e70c0462d7
- engine-doc canonical docs/governance/harness-11-engine.md (PHẦN A/B/C/D + 3-tier D5/D6/D7 + one-direction-lock D8 + CAVEAT honest) - scripts/governance-detectors.ps1 (C1 broken-pointer + C2/B3 staleness + C3 vocab-fork + C4 self-exclusion + C5 resolve, NO-API DÒ+FLAG-only, runtime-proven, FP-refined 59→27) - scripts/memory-archive-gate.ps1 (PHẦN A: hysteresis 0.85 + keep-floor 5 + 2-strike + A7 NO-API L1-eval) + budget.json archive_gate - B1 ×11 count→canonical-pointer (root CLAUDE.md, ef-core/dep-audit SKILL, skills/README, docs/CLAUDE.md) — drift mig53→55/test306→339/gotcha68→69 RESOLVED + ef-core +Mig 54/55 rows - cadence-wire D1 session-start §2.1.3 + D2 session-end §L.b(c) + agents/README Upgrade S75 - run-trace TRACKED: audit wf_7fdc3bd5-930 / implement wf_c5e5844e-7c1 / review wf_d7ca1ff8-942 (REVIEW PASS, completeness-gate ĐẠT) - check-email AI_INFRA harness-11 (verify whole-file 318ff9f6 + body b2a2fc1c) + adap-report + outbox report (body 7fa1b53a) - 0 production code; state THẬT giữ nguyên (Mig 55 · 88 bảng · 339 test · gotcha 69 · menu 54 · bundle BYF5vIMJ/CB-tiRxd) Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
38 lines
4.2 KiB
Markdown
38 lines
4.2 KiB
Markdown
# REVIEW SYNTHESIS — Harness-11 adap (2026-06-18-h11-review · `wf_d7ca1ff8-942`)
|
||
|
||
> 3× reviewer (read-only, adversarial ∥). Em-main scribe @P3. **VERDICT TỔNG: ✅ PASS** (0 blocker · refinement applied · nit fixed).
|
||
|
||
## R1 — COMPLETENESS-GATE → **ĐẠT** (B+C+D function-floor đủ-trọn)
|
||
- **PHẦN B 4/4 PRESENT:** B1 (engine:39 + landed root CLAUDE.md 7 pointer + ef-core 4 + README 2 + dep-audit 1) · B2 (readable giữ) · B3 (script:142-243 LIVE-catch, KHÔNG stub) · B4 (em-main gated + git-diff backstop).
|
||
- **PHẦN C 5/5 runtime-proven:** C1 (0 gotcha-dangling + wikilink-dangling) · C2 (canonical+disk cross-check OK) · C3 (3 vocab-fork) · C4 (**0 self-match LIVE**, 5 paths excluded, leaked=0) · C5 (100% flag có resolve:).
|
||
- **PHẦN D 11/11:** D1 wired §2.1.3 · D2 wired §L.b(c) · D3 · D4 (hmw.js:76 THROW mechanized) · **D5/D6/D7 3-tier EXPLICIT** (engine §D.2 :67-69) · **D8 one-direction-lock codify** (:72) · D9 · D10 · D11.
|
||
- **PHẦN A 🟡 over-floor:** A4/A5/A6/A7 runtime-proven.
|
||
- **HARDEST gate: NO-API PASS · 0-auto-write PASS.** 0 floor thiếu.
|
||
|
||
## R2 — DETECTOR CORRECTNESS+QUALITY → **PASS** (6/6 mechanized criteria clean)
|
||
- C4 0-self-match ✓ · C5 59/59 resolve ✓ · NO-API grep 0-hit ✓ · 0-auto-write (chỉ Out-Null in-mem) ✓ · DRY-RUN no-write (git pre==post byte-identical) ✓ · A7 186/186 pointer-resolve + byte-sanity ✓.
|
||
- **2 refinement non-blocking → ÁP DỤNG (review→fix loop):**
|
||
- **(7a) C2 FP-rate ~89% (24/27 FP):** version-token "EF Core 10" / per-row "N bảng module" / historical "154 test". → **FIXED:** context-skip (table-row `^\s*\|` + historical `baseline|S\d\d|(current` + version-prefix `core|.net|react|vite|mig|phase|session`). C2 **27→11**.
|
||
- **(7b) C1 wikilink 29 = REAL (KHÔNG normalization-FP):** 3 class (hyphen↔underscore-fork · truly-missing · cross-scope). → **FIXED:** normalize `[-_]` both sides → auto-resolve fork-where-file-exists. C1 **29→13** (13 còn lại = genuinely-missing/cross-scope, drift THẬT của memory-index).
|
||
- **Post-refinement: TOTAL 59→27, PS parse OK, C4 vẫn 0 self-match.** Detector từ "noisy" → "sắc".
|
||
|
||
## R3 — HONESTY+CONTAINMENT → **PASS** (0 blocker, 1 MINOR nit)
|
||
- OVER-CLAIM: none-material. Re-run cả 2 script khớp claim. Nấc executed-file vs runtime phân ĐÚNG (A6-2strike tự-khai executed-file; A7/DRY-RUN tick runtime). 71→59 reconcile honest (pre-B1 vs post-B1, grep CLAUDE.md `53 migration`=0 chứng-minh B1 gỡ TP).
|
||
- SINGLE-WRITER D9: git-status grep MEMORY.md = 0-hit · `.archive-strikes.json` absent · budget.json additive-only · 0 sub đụng canonical. CLEAN (KHÔNG lặp S72 residual).
|
||
- NO-AUTO-WRITE-OF-LAW (D6): detector 0 file-write stdout-only · archive-gate 1 Set-Content → counter `.archive-strikes.json` (-Apply-only, KHÔNG MD/luật). ✓
|
||
- B1 GATED (B4): sub KHÔNG tự sửa canonical, em-main cluster. ✓
|
||
- byte-0-loss D11: A7 verify pointer-resolve + nonzero-size (MOVE thật engine CỐ Ý không làm — DRY-RUN; D11 dựa precedent h910-curate md5sum). Phân-định đúng, KHÔNG over-claim.
|
||
- CAVEAT engine-doc:79-84 trung-thực (no-OS-hook + auto-write-CỐ-Ý-CHƯA-LÀM + net-not-lock + executed≠runtime).
|
||
- **MINOR nit → FIXED:** agents/README "71 flag" = volatile-count hardcoded (chính anti-pattern engine chống) → đổi non-volatile.
|
||
|
||
## Em-main actions post-review
|
||
1. ✅ C2 context-skip + C1 normalize (script refinement, re-run 59→27, parse OK).
|
||
2. ✅ agents/README "71 flag" → non-volatile (số → run-trace).
|
||
3. ✅ reconcile số trong synthesis/ledger (71 pre-B1 → 59 post-B1 → 27 post-refinement).
|
||
|
||
## Honest residual (cho report AI_INFRA)
|
||
- C1 13 wikilink-dangling = REAL pre-existing memory-index drift (engine SURFACE đúng; fix từng cái = chore riêng, KHÔNG block adap).
|
||
- C2 11 residual = module-local edge ("4 bảng Budget" historical, "1 migration" prose revert-cmd) — soft-net chấp-nhận (LOW/MED advisory exit-0, self-documented).
|
||
- C3 console mojibake VN-variant = cosmetic Bash-capture (match THẬT đúng, gotcha #30 code-point builder hoạt-động).
|
||
- **VERDICT: PASS — engine adopted, completeness-gate ĐẠT, detector sharp + runtime-proven, containment clean.**
|