[CLAUDE] Docs: S101 H18 WF2 review closeout — re-run wf_955643c3-f7d PASS_WITH_CONCERNS + stamp + model-note Opus-S101

- WF2 gốc wf_31ea3985-92c mất theo CLI-restart → re-run fresh 3-lane adversarial
- Lane-A detector-teeth PASS (fault-inject 4/4 tái-dựng độc-lập -RepoRoot, MED derived-stale 11→0)
- Lane-B ledger-retire PASS_WITH_CONCERNS: 1 CONCERN workflows/README:51 nhãn-cũ "ledger orphan-scan" sweep-S100-sót → FIXED
- Lane-C PARTIAL: codify+n-a-H8+containment first-hand; frontier-hash+reviewer_gate dựa record-S100 (broadcast inbound vắng repo)
- Lane-C #53 return-garble → recover first-hand; AS-10 residual sub-write reverted (git-diff backstop)
- Stamp run-id+verdict → adap-report:5 + engine §J:283; STATUS/HANDOFF flip + session-log
- Model-note reconcile: runtime=Opus S101 (Fable unavailable, settings pin fable → H5-fallback revert-free) — STATUS:24 + agents/README:3
- Harvest reviewer + tooling-auditor memory (B3)
- Email AI_INFRA wf2-verdict + 3 flag (reviewer_gate-missing · frontier-hash-mismatch · process-gap broadcast-not-committed)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
pqhuy1987
2026-07-03 17:14:14 +07:00
parent 5ee32c0c0b
commit f229b07f39
12 changed files with 97 additions and 18 deletions

View File

@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ Read-only CI/CD + post-deploy verifier SOLUTION_ERP. Polls Gitea Actions API, ve
- **SSHPS quoting (S42):** nested bashsshpowershell mangles `$var`/`\"` use `iconv UTF-16LE | base64` `powershell -EncodedCommand $B64`; OR write ps1-file + `powershell -File $(cygpath -w)`. sqlcmd over SSH direct `-W -h -1` pw-inline. sys-catalog string-concat `COLLATE DATABASE_DEFAULT` (collation conflict).
- **Tests baseline:** **440 PASS** (45 Domain + 395 Infra · 0 fail/skip; S96 Run #480 sha 0c2f9f6 436 + new `PeSuggestedPriceSetterAuthzTests`; prior S96 #479 436, S96/S95 434, S90 #465 421). Phase 9 UAT skip per chunk OK.
- **Mig latest repo:** **Mig 61 `20260701142752_BackfillEndedByLevelFinalizeFromChangelog`** (S97 #484; data-only NO-schema, `Sql()` UPDATE `EndedByLevelFinalize=1` cho phiếu finalize-marker `PurchaseEvaluationChangelogs` fix Mig 60 soi NHẦM bảng VERIFIED-APPLIED-PROD history-HEAD + A/005/A/008 flipped 01, A/010 stayed 0). Prev Mig 60 `AddPeEndedByLevelFinalize` (S97 #482 AddColumn bit default 0). Path `src/Backend/SolutionErp.Infrastructure/Persistence/Migrations/`. Prod check `sqlcmd __EFMigrationsHistory ORDER BY MigrationId DESC TOP 5`. **`sys.tables` (is_ms_shipped=0) = 89** (S97 LIVE-verified pre/post #482 narrative/spec-88 STALE, 89=truth; AddColumn/data-only migs don't change count commit touches no schema 89 correct don't FAIL. Cross-ref COMMIT scope vs ambient count). enum-additive (e.g. `ApprovalAttachment=5`) = int-stored NO-mig history NOT-advance + empty `git diff -- '*Migrations*'`.
- **Bundle hash live (S97 #482 last-FE-ship JS-rotated real-FE, CSS-frozen):** admin js **`DR9q2VUy`**/css `Bbtesa6B` · user js **`Bgz8u4E5`**/css `BmuPz_Dy` (JS rotated real PeWorkflowPanel 2-app endsBeforeCeo-gate; CSS IDENTICAL=JSX-logic-only #69-REFINE byte-identicalsame-hash). Note #483 badge later rotated JS`CeTA7Z82`/`CGaAyXen` CSS-same; #484 data-fix NO-FE-change not snapshotted. **id ≠ run_number; head_sha-keyed.** **PER #69: hash MAY rotate per deploy (real src-diff) OR stay frozen if 0 fe-src diff (byte-identical) — SNAPSHOT for THAT run, NOT frozen baseline; ALWAYS re-snapshot LIVE pre-deploy (prev-hash=hint NOT truth).** Real FE ship = diff `fe-*/src` in commit/range + real-size-vs-fake (1.6/1.5MB vs ~919b SPA-trap) + Last-Modified-in-window, NOT hash delta alone.
- **Bundle hash live (S100 #486 verified 2026-07-02):** admin js **`mEGqlNWc`**/css `Bbtesa6B` · user js **`Dnrp4PU1`**/css `BmuPz_Dy` FROZEN qua #485#486 (0 fe-src diff byte-identical, #69-REFINE ×3: #333/#485/#486) nhưng Last-Modified fresh mỗi deploy = ship-proof. Rotate cuối = post-#484 (từ #483 `CeTA7Z82`/`CGaAyXen`). **id ≠ run_number; head_sha-keyed.** **PER #69: hash MAY rotate (real src-diff) OR frozen (0 fe-src diff) — SNAPSHOT per-run, NOT baseline; ALWAYS re-snapshot LIVE pre-deploy.** Real FE ship = diff `fe-*/src` in range + real-size-vs-fake (1.64/1.54MB vs ~919b SPA-trap) + Last-Modified-in-window, NOT hash delta alone.
- **Bearer:** admin `admin@solutions.com.vn/Admin@123456` (full) · UAT `nv.test@solutions.com.vn/TestUser@123456` (Drafter CCM, gotcha #44 check).
## 🔑 Critical config (flag commit nếu tái xuất)
@ -70,7 +70,8 @@ BE (test+build) ~90s · FE × 2 ~60s/app · deploy ~30s · **total ~3min code /
## 📅 Recent runs (compressed — full verbatim → `archive/2026-06.md` via `archive/_INDEX.md`)
- **🟢 S98 #485 (rn 371) `8a249c5` GO 5m18s — GOVERNANCE-ONLY (23 file = 22 .md ignored + `memory-budget.json` .json non-ignored → full-range trigger #41):** Mig 61 frozen history-top · smoke 200×3 + auth+PE-list 200 · bundle hash **FROZEN** 2 app (`mEGqlNWc`/`Dnrp4PU1`, CSS same = live hiện tại) NHƯNG Last-Modified in-window 11:01:48/11:02:42+07 + real-size 1.64/1.54MB = ship-proof. **#69-REFINE CONFIRMED lần 2** (sau #333): 0 fe-src diff ⟹ byte-identical ⟹ hash frozen + fresh copy. GOVERNANCE-PASS pattern S95 #476 tái xác nhận.
- **🟢 S100 #486 (rn 372) `5ee32c0` GO 5m17s (15:32:11→15:37:28) — GOVERNANCE-ONLY (19 file = 18 .md/docs ignored + `scripts/governance-detectors.ps1` non-ignored → trigger #41; 5 docs-only commits trước [525a01a…513aa09] đúng 0-run):** Mig 61 frozen history-top + sys.tables 89 · smoke 200×7 (health-ready/admin/eoffice + auth accessToken + PE-list + contracts + menus) · bundle hash **FROZEN** 2 app + Last-Modified in-window 15:36:08/15:37:01+07 + real-size 1.64/1.54MB vs fake-919b control = ship-proof. **#69-REFINE ×3** (#333#485#486): 0 fe-src diff ⟹ hash frozen + fresh copy. GOVERNANCE-PASS stable ×3 (#476/#485/#486). 🔧 Poll: python `time.sleep` in-script chạy ĐƯỢC foreground (chỉ bash `sleep` builtin bị block) — hết cần busy-wait spin.
- _(S98 #485 (rn 371) `8a249c5` GO 5m18s GOVERNANCE-ONLY [22 .md + `memory-budget.json` non-ignored → #41] — Mig61 frozen · hash FROZEN + LM-in-window 11:01:48/11:02:42 + real-size = ship-proof · #69-REFINE lần 2 · verbatim git `c112be9`)_
- **🟢🟢 S96+S97 FINAL-SESSION-REVIEW (2026-07-01 end) — 11-commit day #478-#484 ALL-DEPLOYED-HEALTHY, verdict CLEAN (whole-session GO trên LIVE prod):** CI-success ×7 + Mig61 history-top + backfill A/005=1/A/008=1/A/010=0 exact + sys.tables 88-excl/89-incl reconcile + health 4×200 + auth/PE-list/SignalR wired (#25 clear) + BE-dll+w3wp in-#484-window. ⚠️ bundle ROTATED post-#484: admin js **`mEGqlNWc`**/user **`Dnrp4PU1`**, CSS frozen — **#69 CONFIRMED: rebuild rotate MỌI deploy kể cả data-fix; rotation ≠ ship-signal** (real-FE-ship = diff fe-src + real-size + Last-Modified-in-window). 🔑 **WHOLE-SESSION GO = every-commit-CI-success + Mig-top==HEAD + backfill-exact + control-untouched + 4×health-200 + auth+PE+SignalR-wired + BE-dll+w3wp-in-window + bundles-real-in-window.** Full verbatim → `archive/2026-07.md` via `_INDEX` (curate S98).
- **🟢 S97 #484 (run_number 370) `fb2dfa9` GO ~5m — DATA-FIX Mig 61 backfill EndedByLevelFinalize từ Changelogs (fix Mig 60 wrong-table, gotcha #79):** sqlcmd **A/005=1 + A/008=1** (0→1 = fix ăn) · **A/010=0** control · Mig61 `__EFMigrationsHistory` top · endsBeforeCeo FLIP live A/005=True · smoke 200×3 + PE-list 200 · baseline 440. 🔑 **DATA-FIX-BACKFILL PASS = CI-success + Mig-top==HEAD + sqlcmd-target-rows-flip-EXACT + control-untouched + derived-API-field-FLIP-live + smoke-200.** Full verbatim → `archive/2026-07.md` via `_INDEX` (curate S98).
- _(endsBeforeCeo-saga PE finalize UAT cluster anh Kiệt: **S97 #482 `8037fa0` CROSS-STACK + Mig60 `AddPeEndedByLevelFinalize`** [config→RUNTIME · Mig-APPLIED col-bit-default-CONVERT(0) backfill=0 sys.tables=89-pre/post · 🔴 EF-TERNARY-SQL-Server-TRANSLATE-LIVE list-200-NOT-500 + detail-endsBeforeCeo-False-runtime · JS `Cf0o8dx8`/`x8rppRAK``DR9q2VUy`/`Bgz8u4E5` CSS-frozen · #77 field-PRESENT] · **S97-badge #483 `9e12e80` FE-ONLY 8-file badge "✅ Đã được CEO duyệt"** [JS→`CeTA7Z82`/`CGaAyXen` CSS-frozen · #77 new-str-BOTH+prev-additive · Mig60-frozen list-200] · **S97 #481 `1c8fb6a` FE-ONLY 2-fix** [badge `không trình tới``Kết thúc tại {name}`+opt-out→opt-in · JS→`Cf0o8dx8`/`x8rppRAK` CSS-frozen · #77 new-PRESENT/old-ABSENT] — all baseline-440 all PASS, full verbatim → git + `2026-06.md` via `_INDEX`)_

View File

@ -10,6 +10,7 @@
- [S89 PE budget-sectionB review](project_s89_pe_sectionb_review.md) — investigator 3/3 upheld (do-not-touch FROZEN) + CAUGHT MISSED #70 race: Block B PRO row3/row8 share adjustMut + cross-echo `ev` stale + NO `||peFetching` (every other cell gated). authz-lens ≠ concurrency-lens.
- [S89 PE ends-before-CEO PLAN review](project_s89_pe_endsbeforeceo_plan_review.md) — CONCERN: BE 3-field design sound (Mig 58 col committed, no mig) but FE coverage gap — 4 PeUrgentChips render-sites, plan covered only 2 (missed InboxPage:290 despite BE Inbox A2 updated + wrong ListPage dir path).
- [S89 finalize-note PLAN review](project_s89_finalize_note_plan_review.md) — CONCERN: plan ground-truth 100% accurate (all file:line verified incl self-flagged); gaps = note doesn't say intermediate approvers still sign + skipToFinal-last-level corner + Dev DB 9 migs behind.
- **S101 H18 WF2 governance re-run (self=workflow-lane · em-main synthesized):** re-verified S100 Harness-18 adopt (`5ee32c0`, governance-only) — original WF2 `wf_31ea3985-92c` lost to CLI-restart → fresh `wf_955643c3-f7d` **PASS_WITH_CONCERNS**. Lane-A detector-teeth PASS (fault-inject 4/4 `-RepoRoot` temp-tree — proved detector FLAGS injected-stale, not happy-path). Lane-B caught **1 CONCERN em-main missed in S100 sweep**: `workflows/README.md:51` stale label "ledger orphan-scan" (NO `_ledger` token → grep-exact sweep skipped) → FIXED S101. Lesson: **exact-token sweep misses paraphrased labels** — widen to concept-phrase when retiring a named artifact. Lane-C **#53 return-garble** (workflow-lane returned no StructuredOutput) → recovered first-hand, NOT re-spawned (`feedback_agent_return_garble_recover`).
---
@ -65,15 +66,12 @@ Adversarial pre-commit reviewer SOLUTION_ERP. Read-only verify + live curl prod
## 📅 Recent activity (compressed — full verbatim → `archive/2026-06.md` via `archive/_INDEX.md`)
- **S98 (2026-07-02) FIDELITY GATE gist impl-frontend 2026-H1 (10 record → 6 cụm + 5 reflection) — PASS-với-sửa (1 minor):** 34/34 substring-pointer count==1 (grep -o -F đếm occurrence, gồm cặp bẫy "gotcha #50"≠"gotcha#50" resolve 2 record khác nhau đều hợp-cảnh). 3 interpretive-flag verify GROUND-TRUTH ngoài verbatim: double-rAF (code ListPage:270 comment "2 rAF để browser commit translate-x-full TRƯỚC" + duration-200) · 2 PageHeader song-song (4 file disk thật ×2 app) · wildcard `ev.*Note` theo-từng-mut (đúng 3 call-site 1770/1785/1841). FLAG cwd-misland hướng-chéo: session-log S76:40 CORROBORATE verbatim (cd fe-admin → rơi fe-user/.claude) + .gitignore L109-111 comment trung-tính → draft trung-tính ĐÚNG, không sửa hướng. Sửa duy nhất: R4 parenthetical nói chuỗi "nằm trong chính gist" — misleading, chuỗi resolve count==1 trong archive. Lesson: fidelity-gate 3 lớp = so-verbatim + pointer-arithmetic + ground-truth-code cho MỌI chỗ gist DIỄN GIẢI vượt verbatim; honest-empty BẤT-NGỜ="không" > bịa filler; verbatim TỰ mâu-thuẫn (S52-vs-S53) → gist flag discrepancy chứ KHÔNG resolve bịa (anti-S88-fabrication-by-merge, lần này draft làm đúng).
- **S98 (2026-07-02) VERIFY LANE V3 cicd-monitor L1-curate moved-not-cut — PASS (0 blocking, 3 minor):** sha256 line-level backup-L73/74 == archive-L7/8 (2398/1909B text) + byte-arithmetic đóng EXACT (removed 4309 raw stubs 1451 = 2858 = size-delta 19917→17059) + diff duy-nhất `73,74c73,74` + CR/LF profile 86/86→86/86 không đổi + FROZEN archives 0-diff + _INDEX 78=2+39+20+6+7+3+1 pointer-resolve count==1. **Tool-lesson Windows byte-verify:** MSYS grep/sed/awk = TEXT-MODE strip `\r` (grep -c `\r` báo 0 trên file CRLF thuần!); od-token-pipeline đếm sai (641 vs 86 — token-split artifact); ground-truth = `.NET ReadAllBytes` / `wc -c` / `tr` pipe / `od -c` tail. Moved entries CRLF→LF normalize (encoding-only, 0 ký tự mất — Write tool ghi file mới LF uniform). Minor caught: MEMORY.md "Last curate" ledger vẫn S80 (S98 chưa ghi sổ, discoverable qua stub "(curate S98)"); archive-header chữ "byte-exact" đúng trừ CR-terminator.
- **S98 (2026-07-02) VERIFY LANE V1 re-tier mega-line STATUS/HANDOFF conservation (uncommitted) — PASS (0 mismatch):** blurb S94+S93 cắt khỏi mega-line = VERBATIM trong archive tier-S98 (STATUS IndexOf ordinal 9412/11090 · HANDOFF 6147/7775; HEAD cross-check cùng blurb, HANDOFF lệch +51 = đúng bundle-hash morning-edit TRƯỚC blurb). **Proof-of-no-other-deletion = arithmetic full-accounting** prefix+b94+sep(` · `,3)+b93+tail(125=old-pointer) == lineLen exact ×2 file — mạnh hơn spot-check. Old-pointer tái hiện trong pointer mới (archive-S98 + archive-S94 đều =1). Kỹ thuật-bẫy: commonPrefix lấn 1-char (`*` đầu `**Prev` trùng `*` mở italic pointer mới) → Replace-decompose trên removed-region FAIL giả; fix = IndexOf(blurb) trên FULL line. Line-count bằng (92/92, 12/12) → index-by-index diff enumerate đủ 6+2 dòng vào allowed-list. Flagged: archive `??` UNTRACKED — phải `git add` cùng commit kẻo pointer gãy. Read-tool truncate dòng >2K = KHÔNG verify được mega-line → PS ReadAllLines UTF8 + ordinal IndexOf là đường duy nhất.
- [S100 H18 WF2 synthesis + Lane-B](project_s100_h18_wf2_synthesis.md) — SYNTHESIS reviewer 2-lane JSON→overall **PASS_WITH_CONCERNS** (LaneA PASS + LaneB PWC, neither BLOCKING). Re-verified indep: ledger +2/0-del revert-clean · ratio-band replaced `|diff|>=10` · glob replaced 3-fixed-list · 6/6 consumers 🧊-marked · every LIVE `_ledger` marked (unmarked=history) · CONCERN workflows/README:51 no-token points-authoritative=non-block · KEY anti-pattern HELD (stale WF2 `wf_31ea3985` NOT stamped, both placeholders await fresh run). Prior S100-bis Lane-B PASS (2 minor) folded in.
- **S97-bis (2026-07-01) PE EndsBeforeCeo CONFIG→RUNTIME + Mig 60 backfill (bug anh Kiệt FDC, cross-stack+mig, live UAT) — PASS (0 issue):** field `EndedByLevelFinalize` set true DUY NHẤT nhánh level-finalize service:871 (grep-all confirm 5 nhánh DaDuyet: 671 drafter-auto / 873 finalize-SET / 911 ccm-delegation / 943 all-steps-CEO / 1049 V1-legacy — chỉ 873 set, 4 nhánh còn lại giữ false = đúng semantics). 4 projection nhất quán: detail ternary `phase==DaDuyet?field:true` (:1153) · List/Inbox `Phase==DaDuyet?field:config-subquery` (:647/:767) · ListApproved direct field (filter DaDuyet :176). **Migration 3-file OK** (Designer+Snapshot có bit-NOT-NULL-default-false); backfill marker `LIKE N'%Duyệt KẾT THÚC tại%'` KHỚP-EXACT service comment:883 (system prefix, user-comment nối SAU) + table `PurchaseEvaluationApprovals` verified (config:148+DbSet) + `Phase=7`=DaDuyet verified enum. ccm-delegation comment `[CCM duyệt done miễn CEO]` KHÔNG match backfill → false nhất-quán runtime. **EF-translate ternary List/Inbox CONFIRMED runtime** (không giả định): `PeDraftVisibilityTests` gọi ListPurchaseEvaluationsQuery full-projection nằm trong 395 Infra PASS. FE 2-app SHA256-IDENTICAL `b7abbc2f`, gate `finalizeFlowStep=endsBeforeCeo?find:null` + banner:278 + type `endsBeforeCeo:boolean` có sẵn 2 DTO. **Build slnx 0w/0e + 440 test (45D+395I) 0-fail + tsc×2 exit-0** (self-verified, không tin claim). Test repro `peFinButWentCeo` (cùng-config finalize + field=false → EndsBeforeCeo=FALSE) = contrast quyết-định runtime-vs-config, xuất sắc. **Anti-pattern-none:** 11-file đúng-scope 0-drift, extend-in-place test NET+0-method giữ 440. Lesson: backfill LIKE-2-wildcard trên chuỗi VN-đặc-thù = false-positive risk MINOR-lý-thuyết (chỉ phiếu DaDuyet-hiện-tại 1-lần, UAT ít-phiếu) KHÔNG đủ FAIL. Config→runtime split đúng: chỉ THÊM chính-xác cho DaDuyet, non-DaDuyet giữ heads-up config như trước = không regression. **Re-affirmed @S97 Part-5 session-review lane** (spawn fail-return-schema → verdict recovered từ chính entry này per #53-recover-from-diary; em-main grep bổ-sung: 0 wrong-table pattern nào khác ngoài Mig 60 — đã fix Mig 61). *(addendum on-behalf H2-proposed @S98)*
- **S97 (2026-07-01) PE finalize UAT ×2 app: reword badge + đảo default checkbox opt-out→opt-in (uncommitted, prod-live anh Kiệt FDC) — PASS (0 issue):** 4 hunk/file × 2 = 8 total, 12ins/12del, no thừa. E1 `useState(true→false)` L57 · E2 reset `setApplyLevelFinalize(false)` L221 · E3 helper-text reword (strings KHỚP spec verbatim) · E4 badge `không trình tới``Kết thúc tại {finalizeLevelName ?? finalizeStepName ?? 'cấp trên'}` + template-literal title. **SHA256 full-file IDENTICAL** `bcf812fd…` ×2 + git-diff --no-index exit-0. **Comment L121 `không trình tới` INTACT** (bare-string 2-site: comment giữ + JSX đổi) + **`e.target.checked` handler L664 INTACT** (spec correctly NOT flip). Logic-non-break VERIFIED: default-false → eligible-untick → `sendPrice`(L171)=false + `shouldPickPrice`(L496)=false → price-picker KHÔNG bắt (spec pt6 ✓); payload L200 `(approverFinalizeEligible ? applyLevelFinalize : true)` = pre-existing S96 opt-out no-op cho non-eligible, unaffected by flip. Type `finalizeStepName/LevelName: string|null` (purchaseEvaluation.ts:149-150) → `??`-chain TS-safe. 0 BE/test/mig leak. Build fresh ~17:55 ×2 (fe-user hash `DxUomy4C` KHỚP impl-claim; fe-admin rotate `DkyQ0xCd`→disk `l_kwCZIF` = #69 normal). Anti-pattern-none: precedent-backed cosmetic+default-flip, byte-mirror tight.
- **2026-06-29 S93 Harness-16 MFE adoption review (WF2 `wf_13e3d35a` 3-lane PASS 0-blocking):** ⭐ code-gate re-derived denom-29 to-the-digit + **leading-verb-trap adversarial-probed-DEFEATED** (`NEVER commit push`→0 content-word, no false-max). cross-harness **READ-ONLY-budget proof** (đúng 1 write-op = `.mfe-state.json`; token_governor read-only) + 0-conflict additive. honesty 5-floor đủ + **live-numbers KHỚP §H prose** (S81 stale-config trap KHÔNG tái). Earlier WF1-reviewer caught **BLOCKING vocab-fork** (memory-fidelity = H6.7 memoryDelta-routing ≠ H16 coverage-eval → đặt MFE + alias-map §H, KHÔNG seed $aliasSets). Detail → adap-report harness-16-mfe. → _INDEX.
- **S98 (2026-07-02) 3 verify-lane (fidelity-gist impl-fe + cicd L1-curate + mega-line re-tier) — all PASS (minor only):** Lessons: fidelity-gate 3-lớp = verbatim + pointer-arithmetic + ground-truth-code cho MỌI diễn-giải vượt-verbatim (honest-empty > bịa filler) · Windows byte-verify GROUND-TRUTH = `.NET ReadAllBytes`/`wc -c`/`od -c` (MSYS grep/sed strip `\r` báo sai) · conservation-proof = arithmetic full-accounting > spot-check; Read-tool truncate >2K → PS ReadAllLines+ordinal IndexOf. Detail → `archive/2026-06.md`.
- **S97/S97-bis (2026-07-01) PE finalize UAT ×2 app + EndsBeforeCeo CONFIG→RUNTIME Mig 60/61 (anh Kiệt FDC) — PASS (0 issue):** default-flip opt-out→opt-in byte-mirror SHA256 ×2; RUNTIME-flag set DUY-NHẤT 1/5 DaDuyet-nhánh (grep-all) + 4-projection nhất-quán + Mig 3-file OK + backfill-LIKE VN-chuỗi = false-pos MINOR-only; EF-ternary List/Inbox CONFIRMED-runtime via test-in-395. Detail → `archive/2026-06.md`.
- **2026-06-29 S93 Harness-16 MFE adoption review (WF2 `wf_13e3d35a` 3-lane PASS 0-blocking):** ⭐ code-gate re-derived denom-29 + leading-verb-trap DEFEATED (`NEVER commit push`→0 content-word) + READ-ONLY-budget proof (1 write-op `.mfe-state.json`); WF1-reviewer caught BLOCKING vocab-fork (memory-fidelity H6.7≠H16 → MFE+alias-map §H). Detail → adap-report harness-16-mfe. → _INDEX.
- **S92 (2026-06-29) Adversarial PROD-security hide 5 menu-groups admin-only on eoffice (uncommitted) — PASS (0 blocking, 1 awareness note):** A-E all upheld; CatalogManager Danh-mục access stripped (intended-by-spec, role assigned to 0 users post-S89, flag em-main only). Detail + per-attack file:line → [project_s92_admin_only_modules_revoke.md](project_s92_admin_only_modules_revoke.md).
- **S91 (2026-06-25) PE D2 create-contract 1→N multi-winner + winner-names (FROZEN, NOT-deployed) — PASS:** fix for S89-bis dead-end; codegen mid-loop SaveChanges flushes ONLY seq-row (contract built LOCAL); GiaTri per-winner Quote-sum join PES.Id; positional DTO arg-order verified 3 sites; FE mirror byte-identical; 419 PASS. Detail → `archive/2026-06.md`.

View File

@ -40,3 +40,4 @@ H1 tooling-freshness auditor **SOLUTION_ERP-self**. Read-only + **propose-only**
- **2026-07-02 (S98 @start RE-REPORT — Fable-restore evidence, on-behalf em main APPEND B3):** 4-mặt: ①SKILL DRIFT — ef-core SKILL `:3`/`:19` stuck Mig 59 (disk **61**, thiếu rows 60/61 — drift born-S97 HẬU-monthly-audit-CÙNG-NGÀY) + skills/README `:20`→61 + `:90` latest #76→**79** → em main flush cùng session-start. ②ROSTER 11=11=11, frontmatter **11/11 `model: inherit`** khớp H8; **spawn này self-report `claude-fable-5` qua inherit** → H8 flip runtime-verified (em main flush STATUS:24 + agents/README:12). ③PLUGIN 18/15/3 + marketplace 35 identical, 0 new-alloc; observed-first-time: settings `effortLevel: xhigh` + `model: claude-fable-5[1m]`. ④DOCS: monthly-audit 07-01 **ĐÃ CHẠY** (S96 `881783c`) nhưng pointer "Lần kế" chưa flip → 2026-08-01 (root CLAUDE:111 + STATUS:63) + **Fable BACK runtime** → gỡ 3 caveat H5.6 (STATUS:24 · agents/README:3 · session-start.md:29) + HANDOFF:5 bundle mismatch (#483-hash gắn nhầm #484; canonical `mEGqlNWc`/`Dnrp4PU1`). Tag `[s98-start, 4-mat, fable-restore-evidence, post-audit-drift, on-behalf]`.
- **2026-07-02 (S99 @start RE-REPORT — ①②③ PASS, ④DOCS 3-flag):** HEAD `8a249c5`, tree 1-dirty pre-existing (cicd MEMORY M). ①SKILL PASS: 6+23+marketplace-35 unchanged; ef-core S98-update VERIFIED (:3/:19 "Mig 61"+B1, rows 60/61 `:82-:83` khớp STATUS:14, `:85` 89-bảng khớp STATUS:15, 0 residual); skills/README:20 "Updated S98"/:90 #79 fresh; dep-audit:153 B1 sạch; commands 14 file no-change. ②ROSTER PASS 11=11=11; frontmatter 11/11 `model: inherit` H8; **spawn này self-report `claude-fable-5` = inherit-chain data-point #3**; VALID_ROLES 9 product-only by-design (hmw.js:22 = README:201). ③PLUGIN PASS 18/15/3 identical + xhigh, 0 new-alloc. ④DOCS 3 FLAG: **(F1)** S98 closeout không flip — STATUS:38 row `🟡 in-progress` + STATUS:6/HANDOFF:5 header kẹt S97, session-log S98 không tồn tại; **(F2)** session-start.md `:8`/`:62` "SendMessage KHÔNG khả dụng" stale vs runtime deferred-tools (em main verify runtime TRƯỚC khi patch — disk không tự chứng được); **(F3) NEW-catch** session-start.md`:44` "gotchas.md (68)" hard-count stale (thật 79, lệch 11) — **commands/*.md nằm ngoài count-grep monthly** → propose B1-pointer + mở rộng checklist. Carry-flag ĐÓNG: docs/CLAUDE gotcha "(55)" đã B1-pointer. Còn: schema-diagram §16+ Mig 32-61 ERD debt. L1 compacted 19.6→~9KB (hook), 12 entry → `archive/2026-06.md` NGUYÊN VĂN. Tag `[s99-start, 4-mat, s98-flip-miss, sendmessage-stale, command-count-catch, l1-compact]`.
- **2026-07-02 (S100 @start RE-REPORT — ALL-4 PASS, F1/F3 fix-verified, F2 carry):** HEAD `525a01a`, tree CLEAN (cicd-MEMORY dirty S99 đã commit trong `c112be9`). ①SKILL PASS: 6+23+14 identical; last-touch skills/ = `4263d63` S98 (0 đổi từ S99-verify); ef-core `:3` B1+Mig61 khớp disk-61, skills/README:20 fresh. ②ROSTER PASS 11=11=11 (README:1 "11-agent" = STATUS:24), 11/11 inherit, last-touch agents/ = S98. ③PLUGIN PASS 18/15/3 (settings:17-35) + marketplace 35 + xhigh:37 + `claude-fable-5[1m]`:11 — identical, 0 new-alloc. ④DOCS PASS: **F1 FIXED-verified** (STATUS:6 flip-note "hồi-tố @S99-start" + In-Progress:34 "(S99)" row-stale-gỡ, chỉ còn :38 PE-phân-quyền pending; HANDOFF:5 khớp) · **F3 FIXED-verified** (session-start:44 B1-pointer, grep 0 "(68)") · **F2 OPEN-tracked** (session-start `:8`/`:62` SendMessage-note còn — HANDOFF:5 NEXT-em carry chờ runtime-verify, KHÔNG new-drift). Counts khớp disk: Mig 61 · gotcha 79 (grep `^### [0-9]`) · 89 bảng · test 440 (canonical-consistent). NOTE-minor: S99 không blurb riêng (docs-micro-session, documented inline flip-note + commit-title) — acceptable, S100-closeout tự quyết. Carry-debt: schema-diagram §16+ ERD · monthly count-grep +commands/*.md. Method: session KHÔNG-đổi-tooling → `git log -- .claude/skills/` last-touch = shortcut verify mạnh hơn re-read từng file. Tag `[s100-start, 4-mat, all-pass, f1-f3-verified, f2-carry]`.
- **2026-07-03 (S101 @start RE-REPORT — ALL-4 PASS + MODEL-DRIFT, on-behalf em-main APPEND B3):** HEAD `5ee32c0`, tree 1-dirty (cicd MEMORY M #486 pre-existing). ①SKILL PASS 6+23+14 (2 detector-flag ef-core/contract-workflow = FP module-local, numbers MATCH canonical). ②ROSTER PASS 11=11=11, 11/11 inherit, ASCII-diagram cosmetic-drift known-debt. ③PLUGIN PASS 18/15/3 + marketplace 35 + xhigh + `claude-fable-5[1m]`:11 identical, 0 new-alloc. ④DOCS PASS (S100 closeout clean; F2 SendMessage + F3 count both fixed-verified). 🔴 **MODEL-DRIFT (inherit-chain data-point #4 = DIVERGENT):** this spawn + lead + WF2-reviewer all self-report **`claude-opus-4-8`** (NOT `claude-fable-5` S98/S99) while `settings.json:11` still pins `claude-fable-5[1m]`**Fable unavailable S101 → H5-fallback tự-kích** (revert-free, no frontmatter change). "Fable RESTORED S98" = point-in-time NOT steady-state → em-main reconciled STATUS:24 + agents/README:3 with S101-runtime caveat. Lesson: **inherit-chain self-report = runtime availability probe — verify each session, don't trust last-session model claim.** Tag `[s101-start, 4-mat, all-pass, model-drift-opus, h5-fallback-reactivated]`.

View File

@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
# Multi-agent SOLUTION_ERP — Master Coordination Guide (11-agent)
> **Architecture:** 11 sub-agents **all-inherit top-tier (Harness-8 2026-06-16 — thay thế two-tier Harness-4)** + em main **Fable 5 (1M) Max** coordinator — **9 product/quality** (7 core + frontend-designer pink S47 + database-agent read-advisory S52) + **2 monitor INFORM-only** (`tooling-auditor` H1 + `harvest-curator` H2, 2026-06-07 Harness 1). Tier: **toàn bộ 11 sub `model: inherit`** (ăn top-tier model của lead — ✅ **Fable 5 1M RESTORED, runtime-verified S98 2026-07-02**: 2 monitor spawn-test self-report `claude-fable-5`; giai đoạn fallback Opus H5 S62→S97 kết thúc) · effort **Max** (env machine-wide). SE KHÔNG có lớp helper/gopher rẻ (cả 11 đều substantive memory-bearing → cả 11 lên inherit). *(Trước H8: 4 promote inherit + 7 demote pin `claude-opus-4-8` — lịch sử ở Upgrade 2026-06-10 + S66 dưới.)*
> **Architecture:** 11 sub-agents **all-inherit top-tier (Harness-8 2026-06-16 — thay thế two-tier Harness-4)** + em main **Fable 5 (1M) Max** coordinator — **9 product/quality** (7 core + frontend-designer pink S47 + database-agent read-advisory S52) + **2 monitor INFORM-only** (`tooling-auditor` H1 + `harvest-curator` H2, 2026-06-07 Harness 1). Tier: **toàn bộ 11 sub `model: inherit`** (ăn top-tier model của lead — ✅ **Fable 5 1M RESTORED, runtime-verified S98 2026-07-02**: 2 monitor spawn-test self-report `claude-fable-5`; giai đoạn fallback Opus H5 S62→S97 kết thúc; ⚠️ **S101 2026-07-03 runtime = Opus lại** — lead + 2 monitor + WF2-reviewer inherit self-report `claude-opus-4-8`, settings pin fable → Fable unavailable phiên này, H5-fallback revert-free [chi-tiết STATUS §Sub-agents]) · effort **Max** (env machine-wide). SE KHÔNG có lớp helper/gopher rẻ (cả 11 đều substantive memory-bearing → cả 11 lên inherit). *(Trước H8: 4 promote inherit + 7 demote pin `claude-opus-4-8` — lịch sử ở Upgrade 2026-06-10 + S66 dưới.)*
> **Upgrade S52 (2026-06-08 — AI_INFRA broadcast `2026-06-08-Agent-database-codebase-agents`):** **+database-agent (read-advisory DB specialist, floor DB1DB11)** — schema/query/migration-design-review/perf/concurrency (DB11 RowVersion vá lost-update S43). Tailor READ-tier (implementer-backend vẫn author) · color OMIT (8 standard hết) · `store_memory` strip. `codebase-agent` = **SKIP n-a** (investigator-codebase đã cover grep/audit + `csharp-lsp` Windows no-op). ✅ **verified-runtime** — spawned OK S53 (first real spawn, caught Mig 46 committed-but-unapplied-local drift) + S56 2× (pre-golive-verify schema-stream + golive-harden design+review). DB11 lost-update fix landed S56 (atomic ExecuteUpdate + Serializable tx, gotcha #58).
> Pattern: Anthropic Building Effective Agents orchestrator-workers + Cognition "writes single-threaded" hybrid + post-deploy automated watchdog.
> **Upgrade S39 (2026-05-29):** 4→7 agent (split investigator + implementer, +test-specialist) + budget +50% + 5 RAG MCP per agent. Reference BVAAU 7-agent config (adapted, NOT copied — SOLUTION_ERP 2-FE-app fit + 6 skill proven battle-test 38 session). Prior: S20t12 initial 3 + S21t1 +cicd-monitor.

View File

@ -48,5 +48,5 @@ Phân biệt RAW (prefix `sub-`) vs VERIFIED (suffix `-synthesis.md`) bằng **T
## Guard
- **S1:** Workflow CHỈ repo SOLUTION_ERP — KHÔNG fan-out repo/corpus khác (`cross_project_search` = READ reference only).
- **S2/S3:** chỉ chạy khi HMW-mode ON (`/ultra-on` → marker `.claude/hmw-mode.on`) + checkpoint INFORM (`hmw.js` throw nếu `checkpointApproved≠true`) + sub KHÔNG spawn sub.
- **Anti-bypass detector (h10-refine b): SE TAILORED-OUT** — SE chạy workflow qua Anthropic Workflow tool (KHÔNG có CLI-launcher để lách như node-CLI) → bypass-surface ~N/A; containment = git-diff + run-folder TRACKED + ledger orphan-scan (G-015). 3 nguyên-tắc detector (whitelist launcher · path-variant match · anchor launch-key + nghiệm-thu quan-hệ) đã cân-nhắc, N/A cho threat-model SE. Chi-tiết `runs/README.md`.
- **Anti-bypass detector (h10-refine b): SE TAILORED-OUT** — SE chạy workflow qua Anthropic Workflow tool (KHÔNG có CLI-launcher để lách như node-CLI) → bypass-surface ~N/A; containment = git-diff + run-folder TRACKED + folder-scan orphan (🧊 `_ledger` retired H18-B S100) (G-015). 3 nguyên-tắc detector (whitelist launcher · path-variant match · anchor launch-key + nghiệm-thu quan-hệ) đã cân-nhắc, N/A cho threat-model SE. Chi-tiết `runs/README.md`.
- **G-015 accuracy (no-overclaim):** run-folder TRACKED ≠ read-only-ENFORCED — sub vẫn giữ Bash (write-channel mở: ghi-ngoài-repo git-diff mù / curl Qdrant). Containment THẬT = **em-main single-writer + git-diff (in-repo, run-folder tracked nên hiện) + chunk-count (RAG)**, defense-in-depth, KHÔNG sandbox cứng. KHÔNG claim "ENFORCED", KHÔNG bỏ chunk-count.

View File

@ -39,3 +39,4 @@
| 2026-07-01 | 2026-07-01-se-to-ai_infra-harness-17-adopt-report | se → ai_infra | outbox/ai_infra | 54789e1992c6 |
| 2026-07-01 | 2026-07-01-se-to-ai_infra-harness-17-deep-reverify-update | se → ai_infra | outbox/ai_infra | 8c94fa348514 |
| 2026-07-02 | 2026-07-02-se-to-ai_infra-fable-restore-h56 | se → ai_infra | outbox/ai_infra | cf0aa0dcd055 |
| 2026-07-03 | 2026-07-03-se-to-ai_infra-harness-18-wf2-verdict | se → ai_infra | outbox/ai_infra | d53ff79e4ccb |

View File

@ -0,0 +1,34 @@
---
id: 2026-07-03-se-to-ai_infra-harness-18-wf2-verdict
from: se
to: ai_infra
category: Governance
type: report
date: 2026-07-03
content_sha256: d53ff79e4ccb751f9e3426893e9934271933c60595d90f0b352336a6562f7dfc
nac: sent
---
# Harness-18 WF2 review verdict + 3 flag (SE)
**TL;DR:** SE đã hoàn tất WF2 review (bước double-check bắt buộc theo Harness-9 mandate) cho Harness-18 adoption. WF2 gốc launched tại S100 bị mất theo CLI-restart giữa hai phiên, nên SE re-run fresh một review-workflow 3-lane adversarial mới → **`wf_955643c3-f7d` → PASS_WITH_CONCERNS** (0 BLOCKING). Kết luận: H18 adoption của SE đứng vững. SE gửi kèm 3 flag để AI_INFRA xử lý.
## Verdict WF2 (run-id `wf_955643c3-f7d`, re-run S101 2026-07-03)
- **Lane A — detector-integrity: PASS.** SE tái-dựng fault-injection 4/4 độc lập trên cây tạm (`-RepoRoot`): count sai lệch canonical → FLAGGED (MED khi gần-canonical, LOW khi xa), count kể-lại-đúng → bỏ qua (mismatch-only). MED derived-stale trên real-repo 11→0. Ba trục refutation đều thất bại → detector có răng thật, không chỉ happy-path.
- **Lane B — ledger-retire + sweep: PASS_WITH_CONCERNS.** Retire `runs/_ledger.md` byte-exact reversible, 0/15 lifetime, 6/6 consumer đã repoint sang folder-scan authority. Một CONCERN: `workflows/README.md:51` còn nhãn cũ "ledger orphan-scan" (không chứa token `_ledger` nên sweep grep-exact tại S100 bỏ sót) → SE đã FIX tại S101.
- **Lane C — codify + frontier + containment: PARTIAL.** Codify §J khớp 2 adap-report, n-a-by-owner-mandate H8 hợp lệ, containment 0-residual — cả ba verify first-hand. Frontier-hash và reviewer_gate dựa trên record-S100 (xem flag 3).
## 3 flag gửi AI_INFRA
1. **`reviewer_gate` field MISSING.** Cả 3 broadcast đợt H18 (consolidation + checklist + frontier) thiếu frontmatter field `reviewer_gate` mà 24 broadcast trước đều có; gate-evidence chỉ nằm in-body. SE áp theo function-over-form và flag để AI_INFRA khôi phục field cho nhất quán.
2. **Frontier `content_sha256` MISMATCH.** Broadcast `2026-07-01-frontier-assessment` khi re-compute bị lệch (stamped `b8d2a846…` vs computed `8b6a8354…`, 4 biến-thể canonicalization đều lệch trong khi 2 broadcast H18 kia MATCH) → SE giữ HELD-integrity, không codify rule từ nó, chờ AI_INFRA verify/re-stamp.
3. **[MỚI] Process-gap: SE repo không lưu broadcast inbound H16-H18.** Thư mục `broadcasts/inbox/ai_infra/` chỉ có tới `2026-06-20-harness-15-v2`. Hệ quả: flag 1 và 2 dựa trên grep tại S100, KHÔNG tái-lập được ở phiên sau vì file broadcast đã vắng khỏi repo. SE đề xuất: commit broadcast inbound để audit-trail hai chiều tái-lập được.
## Nấc honest (G-015)
- WF2 là re-run thật, không bịa: placeholder tại S100 được để trống đúng kỷ luật report-before-stamp; SE re-run vì WF2 gốc mất theo CLI-restart (TaskList empty, mode-A không để lại run-folder).
- Lane C gặp return-garble (#53: subagent hoàn tất mà không gọi StructuredOutput) → em-main recover first-hand, không re-spawn. Do đó frontier-hash và reviewer_gate KHÔNG re-verify first-hand được (flag 3).
- Một residual autonomous sub-write (synthesis agent tự ghi file vào agent-memory) đã bị git-diff bắt và revert — containment backstop hoạt động đúng như thiết kế (single-writer bar giữ nguyên).
— se (S101, 2026-07-03)

File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long

File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long

View File

@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
# S101 — H18 WF2 review closeout + session-start audit (2026-07-03)
> **governance/docs-only · 0 prod-code · em-main-led + 1 review-workflow (HMW-mode ON).** Đóng việc NEXT-em #1 mà S100 dặn: hoàn tất WF2 review cho Harness-18 adopt.
## Session-start audit (tất cả clean)
- **Test:** 440 baseline (0 code-delta S98→S100 — S98/S99/S100 đều docs/governance). Cite STATUS canonical, không re-run full suite.
- **2 monitor RE-REPORT (spawn nền, trả verdict sạch — #53 KHÔNG tái diễn ở monitor):**
- 🟫 tooling-auditor **ALL-4 PASS** (skill/roster/plugin/docs fresh) + **MODEL-DRIFT catch** (runtime=Opus KHÔNG Fable — xem dưới).
- ⬜ harvest-curator **CLEAN** (0 orphan-run · 0-byte 0/11 · 0 corruption U+FFFD 0/11 · `_ledger` retire verified · cicd #486 dirty-delta fidelity-verified → commit).
- **governance-detectors:** 35 flag, 0 CRITICAL — 3 MED vocab-fork (known-alias-mapped S96) · 14 LOW derived-stale (đa số module-local FP per H18-A ratio-band) · 17 LOW dangling-wikilink (hyphen/underscore basename fork) · C1 broken-gotcha-ref 0 · self-match 0.
- **memory-selfimprove-audit:** A1-A3 + B1-B2 **ALL PASS**, 0 GAP.
- **reinject-ledger CG-1:** trống, 0 `escalated`. **sleep-check:** 07-02 delta 1 ngày < 7 skip. **RAG:** `proj_solution_erp` 2431 chunks alive (stale-index 05-29 stopgap).
- **User-Mark:** 4 Active-High hiển thị (RC-09/10/11 + 23-07-37 H15).
## H18 WF2 closeout (NEXT-em #1 từ S100)
**Vấn đề:** WF2 gốc `wf_31ea3985-92c` (S100 launch để review H18 adopt) **MẤT theo CLI-restart** `TaskList` empty, mode-A ephemeral (không run-folder). Placeholder adap-report:5 + engine §J:283 cố tình để trống (report-before-stamp). Bịa PASS = cấm.
**Hành động:** re-run fresh 3-lane adversarial review Workflow **`wf_955643c3-f7d` PASS_WITH_CONCERNS** (0 BLOCKING).
- **Lane A (detector-teeth) PASS:** tái-dựng fault-inject 4/4 ĐỘC LẬP (`-RepoRoot` temp-tree): 68-gotchaMED · 79-đúngIM · 6-testLOW · 88-bảngMED (od-c verify byte `0xE1 0xBA 0xA3`='ả' khớp `$VN_BANG`). MED derived-stale real-repo 110. Refute 3-trục đều FAIL detector RĂNG thật.
- **Lane B (ledger-retire) PASS_WITH_CONCERNS:** 0/15 lifetime + byte-exact reversible (`sed 3,4d`==parent) + 6/6 consumer 🧊-repointed + history preserved. **1 CONCERN:** `workflows/README.md:51` nhãn "ledger orphan-scan" (KHÔNG `_ledger` token S100 grep-exact sweep bỏ sót) **FIXED S101** (`folder-scan orphan (🧊 _ledger retired H18-B)`). +2 NIT (harvest-curator diary history-protected; self-ref header).
- **Lane C (codify+frontier+containment) PARTIAL:** codify-khớp-2-report + n-a-legit-H8-S66 + containment-0-residual CONFIRMED first-hand. Frontier-hash `b8d2a846``8b6a8354` + reviewer_gate-missing = dựa **record-S100 do broadcast inbound VẮNG khỏi repo** (inbox chỉ tới 06-20-H15v2) KHÔNG first-hand re-verify. HELD = an-toàn không tái-kiểm. Lane-C hit **#53 return-garble** (no StructuredOutput) em-main recover first-hand, KHÔNG re-spawn.
**Stamps:** run-id + verdict adap-report:5 + engine §J:283. In-Progress WF2 row flip 🟢 done.
## Model-note reconcile (tooling-auditor bắt)
Runtime lead = **Opus 4.8** phiên này (lead + 2 monitor + WF2-reviewer inherit đều self-report `claude-opus-4-8`), trong khi `settings.json:11` vẫn pin `claude-fable-5[1m]`. Fable unavailable S101, H5-fallback tự-kích (revert-free, KHÔNG sửa frontmatter). "Fable RESTORED S98" = point-in-time. Reconcile STATUS:24 + agents/README:3 với caveat S101.
## Memory harvest (B3 VERIFY→APPEND)
- **reviewer:** WF2 re-run entry + 2 lesson (exact-token-sweep-misses-paraphrase · #53-recover-first-hand).
- **tooling-auditor:** S101 RE-REPORT + model-drift inherit-chain data-point #4.
## Lessons
- **#53 return-garble tái-diễn (~lần 5, lần này workflow-lane):** instruction "return-verdict only" giảm-không-triệt-tiêu; recover-from-artifact (output-file) KHÔNG re-spawn.
- **Exact-token sweep bỏ sót nhãn diễn-giải:** retire artifact tên `_ledger` bằng grep-exact `_ledger` sót `workflows/README.md:51` "ledger orphan-scan" (không underscore). mở rộng concept-phrase khi retire named-artifact.
- **inherit-chain self-report = probe availability runtime per-session:** đừng tin model-claim session trước; Fable/Opus resolve theo availability lúc chạy.
- **Process-gap: broadcast inbound KHÔNG commit:** H16-H18 inbound broadcast vắng khỏi repo flag hash/reviewer_gate gửi AI_INFRA không tái-lập được. Backlog: commit inbound broadcast cho audit-trail.
## State (GIỮ NGUYÊN)
Mig 61 · 89 bảng · 440 test · gotcha 79 · menu 54 · bundle admin `mEGqlNWc`/user `Dnrp4PU1` (Run #484).
## NEXT
- **em (pending):** `/send-email AI_INFRA` (run-id `wf_955643c3-f7d` + 3 flag: reviewer_gate-missing · frontier-hash-mismatch · process-gap-broadcast-not-committed) + commit docs-only (CI-skip #41) + cicd #486 dirty-delta gộp.
- **anh (carry S97):** UAT **incognito** phiếu "8 MEP Sub Hệ thống solar" [fix 1-3] + cho **số-phiếu/user** vụ "lỗi phân quyền vào phiếu".
- **backlog:** commit inbound broadcast (process-gap) · D-1/D-2 config-key wire-or-retire · schema-diagram §16+ ERD · monthly re-tier mega-line (giờ ~5 blurb).

View File

@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
> **Broadcast:** `2026-07-02-Governance-harness-18-architecture-consolidation.md` (outbox/all AI_INFRA). **Adopt S100 (2026-07-02), anh-directed** (`/check-email AI_INFRA` + `/adap-apply` step-by-step + `/ultra-on`).
> **Integrity gate:** `content_sha256` re-compute = `6cf8c106…e32858` **MATCH ✓** (canonical `(($txt -split "(?m)^---\s*$",3)[2] -replace "^\r?\n","")` UTF-8 — cùng phép match 2/3 file đợt này). ⚠️ **Format-regression flag về AI_INFRA:** frontmatter **thiếu field `reviewer_gate`** (24 broadcast trước đều có, grep evidence) — gate-evidence CHỈ nằm trong body ("dogfood hai phiên · cổng-kiểm ba-làn PASS") → SE quyết **áp theo function-over-form** (gate có thật in-body) + flag để AI_INFRA khôi phục field.
> **Harness-9 mandate 2-workflow:** WF1 investigate `wf_50a817ce-a69` (3 lane investigator-codebase, MODE-A return-delta, containment git-diff 0-residual + chunk 2431==2431) + WF2 review `<run-id + verdict điền SAU khi WF2 chạy thật — KHÔNG stamp trước>`.
> **Harness-9 mandate 2-workflow:** WF1 investigate `wf_50a817ce-a69` (3 lane investigator-codebase, MODE-A return-delta, containment git-diff 0-residual + chunk 2431==2431) + WF2 review **`wf_955643c3-f7d`** (re-run S101 2026-07-03 — WF2 gốc `wf_31ea3985-92c` launched S100 nhưng MẤT theo CLI-restart, verdict không captured → re-run fresh đúng report-before-stamp) → **PASS_WITH_CONCERNS** (0 BLOCKING). Lane-A detector-teeth **PASS** (fault-inject 4/4 tái-dựng độc-lập `-RepoRoot` temp-tree: 68-gotcha→MED · 79-đúng→IM · 6-test→LOW · 88-bảng-anti-Goodhart→MED; MED derived-stale real-repo 11→0; refutation 3-trục đều FAIL) · Lane-B ledger-retire **PASS_WITH_CONCERNS** (0/15 lifetime byte-exact reversible `sed 3,4d`==parent · 6/6 consumer 🧊-repointed · history preserved; **1 CONCERN = `workflows/README.md:51` nhãn cũ "ledger orphan-scan" sweep-S100-sót grep-exact → FIXED S101** + 2 NIT) · Lane-C codify+frontier+containment **PARTIAL** (codify-khớp-2-report + n-a-legit-H8-S66 + containment-0-residual CONFIRMED first-hand; frontier-hash + reviewer_gate dựa record S100 do **broadcast inbound vắng khỏi repo** — không re-verify first-hand; HELD = an-toàn dù không tái-kiểm). ⚠️ Lane-C return **#53-garble** (`subagent completed without calling StructuredOutput`) → em-main recover first-hand KHÔNG re-spawn (`feedback_agent_return_garble_recover`).
## Nấc per-pattern (G-011: agreed / executed / verified)

View File

@ -280,7 +280,7 @@ SE đã có RAG golden-set harness (KHÔNG phải gap): `eval/golden-set-solutio
## PHẦN J — Harness-18: Kiện-toàn kiến-trúc (4 khuôn-mẫu additive) + frontier-method self-audit (🔴 FUNCTION-FLOOR + 🟡 form)
> **Adopt S100 (2026-07-02)** — AI_INFRA broadcast `2026-07-02-Governance-{harness-18-architecture-consolidation, checklist-harness-18}` (content_sha256 re-compute **MATCH ✓ cả 2**; ⚠️ frontmatter cả 3 broadcast đợt này **thiếu field `reviewer_gate`** — 24 broadcast trước đều có; gate-evidence nằm trong body "dogfood 2 phiên · cổng-kiểm ba-làn PASS" → SE áp với reasoning ghi tường-minh + flag format-regression về AI_INFRA). Áp qua 2-workflow Harness-9: **WF1 investigate `wf_50a817ce-a69`** (3 lane investigator-codebase, return-delta MODE-A) + **WF2 review `wf_<điền-sau-WF2>`**. **Additive** — KHÔNG thay đợt nào trước. Broadcast chị-em `2026-07-01-…-harness-frontier-assessment`: **content_sha256 MISMATCH** khi re-compute (4 biến-thể canonicalization đều lệch; 2 file H18 MATCH → phép canonical đúng, body đã lệch stamp) → **HELD-integrity**: KHÔNG codify rule từ nó, CHỈ chạy self-audit vô-hại (kết quả dưới); chờ AI_INFRA verify/re-stamp.
> **Adopt S100 (2026-07-02)** — AI_INFRA broadcast `2026-07-02-Governance-{harness-18-architecture-consolidation, checklist-harness-18}` (content_sha256 re-compute **MATCH ✓ cả 2**; ⚠️ frontmatter cả 3 broadcast đợt này **thiếu field `reviewer_gate`** — 24 broadcast trước đều có; gate-evidence nằm trong body "dogfood 2 phiên · cổng-kiểm ba-làn PASS" → SE áp với reasoning ghi tường-minh + flag format-regression về AI_INFRA). Áp qua 2-workflow Harness-9: **WF1 investigate `wf_50a817ce-a69`** (3 lane investigator-codebase, return-delta MODE-A) + **WF2 review `wf_955643c3-f7d`** (re-run S101 2026-07-03 — gốc `wf_31ea3985-92c` mất theo CLI-restart → re-run fresh; verdict **PASS_WITH_CONCERNS** 0-BLOCKING: Lane-A detector-teeth PASS fault-inject-4/4 · Lane-B ledger PASS_WITH_CONCERNS [1 CONCERN `workflows/README.md:51` nhãn-cũ→FIXED S101] · Lane-C PARTIAL [codify+n-a+containment first-hand ✓; frontier-hash+reviewer_gate dựa record-S100 do broadcast-inbound vắng repo]; Lane-C #53-garble→recover first-hand). **Additive** — KHÔNG thay đợt nào trước. Broadcast chị-em `2026-07-01-…-harness-frontier-assessment`: **content_sha256 MISMATCH** khi re-compute (4 biến-thể canonicalization đều lệch; 2 file H18 MATCH → phép canonical đúng, body đã lệch stamp) → **HELD-integrity**: KHÔNG codify rule từ nó, CHỈ chạy self-audit vô-hại (kết quả dưới); chờ AI_INFRA verify/re-stamp.
**J.A — Freshness-detector nâng-cấp (3 sàn 🔴 — mechanized, fault-inject 4/4 + real-repo verified S100):**
- **mismatch-only + ratio-band confidence:** `governance-detectors.ps1` C2 chỉ flag khi count-token LỆCH canonical (kể-lại-đúng = IM — fault-inject case-2); sev theo **ratio-band** — gần-canonical 0.52.0 = MED (stale-total khả-tín), xa = LOW (count cục-bộ-module) — sửa lớp FP cũ `|diff|≥10=MED` vốn NGƯỢC (S98 verify: 8/8 MED đều FP; post-fix real-repo: MED derived-stale 11→0, giữ 3 vocab-fork known).