4 LAN LEAD deu do TEN FILE, sai huong.
(b) memoryPack ghi "S113/pe-negative-quote" -- SAI, la S116. Sub khong bi dat theo.
(c) ghi SHA "8fb2c9d" vao WAL TRUOC khi commit = SHA BIA -- tu bat, sua bang SHA that.
+ rmdir 2 probe dir RONG (_crlf-probe/_lf-probe) => agent-memory 16->14 khop roster.
git MU voi dir rong => porcelain sach = DUONG-GIA, khong phai bang-chung da don.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Wave adap-6-broadcast W2 = 1 OWNER / 1 COMMIT co chu dich. Cac manh phu-thuoc nhau, tach ra la vo
duong dang chay (R2-C3): gate o W2 ma co o W3 => moi /fable-clone >=3 lane THROW ngay truoc khi W3 kip va.
(1) hmw.js - 1 EDIT, 4 viec
- SAN-1 GATE co-khi-hoa: taskList>=3 && !args.run => THROW STOP-HARD.
Truoc S121 san nay chi la CHU trong doc ("script no-fs KHONG tu ep") => phu thuoc lead NHO.
Do that @S119: git grep args.run .claude/commands/ = 0 hit => 4/4 wrapper KHONG co => san danh-nghia.
Vi sao >=3: chet giua run dai ma khong co runs/<run-id>/ => per-turn returns mat theo phien,
CHI file tren dia song sot => /tiep §4 khong co vat-lieu cat-got => chay lai TU DAU (S118
raw-Agent 7-spawn => 0 run-folder). THROW chu khong fail-soft (fail-soft = dut am-tham).
- VALID_ROLES 12->14 (+lead-view-auditor +lead-omission-auditor).
- PA-2a: TIER2_EXPECTED_FULL_ID = 'claude-opus-4-8'. La HANG-SO KHAI-BAO, KHONG phai co-che neo
(neo-tai-spawn bat-kha-thi: param chi nhan alias; SE 0 full-id vi H8 all-inherit). Doc boi
scripts/spawn-model-audit.ps1 (W1b) - thieu hang-so => script FAIL-LOUD.
- H23 note CHUA-VERIFY giu nguyen nac: precedence spawn-param vs frontmatter khi CA HAI hien-dien
= CHUA TUNG TEST; phan-biet duoc CHI o phien lead=Fable => DEFER, khong ban qua nac. + fix#8a chua thu.
(2) 4 co wrapper CUNG COMMIT voi gate (San-1 (c))
fable-clone.md / fable-real.md / ultra-on.md => args.run: 0 -> 3 hit.
Wrapper thu 4 = raw-invoke em-main: KHONG co file de gan co => duoc GATE chan truc tiep
(chinh cu fault-inject duoi day di duong do). Khai that: gate chi phu hmw.js; nguong "hoac uoc
>5 phut" KHONG co-khi-hoa duoc (script khong do truoc thoi-luong) => van la ky-luat lead;
raw Workflow/Agent tool = ke CON-LAI khong gate duoc.
+ go so roster stale (view-stale-role-desc): "roster 12"/"12 sub"/"8-agent"/"9-agent" -> tro
canonical docs/STATUS.md §Sub-agents (B1). session-start.md con "roster 12" = W3 so-huu, KHONG dung.
(3) 2 vai MOI - H24 §2(1), cookie-cutter frontmatter monitor san
lead-view-auditor = view LECH source (5 class view-*)
lead-omission-auditor = cai BI THIEU (5 class gap-*)
model:inherit / memory:project / maxTurns:18 / 8 tool read-only / NO Write-Edit / propose-only.
KHONG gop vao tooling-auditor(H1)/harvest-curator(H2): H24 "gop la mat tieu-diem; can cap mat
CHI danh cho lead". Tu-vung view/omission chon tranh va-cham (detectors:15 da so-huu
derived-staleness; GAP qua-tai). 2 file 0-CR + block-scalar (giu ': ' N/A).
(4) memory-budget.json - single-source H24 §2(3)
h24_cadence { light_every:6, deep_every:15, jump_on_class_repeat:3 } (anh chot Q2).
lead_self_audit.flag_classes = enum DONG 10 class (5 view-* + 5 gap-*) - vai CAM tu che class
(v2 M4: enum song trong dau 1 lane => worker khong bao gio thay => tu che => loang thong-ke).
Honest-caveat giu de bao hub: hub dan "dung chep 3 con-so nay"; SE chon trung 6/15/3 = anh chot
CO CHU-DICH lam khoi-diem, KHONG phai chep vo-thuc; re-tune sau chu-ky-2.
(5) .claude/governance/.session-counter.json (NEW) - seed UNTICKED trung thuc
Content-based (idempotent-key = HEAD sha), KHONG blind-increment: hook wal-flush auto-commit
agent-memory/ MOI TURN => dem mu se vo nghia. Dat o .claude/governance/ CO CHU-DICH = ngoai
3 path hook (.claude/WAL.md, agent-memory/, workflows/runs/) => khong bi quet vao commit wal:.
counter=0 + last_ticked_*=null = SU THAT tai S121 (nghi-thuc tick land o W3); seed tick gia
se lam phep do cadence dau tien noi doi - dung thu H24 sinh ra de bat.
(6) STATUS.md 2 row - CUNG LANDING roster (R3-M2: lech => detector BAO tren chinh thay doi cua H24)
| Sub-agents | 12 -> 14 |
| Policies | 216 | ROW MOI - GAP-3 can no de resolve token 'policy'.
216 GROUND TU MA NGUON, khong chep tu spec: |MenuKeys.All| x |MenuKeys.Actions| = 54 x 4
(Program.cs:82-89 AddPolicy loop; MenuKeys.cs:167 Actions=[Read,Create,Update,Delete]).
=> Policies la DERIVED = Menu keys x 4 => 2 row BUOC doi cung nhau (ghi thang vao row).
VERIFY LEAD TU DO (khong tin return):
14/14/14 (roster / VALID_ROLES / agents-*.md tru README) = acceptance ② EOL.
Glob tho = 15 => xac nhan R2-C1: acceptance CU "ls agents/*.md = 14" se FAIL tren impl DUNG.
Hop-dong cheo W1<->W2 khep CA HAI chieu, do bang chinh script W1:
detector H24-2: "h24_cadence missing" -> "M = h24_cadence.light_every = 6 (read from config)"
spawn-model-audit: "expected constant missing" -> "[OK] expected = claude-opus-4-8 = owner-ratified"
GAP-3 policy: MISSING -> 216, va BAT NGAY permission-matrix/SKILL.md:3 "writes 240 policy but
canonical=216" (+:81 "writes 48") => TOTAL 49->50 (-1 fail-loud cadence, +2 policy) = so cong khop.
eol-check tu nhan 2 vai moi: scoped 37->39 (dem bang glob, khong hardcode).
FAULT-INJECT SAN-1 2 CHIEU (bai hoc W0.3: chi test 1 chieu thi dieu-kien viet nham van PASS):
(b) 3 task + KHONG args.run -> THROW, agent_count=0, subagent_tokens=0, 14ms (chan TRUOC spawn)
(a) 2 task + KHONG args.run -> gate IM, workflow launch binh thuong => khong over-fire, nguong
dung la >=3. Neu viet nham `if (!wave)` thieu nguong thi /fable-real 1-lane se chet oan.
CHUA VERIFY (khai that, KHONG gia vo):
14/14 spawn-probe SONG = PHAI chay SAU RESTART (registry = anh-chup khoi-phien; S120+S121 da do
2 lan xac nhan KHONG hot-reload agent MOI). Static-check KHONG du (broadcast ④d).
=> 2 vai moi hom nay moi chi TON TAI tren dia + trong VALID_ROLES, chua chung duoc SPAWN duoc.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Wave adap-6-broadcast W1 - 4 lane disjoint qua /hmw RUN-TRACE (wf_de36dea9-265, 4/4 lane 0-error).
Lead TU CHAY LAI ca 4 + tu fault-inject, KHONG tin return (gotcha #53 fire 2/2 @W0.6).
(1) governance-detectors.ps1 455->715
- GAP-3 +2 token canonical: menu=54 (STATUS.md:19); policy = row CHUA co (W2 land)
-> FAIL-LOUD + SKIP, khong im lang gia vo xanh.
- Detector H24-1 title-freshness: anchor_patterns[] = MANG 2 dang (fix C2). Bat buoc co dang
'**Status (post Session N <em-dash> YYYY-MM-DD):**' vi permission-matrix/SKILL.md
(positive-control SONG) dung dang do va KHONG co 'Last updated'. Neu 1 regex => detector
loai thang chinh positive-control cua no => W4 bat-kha-thi.
NEO-PHAM-VI load-bearing: STATUS.md:6 chua 2026-08-01 / 1987-03-07 / 2026-20-42 (cat tu
mark-id). Regex-ngay-bat-ky lay max => 2026-20-42 = ngay KHONG ton tai => moc-phai rac
=> trai<phai khong bao gio dung => 0 flag VINH VIEN ma van xanh.
- Detector H24-2 carry-age INFORM-only: M doc tu agent-memory/memory-budget.json
h24_cadence.light_every; thieu key => FAIL-LOUD, 0 so nhip hardcode.
- Bug lane tu bat: PS ten bien CASE-INSENSITIVE => $M (cadence) == $m (loop match) => ghi de
cadence => vo nhanh fail-loud. exit 0 CHE bug nay; chi stderr moi lo.
- M3 scope giu: 4 hang so owner-da-ky KHONG dung (walLineCount 40 / ratio / maxGotcha / liveVariants).
(2) agent-frontmatter-eol-check.ps1 (NEW) - HYGIENE-only
W0.6 spawn-probe @S121 do duoc CRLF-TOLERANT (agent CRLF 276 byte CR spawn an du 4 tang;
token 45248 LF vs 45240 CRLF, lech 8 = chenh chu trong prompt) => gia thuyet 'CRLF giet
registry' BI BAC => script ha cap xuong hygiene, khai that ca o header lan thong diep FLAG
runtime. Scope-chat 37 file (agents/commands/skills), KHONG repo-wide (188 = duong-gia
factory). Tu in GREEN-BUT-VACUOUS thay vi nhan cong.
(3) wal-recovery-test.ps1 (NEW) - 4/4 ca, 30 assert
FIX #3-bis: bien re nhanh = DAY RANGE, KHONG phai NONWAL. Counterfactual chay luat cu =>
tai hien DEADLOCK that voi rebase-exit=0 (hong ma bao thanh cong). Assert
sut-has-no-NONWAL-param bang Get-Command reflection, KHONG grep => ne tu-tham-chieu (W0.4#1).
(4) spawn-model-audit.ps1 (NEW) - PA-2b
FAIL-LOUD khi thieu TIER2_EXPECTED_FULL_ID (W2 chua land). Muc E liet 6 dieu no KHONG chung,
gom precedence spawn-param vs frontmatter (CHUA TEST, defer phien lead=Fable) + fix#8a chua thu.
VERIFY LEAD TU DO (khong phai so sub khai):
TOTAL FLAGS 42->49 (>=46) . permission-matrix/SKILL.md FIRE 3 dong (W4 kha thi; KHONG lane nao
cham file do) . exit 0 + stderr 0 x4 . non-ASCII 0/4 . teeth 2/2: inject 276 CR -> FLAG, go -> 0;
inject claude-opus-9-9 -> FLAG mismatch, sua -> het. Containment sach.
LOI LEAD @S121 (di vao adap-report, khong im):
(a) San-1 lech: marker wf: dang ky SAU khi phong (luat = TRUOC).
(b) Khang dinh fact-tren-dia ma KHONG do dia: lead phan 'backfill [carry:*] = orphan chua ai lam'
-> SAI, da co 7 khoa tu 4727d16 (S119, da push). Co che: ra BANG WAVE thay khong ai duoc
giao => suy ra chua lam. 'Khong wave nao so huu' != 'chua co tren dia'. Brief lead co 4 tien
de sai (config path / acceptance ngay 07-14 vs that 07-15 / carry / do-dai); lane (1) do dia va va het.
GAP THAT thay claim sai (lane 1 tim, lead verify dia): carry-age vacuous vi CAU TRUC - 45
logic-segment nhung carry-lines=1 => streak==1 => 0 fire vinh vien ke ca sau W2. Lo = thieu nghi
thuc RE-STAMP moi phien => giao W3 session-end.md, KHONG phai W2.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
W0.6 = bao-dam falsifiable DUY NHAT cua ca wave (broadcast 4(d): "moi kiem static-text deu
KHONG falsifiable; chi spawn-probe / assert-registry moi that-su chung-minh").
LECH SPEC CO CHU-DICH - spec v2 W0.6 chi dung 1 probe (CRLF) -> RESTART -> spawn. LO: neu spawn
FAIL, quan-sat do KHONG phan-biet duoc 2 gia-thuyet: "reader LF-only nen chet" vs "registry chua
nap file moi". Mot quan-sat, hai gia-thuyet => vo-nghia.
VA: dung them _lf-probe.md GIONG HET, khac DUNG 1 BIEN = line-ending.
CRLF ok + LF ok -> CRLF-tolerant (khoi restart)
CRLF x + LF ok -> CRLF-fatal CHAC-CHAN (LF chung-minh hot-reload CO chay)
CRLF x + LF x -> hot-reload KHONG chay -> chi nhanh nay moi can RESTART
Kiem bien don (soi byte, khong tin sed): _crlf-probe CR=276 LF=276 ; _lf-probe CR=0 LF=276 ;
od -c xac nhan "- - - \r \n n a m e : _ c r l f - p r o b e \r \n" ;
diff <(bo CR, bo dong name:) 2 file -> GIONG HET => bien duy-nhat = line-ending.
LUOT-1 (TRUOC restart) = nhanh 3: CA 2 probe not-found. Available list = 19 sub + plugin co
tu dau phien, khong co probe nao.
>>> NHOM CHUNG CUU 1 KET-LUAN SAI: _lf-probe THUAN LF (0 byte CR) cung chet y het => nguyen-nhan
KHONG PHAI CRLF. Neu lam dung spec (1 probe), lead se thay _crlf-probe chet va rat de ket-luan
"CRLF-fatal" - SAI, va sai THEO HUONG CO LOI cho cau chuyen (xac nhan L3 + giu R4 nac manh).
DO DUOC (moi, S120): registry agent = ANH-CHUP luc khoi phien; KHONG hot-reload agent file MOI.
Doi-chieu memory project_harness4_two_tier_model: ghi "agent file MOI = hot-reload OK" (verified
S107) KEM canh-bao ENV-DEPENDENT (hub ra ket-qua NGUOC S110). S120 do KHONG hot-reload => canh-bao
ENV-DEP xac-nhan lan nua, lan nay ngay trong repo SE. Cau "nghi ngo -> restart" cua memory = DUNG.
=> de-nghi thu hep memory o session-end: "hot-reload agent-file-moi = ENV-DEP, SE do KHONG an @S120".
2 probe = UNTRACKED CO Y. CAM `git add` - `.gitattributes` `* text=auto eol=lf` se NORMALIZE
mat CR = giet thi-nghiem. Hook khong phu .claude/agents/ nen khong tu commit.
WAL: ghim 3 buoc sau restart (LF TRUOC -> CRLF sau -> xoa 2 probe), + verify lenh kiem 276 CR
con nguyen. Day range hien = commit thuong 92de58f => moi wal: sinh sau roi ca(3) an-toan @W6.
0 prod-code, 0 migration, 0 FE, 0 test-change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
W0.4 workflows/README.md - go claim STALE dang CHE San-1:
- Ban cu tuyen SE "tailored-out" khoi lop anti-bypass detector + coi mat-lach gan-nhu-khong-co.
BI BAC x3 BANG SU-KIEN (khong phai ly-le):
(i) S72 RECURRED: chay REVIEW qua raw Workflow tool -> khong inject writeGuard -> reviewer
tu ghi MEMORY +2850B over-cap -> git-status bat @session-end + revert. Nguyen-van
feedback_harness10_run_trace.md:20 "dung RAW Workflow tool = MAT governance project-wrapper".
(ii) S118 raw-Agent 7-spawn -> 0 run-folder (viec rot khoi so).
(iii) CHINH run S119 di raw Workflow tool.
- Ban moi khai 3 DUONG phong, chi 1 gate duoc: /ultra-on->hmw.js (gate) | raw Workflow (KHONG)
| raw Agent (KHONG). + khai KE CON-LAI: lach o SE KHONG can CLI-launcher, goi thang tool
harness la xong => 3 nguyen-tac detector (whitelist launcher / path-variant / anchor launch-key)
N/A VI KHONG CO LAUNCHER DE WHITELIST, khong phai vi "khong co ke". Containment THAT =
em-main single-writer + git-diff + chunk-count = PHAT-HIEN-SAU, KHONG NGAN-CHAN-TRUOC (G-015).
- Neu de nguyen claim cu: co "tailored-out" se (sai) bien-minh cho viec skip luon San-1 (F2 v1).
W0.5 baseline orphan - FIX#4 (bo mtime, dung git log %cI):
- Moc closeout cuoi = 3fde8af @ 2026-07-14T16:29:55+07.
- 3 phep do doi chung: naive(chi flat)=13 | dual-accept(+harvest/)=8 | dual+scoped(%cI>moc)=1={S119}.
- Khop CHINH XAC du-bao FIX#4 (13 / 8 / {S119}). Chenh 13-8 = 5 folder S71 h10/h910 dung
harvest/<stage>-synthesis.md -> KHONG duoc flag (C8 README:19). Chenh 8-1 = 7 ton-dong cu
-> loai bang SCOPE, KHONG tao *-synthesis.md gia (Goodhart, R3 flag).
- {S119} bi flag la DUNG: run chua dong, se dong o W6 khi co synthesis that.
- REGRESSED da va: v2 chot scope theo mtime; Dropbox resync GHI DE mtime => khong ben (R3-m5).
W0-evidence-15-07-2026.md - capture stdout THAT vao run-folder (fix #9c: bang-chung
time-anchored thay "reviewer chung-kien" lam neo duy-nhat). Gom: ground-truth /tiep 3 cho stale
+ W0.0-W0.5 so do + 2 fault-inject + nac trung-thuc.
2 LOI LEAD TU MAC o W0.4 (ghi vao evidence, di nguyen vao adap-report, KHONG im):
1. Gate tu-tham-chieu: lead trich NGUYEN-VAN claim cu lam bang-chung -> grep bat trung chinh
cau trich -> FAIL tren ban sua DUNG. Roi lead viet LITERAL mau regex cua gate vao ghi-chu
-> mau tu khop chinh no -> FAIL lan 2. => gate grep-chuoi chay tren chinh file no kiem =
TU-THAM-CHIEU, can neo bang dau-hieu khac. Cung ho R2-C1.
2. Meta-count tai-pham: bang tong-ket cua lead IN SAN chu "PASS" trong khi phep do ngay canh
tra "1 hit" = FAIL. Dung lop v3 §Nac-trung-thuc "lead DO tot; lead DEM VE CHINH MINH thi sai".
=> pass/fail phai TINH tu so do, cam in nhan cung. Da ap dung o lan do lai.
0 prod-code, 0 migration, 0 FE, 0 test-change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
W0.1 .gitattributes theo CLASS (khong va theo duoi-file-vua-can):
- `* text=auto eol=lf` = san chung. core.autocrlf=true @system lat LF->CRLF luc checkout;
attr nay ep blob LF + worktree LF, DOC-LAP autocrlf.
- Khai binary TUONG-MINH 13 duoi (zip/exe/dll/docx/xlsx/pptx/pdf/png/jpg/jpeg/ico/woff/woff2)
thay vi pho-thac heuristic NUL-byte-8000-dau: .docx "gay" co the lot thanh text -> mangle
OOXML -> hong file KHONG cuu duoc. Do that: repo co 19 binary (12 docx + 6 png + 1 xlsx).
- .svg = XML -> CO Y giu text. Giu 2 rule cu (broadcasts/** + *.sh) tuong-minh.
- Fault-inject chung rule CO RANG: go `*.docx binary` -> git coi .docx la `text: auto` (nguy
hiem that); khoi phuc -> `text: unset`. 19/19 binary co attr/-text.
- Acceptance PASS: agents/reviewer.md unspecified -> text:auto eol:lf.
W0.2 scoped-only (vacuous, KHAI THAT):
- scope-gate (agents+commands+skills) = 0 DA XANH SAN truoc khi lam gi -> KHONG tinh la thanh-tuu.
- repo-wide 188 (131 Migrations + 57 con lai) = INFORM-only. CAM mass rm+checkout phien nay.
- `git add --renormalize --dry-run .` = 0 file dirty; `git diff --cached --stat` = rong.
W0.3 hook rebase-interlock (anh ky S119 fix#8b = TRONG KHUNG, khong can adap-request):
- wal-flush.ps1: `if (Test-Path .git/rebase-merge -or .git/rebase-apply) { exit 0 }`.
- Dat SAU Set-Location $root, KHONG phai dau file: dat truoc thi Test-Path soi nham CWD.
- Chung RANG 2 CHIEU tren cay tam: (a) khong rebase-state -> hook VAN commit (guard khong
over-fire, WAL persist con song); (b) co rebase-state -> 0 commit, exit 0, worktree GIU dirty.
- Pure-ASCII giu nguyen (gotcha #30). Do lai bang tr sau khi phat hien `grep -P` false-pass
(loi locale -> output rong -> wc -l dem 0 = grep CHET, khong phai sach).
FIX #3-bis (MOI, ghi vao v3-PATCH) - dieu-kien re nhanh W0.3 test SAI THU:
- v2:92 re nhanh bang `NONWAL==0`; luat fix#3(c) noi phai test "wal: o DAY range". Hai thu khac nhau.
- Fault-inject 4 cay tam chung diem re o ca2 (shape base|wal:|[CLAUDE], NONWAL=1, day=wal:):
v2 -> nhanh-B REBASE; v3bis -> reset--soft. Chay that nhanh-B tren ca2: REBASE-EXIT=0 KHONG
crash, nhung commit gop THUA KE message "wal: flush 1" -> push-guard n=1 -> chan push ->
re-squash cung logic -> van "wal:" -> STOP VINH VIEN. Deadlock XAC NHAN bang thuc nghiem.
- +ca(0) MOI v2/v3 khong liet: K=0 range RONG (S119 da push 4727d16) -> NO-OP commit thang.
- 4 ca: (0) K=0 NO-OP · (1) day=wal: NONWAL=0 · (2) day=wal: NONWAL>0 -> (1)+(2) CUNG xu-ly
reset--soft origin/main CAM rebase · (3) day=commit-thuong -> rebase+fixup OK.
- Ca fire hom nay = ca(0). Commit-chot nay dat day range = commit thuong -> moi wal: sinh sau
deu roi vao ca(3) an-toan. Dung y do fix#3(a).
WAL reconcile (/tiep S120): ground-truth thang WAL 3 cho - (1) 7 broadcast "UNTRACKED co y"
da tracked+pushed trong 4727d16, W0.3 khong con viec gop; (2) "K troi 10->11" -> thuc te K=0
range RONG; (3) fix#8 tick mau-thuan -> owner-decisions xac nhan DA KY, gate-blocker=0.
0 prod-code, 0 migration, 0 FE, 0 test-change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Lo hong (reviewer S118 phat hien khi phan quyen PRO tra.bui): ReportsController chi co
[Authorize] tran (khong policy) -> MOI user dang nhap goi duoc GET /reports/dashboard (tong gia
tri HD dang chay, top NCC/du an theo gia tri, xu huong 12 thang) + GET /reports/contracts/export
(xuat toan bo HD ra Excel). Nguoc quyet dinh S92 "HD chi Admin thay" (menu an nhung API van mo,
go URL/API truc tiep lay duoc).
Fix (owner chot: chi Admin qua Reports.Read policy -- linh hoat mo role khac qua ma tran sau):
- Dashboard() + ExportContracts() -> them [Authorize(Policy = "Reports.Read")] per-method. Hien
chi Admin co Reports.Read -> non-admin 403. Admin bypass moi policy nhu cu.
- MyDashboard() GIU MO (chi [Authorize] class-level) -- scope theo currentUser, moi user chi thay
so cua CHINH MINH (draft/pending/SLA/gia tri draft cua minh), khong lo toan cong ty.
Test: +4 reflection authz regression (AuthorizePolicyRegressionTests, mirror gotcha #44 S45):
dashboard/export co Reports.Read; my-dashboard KHONG co action-policy (guard chong ai khoa nham
dashboard ca nhan). 505 -> 509. Gotcha #82 (menu-flag grant != quyen API that).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Van de (UAT anh Kiet FDC, S118): user tra.bui (Bui Le Thuy Tra, Procurement TP) dang nhap khong
thay menu quan ly NCC/Suppliers. Nguyen nhan: seeder S92 RevokeTemporarilyHiddenModulesAsync (chay
moi startup) set CanRead=false cho Master/Suppliers/Projects/Departments/Catalog* voi moi role
non-Admin ("chi Admin thay").
Fix (owner chot mo ngoai-le CHI role Procurement, ben qua deploy):
- Them SeedProcurementMasterAccessAsync chay NGAY SAU revoke de THANG (mirror pattern Hrm S65 /
Office S69). Chi dung role Procurement -- S92 "chi Admin thay" GIU NGUYEN cho moi role khac.
- Grant 9 key: Suppliers (R+C+U -- quan ly + cong bo NCC, S113 publish can Suppliers.Update);
Master/Projects/Departments/Catalogs + 4 Catalog leaf (Read-only). KHONG Delete.
- Dashboard/Reports CO Y KHONG cap (reviewer bat: Reports lo tong gia tri HD + top NCC/du an theo
gia tri, nguoc S92; owner chot bo).
- Upgrade-only idempotent: nang co desired len true, khong ha co, khong dung role khac.
Test: +4 regression scope-isolation (ProcurementMasterAccessSeedTests) -- Procurement duoc nang
dung ma tran, role khac (DeptManager rieng) VAN bi revoke. 501 -> 505.
Reviewer PASS (scope cach-ly sach, no over-grant). Grant tam da ap prod (tra.bui verified 20 menu);
deploy nay = ban ben. Follow-up: gate ReportsController thieu policy (task rieng).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Hai chỉnh từ buổi UAT anh Kiệt FDC (S117):
1) Fix hiển thị lũy kế "duyệt rồi không bắt" — root cause là DISPLAY-LIE, không phải
lũy kế bug. endsBeforeCeo cho phiếu CHƯA DaDuyet nay POINTER-AWARE: chỉ báo "kết
thúc trước CEO" khi con-trỏ còn ở/trước cấp finalize. Phiếu đã đi QUA cấp finalize
(approver bỏ tick "Cấp này KẾT THÚC" → trình tiếp CEO) → false: sơ đồ hết làm mờ
Bước CEO + hết nói dối "Kết thúc tại Cấp X" khi phiếu đang chờ CEO. 3 site (detail
in-memory + list/inbox EF-subquery). Filter lũy kế GIỮ nguyên (đúng nguyên tắc
"duyệt rồi mới bắc"). BE-only — FE là consumer thuần nên tự render đúng.
2) Feature "duyệt theo KHOẢNG Min–Max": khi PRO có cả Min & Max, người duyệt cấp cuối
chọn CẢ HAI (radio "PRO — cả Min và Max", source=ProMinMax) → Min ở ApprovedPriceAmount
+ Max ở ApprovedPriceMaxAmount (Mig 66 AddColumn nullable, no backfill, phiếu cũ
nguyên vẹn). Bất-biến Max⟺ProMinMax, Min≤Max (guard ở service + validator). HĐ.GiaTri
KHÔNG đọc giá chốt (= SUM báo giá NCC được chọn) → range thuần record-of-decision
hiển thị, 0 tác động HĐ. FE 2-app SHA-mirror (Panel + DetailTabs).
Test 495 → 501 (+1 pointer-aware repro, +5 ProMinMax). Cả 2 điều tra qua /fable-real
engine-đắt (investigator-codebase deep-pass) theo yêu cầu anh Kiệt.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Runtime-verify H-22 WAL session-continuity qua restart may that (S116):
/tiep no-op-detect + /session-end no-op-closeout PASS. Reviewer-gated
(return-garble #53 recovered via SendMessage-resume). Honest caveat:
WAL rong -> chi verify persist-file + no-op + idempotent, CHUA content-recovery.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
