vietreport-admin/solution-erp
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
dfde1acbd03d31f93ec4d12d640456a6b3c7bf51
solution-erp/docs/governance/adap-reports/2026-06-19-Governance-architecture-decision-rationality-rc-signature.md
pqhuy1987 33d519eda0 [CLAUDE] Docs: adopt User-Mark (H-12/13 canonical §P) + Harness-14 + RC-signature (S79) 
Áp canonical §P đầy-đủ (P1-P10) khi anh gõ /user-mark-active-high "áp đầy-đủ
chính-xác nhất theo AI_INFRA". 0 production code.

- 4 lệnh /user-mark-{active-high,active,medium,disable} (DACI report-before-stamp)
- ledger .claude/governance/ACTIVE-MARKS.md (4 cấp Active-High/Active/Medium/Disable
  + display-filter) + 3 mark Active-High stamped anh-confirm
  (RC-pqhuy1987-20-06-2026-10-29-09/10/11 = objective-criteria/User-Mark/time-age)
- harness-11-engine.md §E (P1-P10) + §F (Harness-14 3-mức maturity honest)
- rules.md §6.6 objective-criteria (KHÔNG quy-mô-đội / KHÔNG thời-gian-tuổi)
- session-start §2.1.4 + session-end §L.b(h) mark-display
- 4 Workflow: invest wf_82337f7f-95c + review wf_a7cbe93e-912
  + align-re-review wf_9d3beebb-a95 (§P 10/10) + H14-review wf_4d4eba6f-8a0 (§F 6/6)
- completeness-gate H-6→H-13 ĐẠT (H-8 11/11 inherit no-[1m])
- 3 adap-report + email ai_infra (7b8615b3) + check-email STAGE 2

State THẬT GIỮ NGUYÊN: Mig 57 · 88 bảng · 354 test · gotcha 71 · bundle CsJetgZH/BVS0ApIm.
Restart CLI để activate 4 lệnh + session-cmd (no hot-reload).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-20 10:53:23 +07:00

4.1 KiB
Raw Blame History

adap-report — Architecture-decision rationality + RC-signature (tiêu-chí khách-quan + chữ-ký niêm)

  • id: 2026-06-19-Governance-architecture-decision-rationality-rc-signature
  • source broadcast: ai_infra/broadcasts/outbox/all/2026-06-19-Governance-architecture-decision-rationality-rc-signature.md (reviewer_gate: PASS · content_sha256: 4deb7876514686155c389cc8b9cf636855aae4fb0e75369de9b9947a83f32cd5)
  • adopted by: se (SOLUTION_ERP) · session: S79 · date: 2026-06-20
  • protocol: Harness-9 PART-2 mandate = workflow IMPLEMENT + REVIEW tách biệt + report-with-run-id
    • INVESTIGATE wf_82337f7f-95c (3× investigator-codebase — governance-landing map + completeness-gate H-6→H-13 + budget audit) → IMPLEMENT em-main single-writer (governance D9) → REVIEW wf_a7cbe93e-912 (3× reviewer, floor 10/10) → canonical-align re-REVIEW wf_9d3beebb-a95 (2× reviewer — §P P1-P10 fidelity PASS + drift PASS)
  • project-fit: ✅ FIT — SE = solo-dev (chính đối-tượng dễ mắc lỗi "quá mức solo-dev") + có governance engine 11-agent cần kỷ-luật quyết-định.

VERDICT: ✅ ADOPTED — 2 nguyên-tắc codify, mark Active-High stamped (anh-confirm S79)

Broadcast có 2 nguyên-tắc: (1) quyết-định kiến-trúc = tiêu-chí khách-quan (điểm-đau + khối-lượng + chất-lượng) KHÔNG quy-mô-đội; (2) chữ-ký niêm RC-pqhuy1987-dd-mm-yyyy-hh-mm-ss cho mỗi rule-change. Cả 2 codify vào canonical SE + neo bằng User-Mark.

Nấc (executed-file vs runtime · mechanized vs convention)

Phần Trạng-thái Nấc
Nguyên-tắc 1 — objective-criteria rules.md §6.6 (bảng "Căn-cứ SAI" quy-mô-đội + AI=neo-lý-tính + thẩm-quyền cross-project) + engine §E.5/P10 executed-file · convention (kỷ-luật quyết-định)
Nguyên-tắc 2 — RC-signature format RC-pqhuy1987-dd-mm-yyyy-hh-mm-ss REUSE (KHÔNG redefine) ở ACTIVE-MARKS.md + engine §E.1/P1 + rules §6.6; forward-only no-retrofit executed-file · convention
Mark Active-High RC-pqhuy1987-20-06-2026-10-29-09 (objective-criteria) stamped, anh-confirm S79 via report-before-stamp executed-file (owner-confirmed)

Tailoring (SE-specific)

  • §-anchor SE = rules.md §6.6 + engine §E (≙ AI_INFRA §F4.2) — notation (≙ AI_INFRA) giữ traceability cross-project, KHÔNG mượn §-number bên phát.
  • Chữ-ký RC + objective-criteria neo qua User-Mark canonical §P (xem report 2026-06-19-Governance-harness-all-update) — cùng cụm cơ-chế.
  • SE stamp timestamp RIÊNG 20-06-2026-10-29-09 (P1 forward-only: mỗi dự-án ký lúc sign-off của mình), KHÔNG copy timestamp AI_INFRA.

Honest caveats (KHÔNG nói quá)

  • objective-criteria = convention (kỷ-luật người+AI), KHÔNG mechanized — đừng nhận "công-cụ-ép".
  • RC-signature stamp = executed-file owner-confirmed (anh xác-nhận trong session qua "áp dụng đầy đủ chính xác nhất, không hỏi thêm"); chưa runtime-tested qua nhiều session.

Reverse-findings (đề-xuất ngược AI_INFRA)

  1. 2-channel enforcement ⊂ cái SE đã chứng-minh empirically — broadcast trình "tool-action → permission-config NOT hook" như nguyên-tắc; SE đã có bằng-chứng SỐNG E-006/AS-10 (error-ledger.md): hook fails-open → store_memory allowlist-strip = gate THẬT. Xác-nhận nguyên-tắc đúng + đã được thực-chứng ở sister.
  2. objective-criteria rule ⊃ rule team-size cũ — SE map "time/age" (H-14) + "team-size" vào CÙNG bảng "Căn-cứ SAI" (rules §6.6) = trình-bày 1-họ-lỗi gọn hơn 2 rule rời. Đề-xuất AI_INFRA cân-nhắc gom trình-bày tương-tự.

Evidence

  • run-id: wf_82337f7f-95c (investigate) · wf_a7cbe93e-912 (review) · wf_9d3beebb-a95 (canonical-align re-review, §P 10/10 + drift PASS).
  • Mark stamped: ACTIVE-MARKS.md 🔴 ACTIVE-HIGH RC-pqhuy1987-20-06-2026-10-29-09.
  • 0 production code — governance-only. State THẬT GIỮ NGUYÊN: Mig 57 · 88 bảng · 354 test · gotcha 71 · bundle CsJetgZH/BVS0ApIm.