[CLAUDE] Docs: S129 disposition owner-gated đợt 16-07 — (ii) bỏ trần giữ 1 số 100K hub-shape + (iv) provenance /3.0 + email hub a7aff375; (i)/(iii) CHỜ-HUB

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
pqhuy1987
2026-07-16 22:03:42 +07:00
parent 521565897b
commit 949ec33ee7
7 changed files with 72 additions and 26 deletions

View File

@ -1,22 +1,21 @@
# WAL — auto-generated, không sửa tay
updated: 2026-07-16 | session: S128 | branch: main
goal: Mạch adap ĐỢT BROADCAST 16-07 — HOÀN TẤT TRỌN (A✓ B✓ C✓ D-execute✓ D-review✓ commit 289ba96 PUSHED + cicd-monitor GO). Không còn mạch dở — chỉ còn carry chờ người (anh + hub).
updated: 2026-07-16 | session: S129 | branch: main
goal: Disposition 4 mục owner-gated đợt 16-07 (anh trả lời S129 tối, sau /tiep): ii+iv ÁP XONG, i+iii → CHỜ-HUB. Còn carry chờ người: 3 mục S126 (anh) + đợt hub-land (broadcast).
chain:
[x] A fable-reviewer#1 GO-ADAP · B fable-invest draft 6/6 việc (garble #53 — ghi-đĩa-trong-lúc-làm cứu trọn, V1 lead 5/5) · C fable-reviewer#2 GO-WITH-FIXES → fold F1-F11 (bằng chứng: runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/{sub-reviewer-1-verdict,sub-investigator-2-spec-draft,sub-reviewer-3-verdict,spec-execute-dot-16-07}.md)
[x] D-execute 3-wave HMW 11/11 PASS (wf_a965db21-e87 · wf_869809a1-f99 · wf_7436bb45-e20): 5 diff + 5 adap-reports + email 6c + STAGE-2 move 6-file hash-preserve (bằng chứng: execute-synthesis.md)
[x] D-review 2-lane reviewer GO-COMMIT 0-BLOCKER, owner-gated-0-diff CONFIRMED (wf_44eeed6b-3b4) + lead fold M1 + lineage-05-22 cùng-lớp 3-chỗ + re-stamp email c0ac7486447e (bằng chứng: review-synthesis.md + sub-reviewer-{0,1}.md)
[x] Commit 289ba96 PUSHED e9124fc..289ba96 (24 file +474/40) + cicd-monitor GO: run 509/#395 status=success · gate 509 exact (45+464, 0 fail) · smoke ALL 200 (/health/live) · bundle rotate benign #69 (0 fe-src) · NO-BE/NO-Mig (bằng chứng: git log -1 289ba96 + MEMORY cicd-monitor entry S128 + em-main corroborate Gitea-API + curl độc-lập)
[x] Curate reviewer L1 20.3→16.8KB (move-not-cut + seal-verify 3/3 md5 e5218d2f45b6) + residual cicd-monitor xử: return garble #53 (×22) nhưng verdict nằm MEMORY nó tự ghi = WRITE-lane-garble; moved-not-cut 2/2 PASS + CRLF→LF 2 archive + entry GIỮ (bằng chứng: archive/2026-07.md batch-marker S128 ×2 repo-path)
[ ] 🔒 CHỜ ANH — 7 mục: 4 owner-gated đợt 16-07 (i wording _owner_ratified budget:123 · ii C2 rename-vs-exemption budget:89 · iii seal-verify codify-vs-defer · iv budget:65 tail-note) 1-câu-gộp tại runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/owner-gated-proposals-dot-16-07.md + 3 cũ S126 (B3 mega-line · B4 diff memory-budget.json:74 · mark S123 ACTIVE-MARKS.md:33)
[ ] CHỜ HUB: ask do-token pending (errata batch hub đang soạn — đừng đóng sớm). Note lượt sau: recipe body-sha strip-1 vs strip-ALL (2 biến-thể theo phía phát-hành — sub-reviewer-1.md §tooling-note) = ứng-viên adap-request/hỏi hub.
[x] /tiep recovery S129: Sàn-3 4-tín-hiệu soi xong (④ corroborate run S127), verify 6/6 PASS, WAL khớp ground-truth. Trình 7 mục chờ-anh → anh trả lời 4 mục đợt 16-07 (i hub-side · ii bỏ-trần-giữ-cao-nhất · iii hub-đang-làm · iv OK-thống-nhất-hub)
[x] check-email ai_infra: 0 lệch hash outbox-vs-inbox, 0 chưa-nhận. Nắm được: hub s101 ĐANG gate 2 errata (wf_bcc43445-583) + do-token draft 07-15 = trả-lời ask SE + hub P1.3 reply-nợ có mục SE (xác-nhận (i) "chưa broadcast" ĐÚNG) + hub budget shape 1-số-floor (_floor_reserve_tok 100000)
[x] (ii) ÁP: XOÁ measured_token_estimate + _s112_remeasure_note, GIỮ rounded_up_tokens 100000 DUY-NHẤT (hub-shape); (iv) ÁP: đuôi provenance token_estimate + neo do-token method. JSON parse PASS + assert vùng-giữ (_owner_ratified + _target_note B4) NGUYÊN-VẸN. Verbatim archive + DISPOSITION 4-dòng: runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/owner-gated-proposals-dot-16-07.md
[x] 2 adap-report live cập-nhật nấc: vong-tu-bao-tri (ii/iv agreed→executed S129, bảng 3.1 sync) + do-token (S129 addendum retire-not-remeasure)
[x] Email hub disposition (2026-07-16-se-to-ai_infra-disposition-owner-gated-dot-16-07) + _index OUTBOUND + commit PUSHED
[ ] 🔒 CHỜ ANH — 3 mục S126: B3 mega-line giữ/tách/re-tier (em khuyến-nghị #3 re-tier) · B4 diff _target_note wording ("real-token headroom"→"cận-trên heuristic-notice", 2 biến-thể VN/EN) · mark-S123 ACTIVE-MARKS.md:33 (⚠️ dấu-hiệu ĐÃ-chốt-rồi — mark RC-…17-23-10 tồn-tại dòng 25+28 — anh confirm 1 chữ là gỡ carry)
[ ] CHỜ HUB (adopt-on-broadcast khi land, verify hash trước áp): (i) lời-chốt anh cho _owner_ratified (hub P1.3 reply-nợ) → áp theo CANONICAL hub + re-sync F10 session-start.md:206 · (iii) seal-verify khuôn hub · 2 errata EOL-metric + tong-hop-7-lop (đang gate wf_bcc43445) · do-token letter (ask SE giữ MỞ — đừng đóng sớm) · recipe body-sha strip-1 vs strip-ALL (ứng-viên adap-request, sub-reviewer-1.md §tooling-note)
next: Khi anh trả lời 4 mục owner-gated → apply diff soạn-sẵn trong proposals-file + re-sync F10 (session-start.md:206 kể theo wording mới) + báo hub 1 dòng.
next: Hub broadcast land → /check-email nhận+verify hash → áp (i) theo canonical + re-sync F10 + adap 2 errata + đóng ask do-token. Anh chốt 3 mục S126 → apply theo b3-b4-owner-gated-proposals.md + gỡ mark-S123 carry nếu confirm.
verify:
- git log --oneline -1 → wal: pause đầu
- git log --format='%s' origin/main..HEAD | grep -v '^wal:' → rỗng (mọi việc thật đã PUSH ở 289ba96)
- Test-Path .claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/execute-synthesis.md → True (run KHÔNG orphan — bản-ghi-kết-quả dạng-1 flat)
- python -c "import json; print(json.load(open(r'.claude/rag.json',encoding='utf-8'))['contextual_retrieval'])" → False
- (Get-ChildItem broadcasts\inbox\*.md -File).Count → 1 (chỉ README — STAGE-2 đã move 6 file vào inbox/ai_infra/)
- Select-String -Pattern "c0ac7486447e" -Path broadcasts\_index.md -Quiet → True (email hub stamped + logged OUTBOUND)
- python -c "import json; d=json.load(open(r'.claude/agent-memory/memory-budget.json',encoding='utf-8'))['harness_floor']; print('measured_token_estimate' not in d, d['rounded_up_tokens'])" → True 100000
- Select-String -Pattern "DISPOSITION" -Path .claude\workflows\runs\2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07\owner-gated-proposals-dot-16-07.md -Quiet → True
- Select-String -Pattern "S129 ADDENDUM" -Path docs\governance\adap-reports\2026-07-15-Governance-do-token-that-khong-can-api-key.md -Quiet → True
- git log --format='%s' origin/main..HEAD | grep -v '^wal:' → rỗng (sau push)
- (Get-ChildItem broadcasts\inbox\*.md -File).Count → 1 (chỉ README — chưa có broadcast mới từ hub)

View File

@ -62,7 +62,7 @@
"sample_questions": "eval/mfe/sample-questions.json",
"state_file": ".claude/agent-memory/.mfe-state.json",
"honest_caveats": {
"token_estimate": "char/4 is NOT real tokenization; VN-diacritic hot-memory ~3.0-3.5 byte/tok; report a RANGE [bytes/4 .. bytes/3.0]; FIT verdict uses bytes/3.0 (worst-case). Real tokenizer count lies inside the band -- never a single false-precise number.",
"token_estimate": "char/4 is NOT real tokenization; VN-diacritic hot-memory ~3.0-3.5 byte/tok (convention -- chua do tokenizer that tai SE; dinh-chinh 58f5afd8; real-N when it matters = harness Read-truncation notice per hub 'do token that' method, draft 2026-07-15, adopt-on-broadcast); report a RANGE [bytes/4 .. bytes/3.0]; FIT verdict uses bytes/3.0 (worst-case). Real tokenizer count lies inside the band -- never a single false-precise number.",
"judge_layer": "Branch-A recall/apply scorer is SCAFFOLD-only (empty). Self-grade same-session = meaningless (just read the answers). Numbers meaningful ONLY after (a) sample-questions mature in age AND (b) an independent cross-session/different-model judge scores.",
"age_band": "age is a FLAG, never a cut (mark RC-...10-29-11 age=false-proxy). An item drops only on status-change (mark->Disabled, guard->retired, AS row deleted), NOT by age.",
"read_only_scope": "MFE WRITES exactly one file: .claude/agent-memory/.mfe-state.json (its own strikes-state for cross-run Goodhart compare). 'READ-ONLY' is scoped to token_governor / the budget caps (owner-authority) which it NEVER writes -- it is NOT the claim 'writes nothing'."
@ -86,11 +86,9 @@
},
"harness_floor": {
"_note": "Harness-15 A1/A3 (S81, 2026-06-20): SAN-harness = fixed per-spawn cost (NOT tunable) = tool-schema + framing + own persona/role file + lead-pasted base-doc slice + task prompt. SEPARATE HOUSE (A3 anti-double-count): persona + lead-pasted-docs belong HERE (floor), NOT counted in token_governor.l1_always (which = own agent-memory + archive index + work-state block only). MEASURED-ESTIMATE not exact (H15 honest-note b): persona = directly measured bytes (.claude/agents/<name>.md 4.3KB-13.3KB => ~1.3K-4.0K tok via /3.3); tool-schema + framing = harness-injected (cannot byte-count locally), estimated comparable to AI_INFRA same-toolset-family (Read/Write/Edit/Bash/Grep/Glob/Skill/RAG).",
"measured_token_estimate": 55000,
"_s112_remeasure_note": "S112 (2026-07-12) RE-MEASURE — supersedes the S81 ~21K figure, which was a UNDER-COUNT (owner flagged 'why is SE so little vs sisters 60K+'). Byte-measured session-start DISK-inject floor = 57,595B (root CLAUDE.md 13,638 + docs/CLAUDE.md 10,222 + commands/session-start.md 23,669 + user-memory MEMORY.md 10,066) = ~14.4-19.2K tok ALONE. PLUS harness-INJECTED tool-schema + framing + MCP-instructions + deferred-tools + skills-catalog (~50 tool defs + 4 MCP blocks + ~90 deferred + ~60 skills), NOT byte-countable locally, ~30-50K tok. => FULL session-start floor ~45-70K tok, matching the fleet's measured ~60-71K (sister harness_floor_est @S103=71,364). The old 21K was the anomaly: S81 GUESSED the harness block at only ~5K(tool)+2K(framing) AND counted a small 'lead-pasted slice ~5-9K' instead of the full dual-CLAUDE.md + 23.7KB session-start body + user-memory inject. 55000 = honest mid estimate (~19K byte-measured + ~36K harness-injected-est). measured_token_estimate stays an ESTIMATE (harness block not locally byte-countable), not a false-precise number.",
"rounded_up_tokens": 100000,
"_owner_override_note": "S112 (2026-07-12) owner-directive: rounded_up_tokens raised 30000->100000 = OWNER-SET RESERVE (project-owner authority per token_governor.role_boundary_note + mark RC-pqhuy1987-21-06-2026-01-58-01), NOT a re-measurement (100K != a measured floor). NOTE: measured_token_estimate was subsequently re-measured 21000->55000 THIS SAME SESSION (S112, see _s112_remeasure_note) after the owner asked why SE's floor read so low vs sisters -- this override_note predates that re-measure; the live field is 55000. Rationale: reserve headroom for the grown fixed per-spawn overhead (roster 11->12 agents, +office-document, +2 monitor, more MCP tool-schemas, richer lead-pasted slices at the 380K read-set). CAVEAT (honest): harness_floor is an ACCOUNTING/AWARENESS figure (separate house, A3 anti-double-count) documented here; it is NOT actively subtracted by the current scripts (mfe-eval.ps1 / crystallized-backfill.ps1 govern via token_governor caps, not this floor). If owner wants 100K wired as an ACTIVE reserve subtracted from headroom, that is a separate change. Re-measure available on request to check the true current floor.",
"components_note": "persona(measured 1.3K-4.0K, DIRECTLY via Get-ChildItem byte-count of .claude/agents/*.md, NOT via measure-agent-memory.ps1 which only sizes agent-memory tiers) + tool-schema(est ~5K) + framing(est ~2K) + lead-pasted base-slice(est ~5-9K; em-main injects CLAUDE.md/README-slice + task ctx) + prompt(est ~1K). README decision-tree corpus = 32704B but em-main pastes a SLICE, not whole. The ~21K sum is SE's OWN reasoning over SE's OWN agents (persona byte-measured + each harness-injected sub-component estimated independently); it lands NEAR AI_INFRA's ~21K because the toolset family is identical (Read/Write/Edit/Bash/Grep/Glob/Skill/RAG), NOT because borrowed. SE's governing cap = 100K (owner-set reserve S112 2026-07-12; was 30K round-up), independent of AI_INFRA's figure."
"_owner_override_note": "S112 (2026-07-12) owner-directive: rounded_up_tokens raised 30000->100000 = OWNER-SET RESERVE (project-owner authority per token_governor.role_boundary_note + mark RC-pqhuy1987-21-06-2026-01-58-01), NOT a re-measurement (100K != a measured floor). Rationale: reserve headroom for the grown fixed per-spawn overhead (roster 11->12 agents, +office-document, +2 monitor, more MCP tool-schemas, richer lead-pasted slices at the 380K read-set). S129 (2026-07-16) owner-directive 'bo luon cac tran, chi giu tran cao nhat, thong nhat 1 cach voi hub': the parallel field measured_token_estimate RETIRED -- ONE floor number only, mirroring hub shape (hub _floor_reserve_tok = single 100000 + lineage-in-note, no stored parallel estimate; hub lineage ~21K measured -> anh-round 30K -> 60K s78 -> 100K s90). Retired-field history (verbatim archived at runs/2026-07-16-S127-adap-dot-16-07/owner-gated-proposals-dot-16-07.md disposition): S81 ~21K UNDER-COUNT -> S112 re-measure 55000 honest mid-estimate (~19K byte-measured disk-inject 57,595B + ~30-50K harness-injected est; full session-start floor band ~45-70K tok, fleet-parity ~60-71K). WHY retired: a stored 'measured/estimate' number invites the mislabel class (san-su-that 190c11ba; SE dinh-chinh 58f5afd8) -- when a real figure is needed, MEASURE FRESH via harness Read-truncation notice N (hub 'do token that khong can API key' method, draft 2026-07-15, adopt-on-broadcast), do NOT store-and-trust. CAVEAT (honest, unchanged): harness_floor is an ACCOUNTING/AWARENESS figure (separate house, A3 anti-double-count); it is NOT actively subtracted by the current scripts (mfe-eval.ps1 / crystallized-backfill.ps1 govern via token_governor caps, not this floor). If owner wants 100K wired as an ACTIVE reserve subtracted from headroom, that is a separate change. 0 script consumers of the retired field (grep-verified S127 + S129).",
"components_note": "floor COMPONENT LIST (what the fixed per-spawn cost consists of): persona (directly byte-measurable via Get-ChildItem .claude/agents/<name>.md 4.3KB-13.3KB => ~1.3K-4.0K tok; NOT via measure-agent-memory.ps1 which only sizes agent-memory tiers) + tool-schema + framing + lead-pasted base-slice (README decision-tree corpus = 32704B but em-main pastes a SLICE, not whole) + prompt -- the harness-injected parts are NOT byte-countable locally. Per-component S81 estimates and their ~21K sum = RETIRED history with the estimate field (owner 2026-07-16, see _owner_override_note). SE's governing number = rounded_up_tokens 100K (owner-set reserve S112), independent of AI_INFRA's figure (hub's 100K = their own measure+round, toolset family identical Read/Write/Edit/Bash/Grep/Glob/Skill/RAG)."
},
"token_governor": {
"_note": "Harness-15-v2 (S82, 2026-06-21): UPDATED by delta broadcast 2026-06-20-Governance-harness-15-v2-hot-feed-update (supersedes_scope = tier-1-sizing + L2/L3-caps ONLY; rest of H15 unchanged). TWO CHANGES vs S81: (1) Tier-1 = HOT-FEED LARGE per-role (was flat 12K -- too thin, caused lead to forget work across sessions); (2) L2/L3 caps REMOVED (on-demand, no artificial tier-limit, bounded only by model context window). Still the SECOND governor (token) ORTHOGONAL to the BYTE governor (tiers/archive_gate above) -- keep BOTH (B(e)); byte measures file-size-on-disk, token measures context-loaded; VN text ~3.0-3.5 byte/tok so byte/4 = upper bound => real headroom LARGER. Budget = MINIMUM-to-USE floor (FILL Tier-1 with real work-state up to the number; under-fill ONLY when high-value content exhausted; NEVER garbage-stuff -- token-saving = forgetting work).",

View File

@ -29,3 +29,25 @@
---
**1 câu trả lời gộp đủ:** (i) OK/sửa? · (ii) iii hay ii? · (iii) codify hay defer? · (iv) OK? — em apply 1 lượt + re-sync F10.
---
## 📋 DISPOSITION — anh trả lời 2026-07-16 tối (S129 /tiep), áp cùng lượt
> Anh reply trực-tiếp trong phiên + chỉ-thị "check-email của AI_INFRA để nắm thông tin chưa?" → em check-email (0 lệch outbox/se, 0 chưa-nhận) + đối-chiếu hub TRƯỚC khi áp: hub WAL s101 (đang gate 2 errata `wf_bcc43445-583`) · hub `memory-budget.json` (shape 1-số-floor `_floor_reserve_tok: 100000`) · 3 draft chưa-broadcast (`erratum-eol` · `tong-hop-loi-7-lop` · `do-token-that-khong-can-api-key`).
| Mục | Anh chốt (nguyên văn) | Xử-lý S129 |
|---|---|---|
| (i) wording `_owner_ratified` :123 | *"Việc này tao đã trả lời cho Hub rồi, chắc nó chưa broadcast"* | **KHÔNG áp diff local** — lời-chốt canonical của anh nằm phía hub, chờ broadcast (hub WAL s101 P1.3 "đợt-reply-nợ 5-khoản" có mục SE — xác-nhận "chưa broadcast" ĐÚNG). Diff soạn-sẵn ở trên GIỮ làm tham-chiếu, khi thư land thì áp theo bản canonical hub (bài `canonical-spec-over-broadcast` S79). F10 re-sync `session-start.md:206` defer cùng. → carry **CHỜ-HUB** |
| (ii) C2 `measured_token_estimate` :89 | *"Bỏ luôn các trần, chỉ giữ trần cao nhất"* (lối thứ 3 — gốc-rễ hơn cả rename lẫn exemption-note) | **ÁP:** XOÁ `measured_token_estimate: 55000` + `_s112_remeasure_note` (verbatim archive dưới); GIỮ DUY-NHẤT `rounded_up_tokens: 100000` = trần cao nhất (owner-reserve S112). Mirror **shape** hub: 1 số floor + lineage-in-note (hub `_floor_reserve_tok` 30K→60K s78→100K s90, không field ước-tính song-song; chính verb anh từng dùng ở hub s62 "bỏ luôn trần line đi"). Nhãn "measured" biến mất TẬN GỐC — hết class mislabel (190c11ba) cho field này. 0 script consumer (grep re-verify S129; docs nhắc field = lịch-sử đóng-băng runs/-session-log/-email-đã-stamp, không đụng). `components_note` trim phần "~21K sum" stale cùng lượt (view-residual-asym) |
| (iii) seal-verify codify-vs-defer | *"cái Hub đang làm."* | **DEFER + adopt-on-broadcast** — KHÔNG tự codify bản SE-riêng; hub đang chạy cơ-chế thật (stamp 2-nhịp `stamp_verify.py` + gate-outward reviewer ×2 + tầng lưu-trữ sổ-cái thư `291550ff`). Khi hub phát bản chuẩn → SE adap theo khuôn. → carry **CHỜ-HUB** |
| (iv) budget:65 tail-note /3.0 | *"OK, thống nhất 1 cách với Hub."* | **ÁP:** đuôi `(convention -- chua do tokenizer that tai SE; dinh-chinh 58f5afd8; real-N when it matters = harness Read-truncation notice per hub 'do token that' method, draft 2026-07-15, adopt-on-broadcast)`. "Thống nhất 1 cách" = neo cùng method-letter hub — draft 07-15 chính là trả-lời cho **ask do-token SE đang pending** (method: đọc `N` từ notice `(NNNNN tokens, cap 25000)`, tệp lớn dùng thẳng N, cấm chép số hub). Ask do-token GIỮ MỞ tới khi letter land chính-thức (đúng dặn "đừng đóng sớm") |
### Verbatim archive — 2 dòng XOÁ khỏi `memory-budget.json` (archive-trước-rewrite)
```json
"measured_token_estimate": 55000,
"_s112_remeasure_note": "S112 (2026-07-12) RE-MEASURE — supersedes the S81 ~21K figure, which was a UNDER-COUNT (owner flagged 'why is SE so little vs sisters 60K+'). Byte-measured session-start DISK-inject floor = 57,595B (root CLAUDE.md 13,638 + docs/CLAUDE.md 10,222 + commands/session-start.md 23,669 + user-memory MEMORY.md 10,066) = ~14.4-19.2K tok ALONE. PLUS harness-INJECTED tool-schema + framing + MCP-instructions + deferred-tools + skills-catalog (~50 tool defs + 4 MCP blocks + ~90 deferred + ~60 skills), NOT byte-countable locally, ~30-50K tok. => FULL session-start floor ~45-70K tok, matching the fleet's measured ~60-71K (sister harness_floor_est @S103=71,364). The old 21K was the anomaly: S81 GUESSED the harness block at only ~5K(tool)+2K(framing) AND counted a small 'lead-pasted slice ~5-9K' instead of the full dual-CLAUDE.md + 23.7KB session-start body + user-memory inject. 55000 = honest mid estimate (~19K byte-measured + ~36K harness-injected-est). measured_token_estimate stays an ESTIMATE (harness block not locally byte-countable), not a false-precise number.",
```
**3 mục S126 anh CHƯA trả lời lượt này (giữ carry CHỜ-ANH):** B3 mega-line giữ/tách/re-tier · B4 diff `:74` · mark-S123 `ACTIVE-MARKS.md:33` (⚠️ em phát-hiện dấu-hiệu ĐÃ-chốt-rồi — mark `RC-…17-23-10` tồn-tại — chờ anh confirm gỡ).