Files
solution-erp/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-06-18-harness-fix-review/review-synthesis.md
pqhuy1987 18fced6695
All checks were successful
Deploy SOLUTION_ERP / build-deploy (push) Successful in 5m16s
[CLAUDE] Workflow: adopt Harness-10 flat-refine + checklist-v2 + sleep-recovery-cmd (re-audit 3-workflow)
Re-audit Harness-8/9/10/10-refine + checklist v1/v2 + hmw vs canonical AI_INFRA
(mandate Harness-9 B1+B2): audit wf_13868efb-ea7 -> implement wf_ac43b5ff-7d1 ->
review wf_d482e10d-5dd. SE was BEHIND Harness-10 flat.

- run-trace SUBFOLDER->FLAT: hmw.js (:103 subMd + :52 schema + H4.5->H8 drift) +
  workflows/README full-rewrite + runs/README + session-start/end + agents/README
  Upgrade S72 + _ledger; 5 old S71 runs KEEP subfolder (C8 dual-accept). node --check OK.
- adopt 2 pending broadcasts (checklist-v2 + h10-flat-detector-refine).
- port /sleep-recovery-memory-l2 (A8, J2-tailored SE-only, floor intact, live skill).
- detector refine-b TAILORED-OUT (SE Workflow-tool no-CLI-bypass; containment
  git-diff+tracked+orphan-scan G-015).
- REVIEW (B2) caught 2 IMPLEMENT-self-assess missed (hmw.js:52 schema-stale +
  sleep-cmd auto-check un-wired overclaim) -> fixed (auto-check WIRED: budget.json
  +last_sleep_at + session-start/end INFORM). +3 minor fixed.
- em-main containment-check caught 1 reviewer residual-write (raw-Workflow no
  writeGuard) -> revert (reverse-finding #4). B3 self-correct: runs path 14->22.
- sleep-recovery-memory-l2 all = NO-OP (all periods already gisted). last_sleep_at set.

0 production code. State unchanged: Mig 53 / 88 tables / 306 test / 68 gotcha / menu 54
/ bundle BgNCjwsG/CBvh0vtf. adap-report + email ai_infra (5f511fe5c0f2).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-18 14:04:03 +07:00

2.2 KiB
Raw Blame History

REVIEW SYNTHESIS — Harness-10 flat migration + sleep-cmd (B2 double-check, gom/verified)

  • run-id: 2026-06-18-harness-fix-review · wf: wf_d482e10d-5dd · 2026-06-18 13:27→13:4x +07
  • 3× reviewer adversarial ∥. Dogfood B2 SUCCESS: review độc-lập bắt đúng cái IMPLEMENT self-assessment bỏ sót (schema-stale + auto-wire overclaim).

Verdicts

reviewer verdict finding
R1 flat-completeness PASS-with-concerns 1 minor schema-stale + 1 untracked-note
R2 sleepcmd-detector PASS-with-concerns 1 MAJOR auto-wire overclaim + 2 minor
R3 containment-honesty PASS containment clean + honesty strong; 1 minor doc-precision

0 blocker. 1 major + 4 minor — TẤT CẢ FIXED (em-main single-writer, post-review).

Fixes applied + verified

  1. [R1 minor] hmw.js:52 schema subMdPath desc sub-md/→flat ✓
  2. [R2 MAJOR] auto-check WIRED: memory-budget.json +last_sleep_at:null + session-start.md:78 + session-end.md:48 INFORM (null/≥7d, no-autorun) — grep-verified present (was zero) ✓
  3. [R2 minor] provenance design-doc cite → AI_INFRA absolute path ✓
  4. [R2 minor] charter substring anchor + "cam"→"cấm" typo ✓
  5. [R3 minor] runs/README:31 dogfood reworded (audit-run=synthesis-only self-gate; implement-run=full raw) ✓
  • post-fix verify: hmw.js node --check PARSE-OK · budget.json VALID · grep last_sleep_at present cả 2 session cmd.

B2.5 reverse-findings → AI_INFRA report

  1. rename-migration audit phải grep runtime SCHEMA/contract-description strings (không chỉ code-path + prose) — path duplicate ở operative-var + comment + schema-desc; schema-desc copy dễ-sót-nhất (data≠code). [bắt được hmw.js:52 self-doc divergence]
  2. ported-command §-anchor phải grep/ls-verify IN sister repo (re-homed path khác AI_INFRA↔SE); §-cite = wiring-claim → grep-prove (như 'wire BE' bug áp cho governance-doc).
  3. SE runs/.claude/workflows/runs/ không phải repo-root → bare git ls-files runs false-0 = FALSE not-tracked; path-qualify + exit-branch check-ignore (negation last-match-wins vô-hình với text-read).

VERDICT: PASS sau-fix → REPORT (B3) AI_INFRA.