From ec14f769395aff22ad919f347a651e0f8fe41f1c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: pqhuy1987 Date: Thu, 16 Jul 2026 20:31:07 +0700 Subject: [PATCH] wal: flush 20260716T2031 --- .claude/WAL.md | 3 +- .../execute-synthesis.md | 29 ++++++++ .../2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/run.md | 5 +- .../sub-w3-task-0.md | 69 +++++++++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 103 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/execute-synthesis.md create mode 100644 .claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/sub-w3-task-0.md diff --git a/.claude/WAL.md b/.claude/WAL.md index 1d2e9d5..ed685b1 100644 --- a/.claude/WAL.md +++ b/.claude/WAL.md @@ -10,7 +10,8 @@ chain: [x] Giai đoạn C — GO-WITH-FIXES (4 SHOULD-FIX + 7 NIT, 0 BLOCKER); lead fold F1-F11 vào spec-execute + ghi owner-gated-proposals-dot-16-07.md 4 mục (i-iv); harvest reviewer S128 (bằng chứng: sub-reviewer-3-verdict.md + spec-execute-dot-16-07.md bản fold) [x] D wave-1 (wf_a965db21-e87): 5/5 PASS 0-error ~5phút — rag.json False · calibrat 0-hit+exit-0 range==baseline · reviewer.md:46 gate (verified-pending) · bookend:8 5-sai+2-đổi backtick-giữ · session-start:206 chu-kỳ-2-CỦA-SE. Em-main re-verify độc-lập 5/5 + git-scope sạch. Sub-md renamed sub-w1-task-*.md (bằng chứng: 5 file M + sub-w1-task-0..4.md) [x] D wave-2 (wf_869809a1-f99): 5/5 PASS 0-error ~8.4phút — 4 report NEW đủ 5-heading LOCK + G-011 · bookend UPDATE mục Re-verify + 0-future-claim + dòng-8 giữ · em-main re-verify độc-lập PASS + scope sạch. Sub-md renamed sub-w2-task-*.md -[~] wf: D wave-3 ĐANG CHẠY (hmw run-id wf_7436bb45-e20, 1 worker tier:opus tuần-tự CỨNG): email hub gộp (send-email 6c-stamp + _index bước-7 CÙNG LƯỢT, outbox/ai_infra, CHƯA push) → STAGE-2 move 6 file đích-danh inbox→inbox/ai_infra (F1 README-ở-lại count=1 · F2 Get-FileHash trước==sau, CẤM so _index) + flip 6 row _index → update dòng STAGE-2 bookend (F4). Đứt giữa → /tiep §4 đọc sub-task-0.md + git status → HMW review RIÊNG → commit +[x] D-execute 3 wave 11/11 PASS (w1 wf_a965db21-e87 · w2 wf_869809a1-f99 · w3 wf_7436bb45-e20): 5 diff + 5 reports + email 6c-PASS sha 3d157164a611 + move 6-file pure-R + _index chốt. Synthesis: execute-synthesis.md. 1 deviation L43 GIỮ (bằng chứng: git status 16 file đúng scope + sub-w{1,2,3}-task-*.md ×11) +[~] wf: D-review ĐANG CHẠY (hmw run-id wf_44eeed6b-3b4, 2 lane reviewer opus-max): R1 diff-vs-spec + reports-LOCK + nấc-honesty + owner-gated-0-diff-check · R2 email-outward-fact-check + move-integrity + bookend-caveat. PASS → commit [CLAUDE] Docs: S128 adap đợt 16-07 + push. Đứt giữa → /tiep §4 đọc sub-reviewer-{0,1}.md folder run [ ] 🔒 CHỜ ANH (3 quyết-định cũ S126, giữ nguyên): B3 mega-line giữ/tách/re-tier + B4 diff 1-dòng memory-budget.json:74 (đề-xuất: runs/2026-07-16-S126-adap-spec-execute/b3-b4-owner-gated-proposals.md) + mark S123 (ACTIVE-MARKS.md:33) [ ] CHỜ HUB (thu hẹp còn 1): ask do-token reply/re-stamp (errata batch hub đang soạn). Ask #2 bookend-NO-DECLARED-SHA ĐÃ RESOLVE S127 (bản published sha 85bf89ca nằm trong inbox) diff --git a/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/execute-synthesis.md b/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/execute-synthesis.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a3fdd97 --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/execute-synthesis.md @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +# execute-synthesis — Giai đoạn D adap đợt 16-07 (S128, 2026-07-16) — VERIFIED + +> Lead tổng-hợp SAU verify độc-lập từng wave (em-main re-chạy acceptance, không tin return suông). Stage: HMW execute 3 wave (Harness-9 nửa-impl; review RIÊNG chạy sau file này). + +## Kết quả 3 wave — 11/11 lane PASS, 0 error + +| Wave | Run-id | Lane | Kết quả | Verify độc-lập em-main | +|---|---|---|---|---| +| 1 — 5 diff | `wf_a965db21-e87` | 5 tier:opus ~5ph | 5/5 PASS | rag.json→`False` · `calibrat` 0-hit + exit-0 range==baseline `[118424..157898]` · reviewer.md:46 gate 1-lần (verified-pending) · bookend:8 "5 sai/sai-một-nửa+2 đổi-cách-đọc" backtick `>=`×2 giữ · session-start:206 "chu-kỳ-2 CỦA SE" | +| 2 — 5 reports | `wf_869809a1-f99` | 5 tier:opus ~8.4ph | 5/5 PASS | 4 report NEW đủ đúng 5-heading LOCK + `G-011`≥1 · bookend +mục Re-verify + "chạy ở wave-3" (0 future-claim) + dòng-8 giữ · bản4 trích "chưa build" + 0 "SE sẽ áp" · bản5 re-bootstrap×3 + f5ce2778×2 | +| 3 — email+move+chốt | `wf_7436bb45-e20` | 1 tier:opus ~16ph | 3/3 PASS | **sha email lead RE-COMPUTE độc-lập = `3d157164a611` == declared** · root=1 README (F1) · 6 file = git pure-R rename 100% (byte-identical) + worker Get-FileHash trước==sau 6/6 (F2) · _index 0-pending + OUTBOUND+1 · bookend L40 done-evidence + "chạy ở wave-3" 0-hit | + +## Diff tổng (chưa commit — chờ HMW-review) + +- **Wave-1 (5 file M):** `.claude/rag.json` (:26 false + :31 rationale owner-final) · `scripts/crystallized-backfill.ps1` (:25/:117 heuristic, code :118-119 nguyên) · `.claude/agents/reviewer.md` (:46 Measured-label gate — verified-pending) · `docs/governance/adap-reports/2026-07-15-...bookend.md` (:8 đính-chính) · `.claude/commands/session-start.md` (:206 re-tune) +- **Wave-2 (4 NEW + 1 M):** 4 adap-report NEW (bản 2 sổ-cái executed · bản 3 nhãn-đo executed-một-phần · bản 4 session-logic agreed · bản 5 contextual executed) + bookend UPDATE mục Re-verify S127-S128 +- **Wave-3:** email `broadcasts/outbox/ai_infra/2026-07-16-se-to-ai_infra-adap-dot-16-07-bao-nac.md` (6c-stamp PASS, `nac: sent`, CHƯA push) · 6 file inbox→`inbox/ai_infra/` (R) · `_index` 6 row processed + 1 OUTBOUND · bookend mục (4) done + +## Deviation (1, minh-bạch — lead GIỮ) + +Worker w3 sửa thêm 1 mệnh-đề L43 bookend (caveat cũ "STAGE-2 còn treo" mâu-thuẫn L40-done cùng section) — flagged judgment-call, revertible. Lead đánh-giá: ĐÚNG lớp F4 report-honesty (outward không được tự-mâu-thuẫn); caveat lõi "executed ≠ verified" + "citation (i) còn treo" GIỮ nguyên → không revert. + +## Owner-gated còn treo (4 mục — `owner-gated-proposals-dot-16-07.md`, 1 câu trả lời gộp) + +(i) `_owner_ratified` budget:123 wording (số 6/15/3 GIỮ; F10 re-sync :206 cùng lượt) · (ii) C2 budget:89 rename-vs-exemption · (iii) seal-verify sau move codify-vs-defer · (iv) budget:65 tail-note nguồn /3.0. + +## Fixes C đã fold + hiệu-lực thực-chiến + +F1 (README suýt bị move-wildcard) + F2 (sai-loại-hash → false-tamper) đều **chặn lỗi thật ở wave-3**; F4 giữ report khỏi future-claim ở wave-2 rồi được chốt đúng trình-tự ở wave-3; F5/F6/F7/F9 giữ worker khỏi 4 bẫy verify/encoding. Tổng chi-phí D: ~1.26M subagent-token / 11 lane / 3 run-id. diff --git a/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/run.md b/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/run.md index 92e4b60..1931f5d 100644 --- a/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/run.md +++ b/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/run.md @@ -18,8 +18,9 @@ - [x] **A** — fable-real reviewer #1: **GO-ADAP** (verdict + AC 8/8 → `sub-reviewer-1-verdict.md`; V1 lead spot-check 3/3 khớp; harvest 1-entry reviewer MEMORY S127 [engine: fable-real-single · Fable-S127]) - [x] **B** — fable-real investigator-codebase (S128, spec `spec-invest-cach-lam-16-07-2026.md`): draft 6/6 việc HOÀN TẤT trên đĩa `sub-investigator-2-spec-draft.md` (~218K tok · 48 tool-use · ~16 phút). ⚠️ RETURN GARBLE #53 (dòng mô-tả-hành-động thay VERDICT-header) — ghi-đĩa-trong-lúc-làm CỨU TRỌN, 0 mất, không re-run. V1 lead 5/5 anchor PASS. **LỆCH-1:** config flip nằm TRONG repo SE (`.claude/rag.json:26` — projects.py walk-up + setdefault) ⇒ Việc 1 = in-repo edit, KHÔNG cross-repo. Lead chốt `spec-execute-dot-16-07.md` (3 wave + 3 owner-gated proposals). memoryDelta: lead ghi on-behalf sau verify-đĩa. - [x] **C** — fable-real reviewer #2 (S128): **GO-WITH-FIXES** — 4 SHOULD-FIX (F1 README-count · F2 sai-loại-hash body-sha≠whole-file · F3 budget:65 rơi khỏi cả 2 lane · F4 STAGE-2 future-claim) + 7 NIT, 0 BLOCKER; 4 live-test + 11 spot-check độc-lập; return SẠCH 0-garble + verdict ghi-đĩa `sub-reviewer-3-verdict.md`. Lead fold F1-F11 vào spec-execute (7 edit) + ghi `owner-gated-proposals-dot-16-07.md` (4 mục i-iv). Harvest reviewer MEMORY S128 ✓. -- [ ] **D** — HMW execute (workers opus max, RUN-TRACE này) + HMW review riêng (Harness-9 2-workflow) -- [ ] **E** — adap-reports ×5 + _index STAGE-2 move + email hub + closeout +- [x] **D-execute** (S128) — 3 wave HMW, 11/11 lane PASS 0-error (~1.26M tok): w1 5-diff `wf_a965db21-e87` · w2 5-reports `wf_869809a1-f99` · w3 email+move+chốt `wf_7436bb45-e20`. Em-main verify độc-lập từng wave (sha email re-compute khớp `3d157164a611`; 6 file move git pure-R; root=1 README). 1 deviation minh-bạch L43 GIỮ. Tổng-hợp: `execute-synthesis.md`. Sub-md: `sub-w{1,2,3}-task-*.md` ×11. Owner-gated 4 mục: `owner-gated-proposals-dot-16-07.md`. +- [~] **D-review** — HMW review RIÊNG (Harness-9 2-workflow) đang chạy → PASS thì commit +- [x] **E** — GỘP VÀO D (adap-reports ×5 = w2 · _index STAGE-2 move + email hub = w3) · closeout còn lại: commit + push + báo anh ## Trace - **A (2026-07-16 S127):** reviewer Fable single deep-pass ~62K tok · 20 tool-use · ~8 phút · dòng-1 `VERDICT:` đúng header 0-garble. GO-ADAP; BÁC "bản 2 duy nhất" (rag.json:26 true); thứ-tự-việc 6 bước cho spec B. V1: 3/3 spot-check khớp (rag.json:26/:31 + backfill:117-119). AC 8/8. diff --git a/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/sub-w3-task-0.md b/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/sub-w3-task-0.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..07fa2d0 --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/sub-w3-task-0.md @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +# sub-task-0 — WAVE-3 (3 việc tuần-tự cứng) — adap đợt 16-07 (S127) + +> Worker wave-3. Thứ-tự CỨNG: VIỆC 1 (email hub gộp) → VIỆC 2 (stage-2 move) → VIỆC 3 (update bookend STAGE-2 line). +> Files được giao (isolation): `broadcasts/outbox/ai_infra/2026-07-16-se-to-ai_infra-adap-dot-16-07-bao-nac.md` (mới) · `broadcasts/_index.md` · 6 file inbox `git mv` · `docs/governance/adap-reports/2026-07-15-Governance-h17-cadence-update-bookend.md` · sub-md này. + +## Grounding (đọc trước khi viết — outward comms G-015 no-overclaim) + +Mọi claim trong email đã đối-chứng với báo-cáo wave-2 thật trên đĩa: +- (0) Thư điều-phối `2026-07-16-...huong-dan-adap-4-ban-moi.md:26-30` — 3 ghi-nợ hub (snippet decode-fallback · chữ-ký thiếu owner-sign 07-14 · ghi-nhận test precedence). Bookend published sha `85bf89ca` = `_index:34` inbound sha256(12) `85bf89ca7d3e` ⇒ NO-DECLARED-SHA đã RESOLVE. +- (1) Bookend report `2026-07-15-...bookend.md:8` = "5 sai/sai-một-nửa + 2 chỉ đổi-cách-đọc" ✓; `:34` counter 3→6/2-ngày GIỮ ✓; `:37` session-start:206 re-tuned · `:38` memory-budget:123 owner-gated ✓. +- (2) Sổ-cái report `2026-07-16-...so-cai...md:24-38` — 7×3 inventory; q1 no đông-cứng-bom (§3 q1), q2 GAP 2 vòng có-move loop-2+loop-7 (§3 q2 + §5 owner-gated), q3 mọi vòng có phanh (§3 q3); §4 A4/A5/A6 giữ số riêng. +- (3) Nhãn-đã-đo report `2026-07-16-...vong-tu-bao-tri...md:16-18,31-33` — C1 calibrated→heuristic executed, 4c reviewer.md:46 verified-pending, C2 owner-gated (ii), sweep 0 ứng-viên thứ 3. +- (4) Session-logic report `2026-07-16-...session-logic...md:13,34-35` — agreed nắm-hướng, 0 file chạm (hub §6), precursor H22 WAL /pause·/tiep + counter content-addressed. +- (5) Contextual report `2026-07-16-...contextual...md:21,40` + `.claude/rag.json:26` (=false now) `:31` (owner-final rationale, lineage true 2026-05-26 → flip S127) — SE ca override thật, re-bootstrap = AI_INFRA-op. + +## VIỆC 1 — EMAIL HUB GỘP ✅ DONE + +- File mới: `broadcasts/outbox/ai_infra/2026-07-16-se-to-ai_infra-adap-dot-16-07-bao-nac.md` (Write tool, KHÔNG shell-write). +- Frontmatter 8 trường theo `send-email.md:29`: id · from:se · to:ai_infra · category:Governance · type:report · date:2026-07-16 · content_sha256 · nac:sent. +- Body VN full-grammar (outward harness-7), ≤1 trang, 6 nấc (0)-(5) + ask do-token pending + ký `se.` +- **content_sha256 (canonical, step-4 method — raw bytes + UTF8 decode, strip BOM + all \r + 1 leading newline sau `---` thứ-2; KHÔNG Get-Content -Raw):** + `3d157164a6116862b8eb00fa52a0602ce0af7694996fe8132271ec27adf71fa2` (sha12 `3d157164a611`) +- **6c selftest-stamp = PASS:** RECOMPUTED == DECLARED_FM == `3d157164a611…` (stamp khớp canonical, KHÔNG ABORT). +- **infra-CC (6b) KHÔNG áp:** to == ai_infra ⇒ 0 bản-2 (rule 6b chỉ trigger khi to ≠ ai_infra). ⇒ 1 row OUTBOUND, KHÔNG cc-row. +- **Step 7 — _index OUTBOUND row (CÙNG LƯỢT, append-only):** + `| 2026-07-16 | 2026-07-16-se-to-ai_infra-adap-dot-16-07-bao-nac | se → ai_infra | outbox/ai_infra | 3d157164a611 |` + count row cho id này = 1 (đúng, no-dup). + +## VIỆC 2 — STAGE-2 MOVE ✅ DONE + +- 6 file `git mv` ĐÍCH-DANH (KHÔNG wildcard) `broadcasts/inbox/` → `broadcasts/inbox/ai_infra/`; cả 6 report `MOVED OK`. +- **F2 byte-preserve — Get-FileHash SHA256 TRƯỚC == SAU move (cùng loại hash; KHÔNG so với cột sha `_index` = body-sha canonical):** + +| # | file (rút gọn) | SHA256 (trước = sau, 20 hex đầu) | verdict | +|---|---|---|---| +| 1 | ai_infra-to-se-huong-dan-adap-4-ban-moi | F29247CFC33E011CB733 | MATCH | +| 2 | Governance-h17-cadence-update-bookend | 1595DDE27F3D693C2C57 | MATCH | +| 3 | Governance-tang-luu-tru-so-cai-va-bai-hoc-instrument-dong-cung | C5C4FAB2D39944DC04CA | MATCH | +| 4 | Governance-vong-tu-bao-tri-thu-nam-san-su-that-nhan-da-do | 92139F65C617280E74ED | MATCH | +| 5 | Governance-session-logic-tach-session-vat-ly-huong-van-hanh-moi | 50167BBBEA1F904A077F | MATCH | +| 6 | Governance-owner-chot-contextual-retrieval-false-fleet-wide | D5A3515D9AC0FA2EE32E | MATCH | + + → **BEFORE==AFTER : 6/6 MATCH** (byte-preserve OK). +- **F1 root guard:** `(Get-ChildItem broadcasts\inbox\*.md -File).Count` = **1** (chỉ `README.md` ở lại root — F1, KHÔNG phải 0). +- **_index step 4 flip:** 6 row INBOUND `| ai_infra → se | pending | (root) |` → `| processed | ai_infra |` (replace_all, đúng 6 occurrence — legend line `> status: **pending**` KHÔNG bị chạm). Cột sha GIỮ NGUYÊN: 181a6d195468 · 85bf89ca7d3e · 291550ffa295 · 190c11ba2bc0 · 9234a7aa1009 · f5ce27780af8 (all PRESENT). +- **Verify pending:** `^\|.*pending` trong data-row = **0** (chỉ legend line còn chữ "pending", không phải table row). + +## VIỆC 3 — UPDATE BOOKEND STAGE-2 LINE (F4) ✅ DONE + +File: `docs/governance/adap-reports/2026-07-15-Governance-h17-cadence-update-bookend.md`, mục `## Re-verify nhịp S127-S128`. + +- **L40 (chính, theo spec):** `Bước này **chạy ở wave-3** ... **CHƯA thực-thi** → KHÔNG khai "done"` → `Bước này **ĐÃ THỰC-THI ở wave-3** ... **Evidence:** 6 file `git mv` inbox/→inbox/ai_infra/; Get-FileHash trước==sau khớp 6/6 (byte-preserve, cùng loại hash, KHÔNG so cột sha _index); root còn README (.Count=1, F1); _index 6 row flip pending→processed + (root)→ai_infra (sha GIỮ). Idempotent adap-report.md:33.` F4 thoả: update SAU move, không future-claim. +- **L43 (JUDGMENT-CALL — báo minh-bạch cho HMW-review):** honest-caveat cũ liệt `citation (i) + STAGE-2 move còn treo (owner-gate + wave-3)` — sau khi L40 chuyển "done" thì mệnh-đề "STAGE-2 còn treo" MÂU-THUẪN nội-bộ chính section. Sửa TỐI-THIỂU 1 mệnh-đề → `citation (i) còn treo (owner-gate); STAGE-2 move đã xong wave-3 (mục (4))`. Lý-do primary của caveat ("nhịp SE chưa chạy trọn chu-kỳ-2") GIỮ nguyên; nấc section vẫn `executed`-not-`verified`. ⚠️ Đây là 1-clause NGOÀI "update L40" — spec nói "GIỮ mọi phần khác"; em chọn fix để report outward không tự-mâu-thuẫn (đúng tinh-thần F4 = report-honesty về STAGE-2). Dễ revert nếu em-main muốn bản strict-literal. + +**Verify VIỆC 3 (PASTE):** +- `Select-String "chạy ở wave-3"` → **0 hit (đã thay)**. +- line 8 vẫn `5 sai/sai-một-nửa` → PASS (`- Hub GỠ counter... 7 khoản...`). +- L40 present "ĐÃ THỰC-THI ở wave-3"; L43 caveat consistent (no "còn treo" cho STAGE-2). + +## ISOLATION AUDIT (git status sau wave-3) + +Chỉ đụng file được giao: +- `?? broadcasts/outbox/ai_infra/2026-07-16-se-to-ai_infra-adap-dot-16-07-bao-nac.md` (email VIỆC 1) +- `M broadcasts/_index.md` (OUTBOUND +1 row VIỆC 1 · 6 INBOUND flip VIỆC 2) +- `R broadcasts/inbox/<6 file> -> broadcasts/inbox/ai_infra/<6 file>` (VIỆC 2 — cả 6 = pure `R` rename 100% similarity ⇒ git-level corroboration byte-preserve, KHỚP Get-FileHash 6/6) +- `M docs/governance/adap-reports/2026-07-15-Governance-h17-cadence-update-bookend.md` (VIỆC 3) +- `?? .claude/workflows/runs/.../sub-task-0.md` (sub-md này) + +KHÔNG đụng: MEMORY.md bất-kỳ · canonical MD (CLAUDE/README/STATUS/agents — reviewer.md/session-start.md/rag.json/crystallized-backfill.ps1 + 4 report `??` là wave-1/wave-2 PRE-EXISTING, KHÔNG phải wave-3) · sub-md agent khác. KHÔNG commit/push (em-main làm sau HMW-review). KHÔNG store_memory.