All checks were successful
Deploy SOLUTION_ERP / build-deploy (push) Successful in 5m23s
FINALIZE review wf_73de399d-753 (3 reviewer, R1/R2 no-StructuredOutput->self-gate, R3 thorough): audit 21 checklist item A1-A9/B1-B4/C1-C8 on-disk = 0 code-defect, adoption SOUND, 3 deferred-gap. Closed: G1 curate wf_f32987b8-03f (reviewer 36.7->24.8KB + investigator 29.8->23.2KB <25600 cap, archive +N -0 0-byte-loss, +reviewer-gist gen:2, budget.json re-measure) + G2 (2 stale user-memory claims) + G3 (feedback_harness10_run_trace.md new) + minor (gitignore check-ignore exit-trap corrected). Race root-cause fixed structurally. State unchanged (Mig 53/88 tables/306 test). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2.7 KiB
2.7 KiB
FINALIZE synthesis — H-9 + H-10 + checklist full audit (em-main single-writer, C4)
Workflow
wf_73de399d-753· 3 reviewer. R1 (Part A) + R2 (Part B+C) no-StructuredOutput ×2-nudge → self-gate (patternfeedback_agent_kill_recovery). R3 (cross-cutting) thorough — audit luôn Part A/B/C items → đủ coverage (+ H2 bootstrap + self-verify S71 trước).
Verdict: GAPS-FOUND — 0 defect/bug/over-claim-in-code; adoption SOUND. Findings = deferred-incompleteness cần đóng.
COMPLETE (verified-on-disk, R3)
- Containment model đồng-bộ MỌI file (4 owning + agents/README:111/:162 + harvest-curator:52 + tooling-auditor + session-end:51 + session-start:71) — 0 file giữ B6 cũ. agents/README:8 = frozen 06-07 chronology (acceptable).
- Frozen-evidence byte-intact (git diff f36aab8^..HEAD: broadcasts/_index additive 2 row, harness-2/error-ledger/sessions KHÔNG touched).
- Part C: run-folder 3-phần ×4 · gitignore (runs NOT-IGNORED / wave-*+teams IGNORED / ls-files 14) · hmw.js engine (node --check OK) · C7 caveat đủ 4 trục.
- Part B: 3 run-id evidenced · review-workflow bắt C5 L1 (validate mandate B2). Part A: floor intact (budget/measure-script/_INDEX/gist/ragignore/session-start §2.1.2).
- Category 6: email full-grammar VN, hash MATCH, honest self-disclose.
GAPS (hoàn chỉnh)
- G1 HIGH: reviewer/MEMORY.md 33782B (>30720 soft + >25600 auto-inject — harness đã truncate ~8KB HOT lúc spawn này) + investigator-codebase/MEMORY.md 29819B (>25600). Root: S71 same-role race append. budget.json
measuredSTALE (S70 snapshot 24795/24052). Harness-9 claim "4 <25KB" re-violated. → re-measure + curate L1→L2 (verbatim→archive, _INDEX, gist distill-gen bump) đến <25600. Acceptance: wc -c <25600 + numstat archive +N -0. - G2 MED: (a)
feedback_harness9_l2_recovery_2workflow_adap.md:14"cả 4 <25KB (đóng P1)" FALSE → note re-opened S71 + re-closed sau G1. (b)feedback_harness_123_adoption.md:13wave-folder presented operative → mark SUPERSEDED-by-Harness-10. - G3 MED: thêm
feedback_harness10_run_trace.md(run-trace supersedes wave + containment flip + 3 lesson: engine-no-fs→em-main-scaffold-fragile-C2 · custom-workflow-must-copy-return-delta-guard · check-ignore-exit-trap-CORRECTED) + index pointer + link feedback_harness9_l2_recovery_2workflow_adap. - MINOR: gitignore:96-98 exit-trap explanation imprecise ("exits 0 for BOTH" — thực: plain check-ignore exit 1 cho negation; chỉ
-v --no-indexmới 0-both). Command vẫn đúng. Fix khi touch (em fix luôn). Email frozen — KHÔNG sửa.