vietreport-admin/solution-erp
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
e7e99d10f2358b707d0a33b3842ba90455d26e6d
solution-erp/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-06-18-mig54-pe-review/run.md
pqhuy1987 e7e99d10f2 [CLAUDE] Docs: S73 closeout — Mig 54 PE gia de xuat + CCM duyet-done (STATUS/HANDOFF/session-log + review run-trace + agent-memory harvest) 
- STATUS/HANDOFF S73: Mig 54 · test 334 · bundle Bv3jUCNo/BWlMBQz6 (Run #313 feature + #314 fix)
- session log 2026-06-18-S73-pe-gia-de-xuat-ccm-done.md
- run-trace runs/2026-06-18-mig54-pe-review (custom-inline review, bu post-hoc) + _ledger 2 row (R1 schema 1/4 + R2 free-text 2/3)
- agent-memory flush 5 sub + reconcile implementer-frontend cwd-misland stray -> canonical

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-18 16:32:41 +07:00

2.5 KiB
Raw Blame History

RUN — Mig 54 PE giá-đề-xuất + CCM duyệt-done · ADVERSARIAL REVIEW (custom inline)

  • run-id (folder): 2026-06-18-mig54-pe-review
  • workflow run-id (evidence): wf_8c979a93-1a4
  • type: ⚠️ CUSTOM INLINE Workflow (KHÔNG dùng hmw.js RUN-TRACE) — agents trả structured schema data, KHÔNG ghi sub-*.md. Em-main viết run.md + review-synthesis.md POST-HOC (anh chốt "custom OK, miễn ghi MD"). Vì author inline nên KHÔNG có run-trace tự-scaffold @P1 — đây là bù vết kiểm sau.
  • checkpoint: APPROVED (anh yêu cầu "workflow cho nhanh")
  • opened: 2026-06-18 ~15:55 +07 (post-hoc — workflow đã chạy xong khi ghi)
  • closed: 2026-06-18 ~16:05 +07
  • target: commit 1d86abc (Mig 54) — pre-UAT financial review, go-live thứ Hai 22/06
  • status: CLOSED

Agents (4× reviewer adversarial ∥, schema-forced) + verify-chéo

dim lens KẾT QUẢ
be-logic ApproveV2 ③ opt-in + ① bind giá + V1/skipToFinal ✅ RETURNED — PASS, 2 finding (đều not-an-issue/nit sau verify-chéo)
authz-security 2 setter fail-closed + CCM bypass CEO ❌ FAILED — subagent KHÔNG gọi StructuredOutput (2 nudge) → 0 kết quả
cross-stack-wire 7-layer thread + FE "duyệt cuối" derive (rủi ro #1) ❌ FAILED — no StructuredOutput → 0 kết quả
regression-edge AUTO→OPT-IN in-flight + Mig nullable + DTO order ❌ FAILED — no StructuredOutput → 0 kết quả

Honest outcome

  • 3/4 lane FAILED — đúng flakiness đã ghi feedback_workflow_fanout_reliability (schema-forced agents hay không gọi StructuredOutput trong harness này). Tổng 10 agent / 966K token / 198 tool-use, nhưng chỉ be-logic trả structured.
  • be-logic = PASS, 0 blocker / 0 major. 2 finding verify-chéo: (1) V1 legacy không bind giá = BY DESIGN (nullable, KHÔNG feed CreateContractFromEvaluation.GiaTri — giá HĐ = SUM Details.ThanhTienNganSach) · (2) stray fe-user/.claude/ = nit (commit 1d86abc đã verify SẠCH).
  • 3 lane CHƯA review độc-lập → em-main self-gate (xem review-synthesis.md §B). Verdict tổng: không blocker; 1 UAT-note (empty-candidates UX edge).
  • Bài học (ghi cho session sau): review fan-out NÊN dùng free-text return (Agent-tool) thay schema-forced Workflow — schema-force = nguyên nhân 3/4 fail. HOẶC dùng hmw.js RUN-TRACE (sub ghi file, không phụ thuộc StructuredOutput).