# Session 23 turn 3 — 2026-05-15 — Plan M Fix F1 edge case + FE label rename

**Dev:** Claude Opus 4.7 1M (4 sub-agents active + em main coordinator)
**Duration:** ~2h
**Base commit:** `83c9f7b` (S23 t2 Plan L5 chốt)
**Final HEAD:** `4dd6f9c` (M2 tests) — local, CHƯA push remote (chờ Reviewer verdict)
**Total commits Plan M:** **3** (M1 + M3 + M2)

## 🎯 Trigger session

Bro UAT post-Plan L deploy (S23 t2 chốt ~02:00) phát hiện disconnect:

> "Hiện logic cũ là khi trả lại 1 cấp hoặc chỉ định hoặc edit là trạng thái draft -> cái này thay đổi lại nhé, các tính năng duyệt thẳng, trả lại 1 cấp hoặc người chỉ định hoặc cho edit thì cho xử lý đc ở trạng thái đang gửi duyệt luôn."

Em main pre-flight Investigator spawn audit code thực tế. **Verdict surprise:** code main path đã đúng (F1.OneLevel/Assignee + F2 + F3+F4 giữ ChoDuyet đúng spec Mig 28-31 cumulative). Chỉ **edge case F1.OneLevel/OneStep tại Bước 1** còn fallback Drafter (Phase=TraLai) — đây là "draft" bro phát hiện.

Bro 3 AskUserQuestion chốt spec Plan M:
- **F1.OneLevel/OneStep Bước 1**: reset (0, 1) giữ ChoDuyet (Recommended Option A — no-op effective + audit log)
- **FE Phase=TraLai display label**: rename "Trả lại" → "Cần chỉnh sửa lại"
- **F1.Drafter mode 4**: GIỮ NGUYÊN Phase=TraLai semantic (explicit role mode, KHÔNG phải fallback)

## 🌳 Plan M 3 chunk execution

### Chunk M1 — BE Service refactor F1 edge case (`c2042ef`)

👤 Chủ trì Solo (cross-stack reasoning F1 state machine — Implementer auto-refuse criteria #1 schema-ish + #4 bug-fix-reasoning).

File: [PurchaseEvaluationWorkflowService.cs:287-333](src/Backend/SolutionErp.Infrastructure/Services/PurchaseEvaluationWorkflowService.cs:287)

```diff
case WorkflowReturnMode.OneLevel:
    // Lùi 1 Cấp trong cùng Step. Nếu đang Cấp 1 → lùi sang Bước trước
    // Cấp cuối. Nếu đang Bước 1 Cấp 1 → reset về (0, 1) giữ ChoDuyet
-   // → fallback Drafter (no further).
+   // (Plan M S23 t3 — KHÔNG fallback Drafter, phiếu giữ "đang duyệt").
    if (curLevel > 1) { ... }
    else if (curStepIdx > 0) { ... }
    else
    {
-       // Bước 1 Cấp 1 — no further back. Fallback Drafter.
-       evaluation.Phase = PurchaseEvaluationPhase.TraLai;
-       evaluation.CurrentWorkflowStepIndex = null;
-       evaluation.CurrentApprovalLevelOrder = null;
-       evaluation.SlaDeadline = null;
-       return "Trả về Người soạn thảo (fallback — đang Bước 1 Cấp 1)";
+       // Bước 1 Cấp 1 → reset về (0, 1) giữ Phase=ChoDuyet (no-op effective
+       // — Approver A hiện tại). Audit log rõ "không lùi được". SLA reset
+       // dưới cuối hàm cho approver giữ nguyên.
+       evaluation.CurrentWorkflowStepIndex = 0;
+       evaluation.CurrentApprovalLevelOrder = 1;
+       summary = "Action 'Trả lại 1 Cấp' không lùi được — phiếu reset về Approver Bước 1 Cấp 1";
    }
```

OneStep analog: line 314-333 cùng pattern reset (0, 1) thay vì fallback Drafter.

**Verify:**
- `dotnet build src/Backend/SolutionErp.Infrastructure` clean (0 err, 2 warn pre-existing DocxRenderer)
- Diff 13+/13- LOC 1 file surgical

**KHÔNG đụng:**
- F1.Drafter line 268-275 (explicit role mode, giữ TraLai)
- F1.Assignee line 335-360 (giữ throw nếu không match)
- F2 ApproveV2Async line 483-524 (Plan L L1 fix unchanged)
- F3 EnsureEditableForDetailsAsync (Mig 28 wire unchanged)
- F4 AdjustBudgetCommand handler (Mig 30 wire unchanged)

### Chunk M3 — FE label Phase=TraLai rename × 2 app (`508b17a`)

🟨 Implementer Case 2 (cookie-cutter mirror 2 app, ~6K tokens spawn).

Files (4 FE + 1 MEMORY):
- [fe-admin/src/types/purchaseEvaluation.ts](fe-admin/src/types/purchaseEvaluation.ts): `PurchaseEvaluationPhaseLabel[98]` + `PeDisplayStatusLabel.TraLai`
- [fe-user/src/types/purchaseEvaluation.ts](fe-user/src/types/purchaseEvaluation.ts) mirror
- [fe-admin/src/components/pe/PeWorkflowPanel.tsx](fe-admin/src/components/pe/PeWorkflowPanel.tsx): F1 dialog tooltip + confirm message status reference
- [fe-user/src/components/pe/PeWorkflowPanel.tsx](fe-user/src/components/pe/PeWorkflowPanel.tsx) mirror

Diff +4/-4 LOC × 4 file = 8 LOC tổng. Mirror 2 app §3.9 strict.

**Scope decisions Implementer:**
- ✅ Rename 2 const map label (badge primary)
- ✅ Tactical extension: rename 2 inline literal "Trả lại" trong PeWorkflowPanel.tsx F1 dialog (tooltip + confirm message — status display reference, KHÔNG phải action verb). Anti-fiddle <20% LOC threshold respected.
- ✅ KHÔNG đụng `← Trả lại` action button, `Trả về Người soạn thảo` mode picker, comments narrative
- ✅ KHÔNG đụng `types/contracts.ts` + `types/budget.ts` Phase 98 (Contract + Budget module ngoài scope M3)

**Verify:** fe-admin npm build PASS clean (0 TS err, 9.40s) + fe-user PASS clean (0 TS err, 6.92s).

### Chunk M2 — Tests F1 edge case (`4dd6f9c`)

🟨 Implementer Case 3 (test generation cookie-cutter, ~14K tokens spawn).

File: [tests/SolutionErp.Infrastructure.Tests/Services/PurchaseEvaluationWorkflowServiceReturnModeTests.cs](tests/SolutionErp.Infrastructure.Tests/Services/PurchaseEvaluationWorkflowServiceReturnModeTests.cs)

2 test mới (Pattern 11 SeedWorkflowAsync helper extend 2 param optional `allowReturnOneLevelL1` + `allowReturnOneStepL2`):
- `ApplyReturnMode_OneLevel_AtStep1Level1_ResetsToBuoc1Cap1_KeepsChoDuyet`
- `ApplyReturnMode_OneStep_AtStep1_ResetsToBuoc1Cap1_KeepsChoDuyet`

Assertions:
- Phase.Should().Be(ChoDuyet) — KHÔNG TraLai
- CurrentWorkflowStepIndex.Should().Be(0)
- CurrentApprovalLevelOrder.Should().Be(1)
- SlaDeadline.Should().NotBeNull (reset 7d)
- ContextNote contain "không lùi được" (KHÔNG `Summary` — fix spec bug em main bị Implementer correct: `LogTransitionAsync` set Summary = "Chuyển phase {from} → {to}" cố định; summary từ `ApplyReturnModeAsync` chèn vào `comment` param → ghi vào `ContextNote`)

**Verify:** `dotnet test SolutionErp.slnx` **106/106 PASS** (58 Domain + 48 Infra: +2 từ 46 baseline). K7 Approver F2 NO regression (3 `ApproveV2_SkipToFinal_*` tests still green — M1 chỉ đụng F1 path).

Diff +94/-2 LOC test file + 22 LOC MEMORY append.

### Pending Chunk M4 + Reviewer verdict + push

- 🟥 Reviewer pre-commit running background (a7cce1b29) — verify M1+M2+M3 cumulative
- 👤 Chủ trì M4 docs (STATUS + HANDOFF + session log file này + memory update) — IN PROGRESS
- Push remote sau Reviewer PASS + bro confirm
- 🟩 CICD Monitor post-deploy verify

## 📊 Stats Plan M chốt

| Metric | Trước (S23 t2) | Sau (S23 t3) | Δ |
|---|---|---|---|
| DB tables | 59 | 59 | 0 |
| Migrations | 31 | 31 | 0 |
| Endpoints | ~145 | ~145 | 0 |
| FE pages | 34 | 34 | 0 |
| **Unit tests** | 104 | **106** | **+2** (F1 OneLevel/OneStep edge case) |
| Gotchas | 47 | 47 | 0 |
| **Memory entries** | 20 | **21** | +1 reinforcement S23 t3 (per_nv_permission_scope + uat_skip_verify update) |
| Skills | 6 | 6 | 0 |
| Sub-agents | 4 (1 spawn Plan L) | 4 (3 spawn Plan M: 1 Inv + 2 Imp + 1 Rev pending) | active |
| **Commits Plan M** | — | **3** (M1 + M3 + M2 local) | pending push |

## 🎯 Multi-agent ROI evidence Plan M

| Spawn | Agent | Cost (tokens) | Output | Catch |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-flight | 🟦 Investigator | ~20K | 7-feature audit matrix file:line + verdict "code main path đúng, chỉ edge case sai" | **Avoid em main spam refactor sai** — verify 6/7 feature đã đúng spec, chỉ scope hẹp Bước 1 fallback cần fix |
| M1 | 👤 Chủ trì | ~self | 1 commit BE Service 13+/13- LOC | — |
| M3 | 🟨 Implementer Case 2 | ~6K | 1 commit FE label rename × 4 file mirror | Tactical extension catch inline literal F1 dialog tooltip + confirm message |
| M2 | 🟨 Implementer Case 3 | ~14K | 1 commit tests 2 new + 106/106 PASS | Spec field bug catch (`ContextNote` vs `Summary`) + helper extend backward-compat |
| Reviewer | 🟥 Reviewer | ~22K (pending) | PASS verdict + Smart Friend guard | TBD post-spawn |
| Post-deploy | 🟩 CICD Monitor | ~150K (pending) | Bundle hash + smoke F1 endpoint | TBD post-push |

**Total Plan M spawn cost (excl Reviewer + CICD):** ~40K tokens — well under 200K budget per session.

**Multi-agent value caught:**
1. **Investigator avoid em main spam refactor** — bro statement "logic cũ là về draft" easy lead em main refactor toàn bộ 4 mode F1 + F2 + F3 + F4. Investigator catch fact code main path đã đúng → scope giảm 80% (LOW effort vs HIGH).
2. **Implementer Case 3 catch spec bug `ContextNote` vs `Summary`** — em main spec viết `Summary.Should().Contain(...)` sai field. Implementer correct → test pass real, không pass-by-mistake.
3. **Implementer Case 2 tactical extension** — rename inline literal trong F1 dialog tooltip + confirm message (cùng status reference disconnect). Anti-fiddle threshold respected, KHÔNG scope drift.

## ⚠️ Pending S23 t4+

- 🟥 **M-Review verdict** — chờ Reviewer pre-commit Plan M cumulative
- 🟩 **CICD Monitor K-Plan-M** — chờ push remote → spawn post-deploy verify
- 🟡 **Plan B Contract V2 wire (Mig 32+33)** — vẫn pending S23+ (HIGH priority next)
- ⛔ **Plan F drop V1** — defer sau Plan B + UAT 2-3 tuần
- 🟢 **Plan H PE PDF Export** — LOW priority carry
- 🟡 **Plan I RAG Hybrid setup 5 dự án** — defer chờ bro confirm
- 🔧 **Gotcha #47 paths-ignore agent-memory** — PENDING bro confirm

## 📋 Pattern reinforced

- **Investigator pre-flight audit avoid em main spam refactor** — khi bro statement có vẻ "code sai" mà Investigator audit verify code đã đúng → scope giảm drastically (LOW vs HIGH effort). Pattern reusable: BẮT BUỘC spawn Investigator pre-flight cho mọi bug fix scope > 50 LOC, KHÔNG em main solo audit (bias).
- **Edge case "không thực hiện được" KHÔNG fallback role khác** — pattern user-level reinforced trong `feedback_per_nv_permission_scope.md` S23 t3 entry. Action per-NV flag được trigger nhưng state machine không cho phép → giữ Phase hiện tại + reset pointer hợp lệ + audit log warning.
- **Service refactor semantic BẮT BUỘC test cùng commit** — Plan L L1→L4 lesson (CI #196/#197 FAIL cascade). Memory `feedback_uat_skip_verify.md` updated với rule mới.
- **Implementer Case 2+3 cookie-cutter 2 spawns parallel** — M2 (test) + M3 (FE) chạy background đồng thời ~6K + ~14K tokens. Em main solo M1 (cross-stack reasoning). Total Plan M token ~40K under 200K budget.

## References

- Memory user-level updated: `feedback_per_nv_permission_scope.md` (S23 t3 reinforcement) + `feedback_uat_skip_verify.md` (Plan L lesson Service refactor semantic)
- Files: [Service.cs:287-333](src/Backend/SolutionErp.Infrastructure/Services/PurchaseEvaluationWorkflowService.cs:287) (M1) + [types/purchaseEvaluation.ts × 2 app](fe-admin/src/types/purchaseEvaluation.ts) + [PeWorkflowPanel.tsx × 2 app](fe-admin/src/components/pe/PeWorkflowPanel.tsx) (M3) + [PurchaseEvaluationWorkflowServiceReturnModeTests.cs](tests/SolutionErp.Infrastructure.Tests/Services/PurchaseEvaluationWorkflowServiceReturnModeTests.cs) (M2)
- 4 agent MEMORY.md flushed (Investigator pending + Implementer 2 entry + Reviewer pending) at `.claude/agent-memory/{investigator,implementer,reviewer,cicd-monitor}/MEMORY.md`
- Rules: §3.9 mirror 2 FE, §7 test timing, `feedback_uat_skip_verify` (updated rule Service semantic refactor), `feedback_per_nv_permission_scope` (S23 t3 reinforcement)