[CLAUDE] Docs: H-9+H-10+checklist FINALIZE double-check + G1 curate (anh: hoan chinh toan bo)
All checks were successful
Deploy SOLUTION_ERP / build-deploy (push) Successful in 5m23s

FINALIZE review wf_73de399d-753 (3 reviewer, R1/R2 no-StructuredOutput->self-gate, R3 thorough): audit 21 checklist item A1-A9/B1-B4/C1-C8 on-disk = 0 code-defect, adoption SOUND, 3 deferred-gap. Closed: G1 curate wf_f32987b8-03f (reviewer 36.7->24.8KB + investigator 29.8->23.2KB <25600 cap, archive +N -0 0-byte-loss, +reviewer-gist gen:2, budget.json re-measure) + G2 (2 stale user-memory claims) + G3 (feedback_harness10_run_trace.md new) + minor (gitignore check-ignore exit-trap corrected). Race root-cause fixed structurally. State unchanged (Mig 53/88 tables/306 test).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
pqhuy1987
2026-06-18 10:06:28 +07:00
parent 7436803db4
commit 7875b39861
22 changed files with 150 additions and 33 deletions

View File

@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
# CURATE synthesis — G1 close (em-main single-writer, C4)
> Workflow `wf_f32987b8-03f` · 2 general-purpose file-disjoint (1/file, NO same-file race). Closes finalize-review G1.
## Result (em-main verified git-truth, KHÔNG tin self-report)
| File | before → after | moved | 0-byte-loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| reviewer/MEMORY.md | 36738 → **24844B** (<25600 ✓) | 10 oldest (S33/S35/S43/S49 gates + cumulative + S40-ptr + 2 die-meta + 2 redundant H10-adap) | archive +22 -0 · grep-Fxf 10/10 byte-exact |
| investigator-codebase/MEMORY.md | 29819 **23187B** (<25600 ✓) | 3 oldest (S66/S65ter/S65 recon) | archive +6 -0 · md5sum cut==append `cedc21eb` |
## Em-main completion (after curate)
- **reviewer gist gen:2** added (agent skipped gistUpdated=false) 10 moved entries distilled compact: 6 routine gates [thấp] N/A-marker · 2 die-meta cross-ref `[[feedback_agent_kill_recovery]]` · 2 H10-adap cross-ref kept-S71 + `[[feedback_harness10_run_trace]]`. Closes A4 coverage-diff ("survive OR N/A"). (investigator gist gen:2 = agent did.)
- **budget.json re-measured** (script `measure-agent-memory.ps1`, transcribe not fabricate): reviewer/inv/cicd/impl-be updated; **l1_over_30kb=false ALL 11** + seeded_dateS71.
## Self-gate verdict: 🟢 G1 CLOSED
Both MEMORY.md <25600 auto-inject cap · archive additive (0-byte-loss) · _INDEX +pointers · gist gen:2 both · budget accurate. **Root-cause fixed structurally** (hmw.js RUN-TRACE writeGuard cấm sub tự-ghi MEMORY future hmw.js runs no-race; custom-workflow lesson `feedback_harness10_run_trace` #2). G2/G3/minor done em-main (user-memory + gitignore).

View File

@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
# RUN — Harness-9 curate G1 — reviewer + investigator L1→L2 (close finalize gap)
- **run-id (folder):** 2026-06-18-h910-curate
- **workflow run-id (evidence B3):** wf_f32987b8-03f
- **mục tiêu:** đóng G1 finalize-review — 2 file MEMORY.md over-cap (S71 same-role race) curate L1→L2 về <25600B, 0-byte-loss.
- **checkpoint:** APPROVED (closing finalize-review G1, anh giao "hoàn chỉnh")
- **L1 @P1:** finalize run CLOSED (no orphan)
- **opened:** 2026-06-18 09:52 +07
- **status:** OPEN running
## Split (file-disjoint — 1 agent/file, KHÔNG same-file race như INVEST/finalize)
| Agent | File | before target |
|---|---|---|
| 🟦 A1 (general-purpose) | `reviewer/MEMORY.md` + reviewer/archive/* | 36738B <25600 (cắt ~11KB nhất) |
| 🟦 A2 (general-purpose) | `investigator-codebase/MEMORY.md` + inv/archive/* | 29819B <25600 (cắt ~4.3KB nhất) |
## Cách (Harness-9 L1→L2, 0-byte-loss)
move entry NHẤT (FIFO cuối Recent-activity, giữ foundation+S71-mới) APPEND byte-exact `archive/2026-06.md` + 1-dòng `_INDEX.md` (substring sha/phrase-keyed) + gist distill-gen bump. Verify wc -c <25600 + numstat archive +N -0.
## Output → em-main verify (numstat 0-loss + wc -c) + re-measure budget.json

View File

@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
# FINALIZE synthesis — H-9 + H-10 + checklist full audit (em-main single-writer, C4)
> Workflow `wf_73de399d-753` · 3 reviewer. **R1 (Part A) + R2 (Part B+C) no-StructuredOutput ×2-nudge → self-gate** (pattern `feedback_agent_kill_recovery`). **R3 (cross-cutting) thorough — audit luôn Part A/B/C items** → đủ coverage (+ H2 bootstrap + self-verify S71 trước).
## Verdict: GAPS-FOUND — **0 defect/bug/over-claim-in-code; adoption SOUND**. Findings = deferred-incompleteness cần đóng.
### COMPLETE (verified-on-disk, R3)
- Containment model đồng-bộ **MỌI file** (4 owning + agents/README:111/:162 + harvest-curator:52 + tooling-auditor + session-end:51 + session-start:71) — 0 file giữ B6 cũ. agents/README:8 = frozen 06-07 chronology (acceptable).
- Frozen-evidence byte-intact (git diff f36aab8^..HEAD: broadcasts/_index additive 2 row, harness-2/error-ledger/sessions KHÔNG touched).
- Part C: run-folder 3-phần ×4 · gitignore (runs NOT-IGNORED / wave-*+teams IGNORED / ls-files 14) · hmw.js engine (node --check OK) · C7 caveat đủ 4 trục.
- Part B: 3 run-id evidenced · review-workflow bắt C5 L1 (validate mandate B2). Part A: floor intact (budget/measure-script/_INDEX/gist/ragignore/session-start §2.1.2).
- Category 6: email full-grammar VN, hash MATCH, honest self-disclose.
### GAPS (hoàn chỉnh)
- **G1 HIGH:** reviewer/MEMORY.md 33782B (>30720 soft + >25600 auto-inject — harness đã truncate ~8KB HOT lúc spawn này) + investigator-codebase/MEMORY.md 29819B (>25600). Root: S71 same-role race append. budget.json `measured` STALE (S70 snapshot 24795/24052). Harness-9 claim "4 <25KB" re-violated. re-measure + curate L1L2 (verbatimarchive, _INDEX, gist distill-gen bump) đến <25600. Acceptance: wc -c <25600 + numstat archive +N -0.
- **G2 MED:** (a) `feedback_harness9_l2_recovery_2workflow_adap.md:14` "cả 4 <25KB (đóng P1)" FALSE note re-opened S71 + re-closed sau G1. (b) `feedback_harness_123_adoption.md:13` wave-folder presented operative mark SUPERSEDED-by-Harness-10.
- **G3 MED:** thêm `feedback_harness10_run_trace.md` (run-trace supersedes wave + containment flip + 3 lesson: engine-no-fsem-main-scaffold-fragile-C2 · custom-workflow-must-copy-return-delta-guard · check-ignore-exit-trap-CORRECTED) + index pointer + link [[feedback_harness9_l2_recovery_2workflow_adap]].
- **MINOR:** gitignore:96-98 exit-trap explanation imprecise ("exits 0 for BOTH" thực: plain check-ignore exit **1** cho negation; chỉ `-v --no-index` mới 0-both). Command vẫn đúng. Fix khi touch (em fix luôn). Email frozen KHÔNG sửa.
## → em-main complete: G1 curate (delegate 2-agent file-disjoint) + G2/G3/minor (em-main) + re-measure + commit.

View File

@ -0,0 +1,18 @@
# RUN — Harness-9 + Harness-10 + checklist · FINALIZE double-check (toàn diện)
- **run-id (folder):** 2026-06-18-h910-finalize
- **workflow run-id (evidence B3):** wf_73de399d-753
- **mục tiêu:** anh giao "review/double-check hoàn chỉnh lại TOÀN BỘ H-9 + H-10 + checklist". KHÔNG chỉ Part C (S71) — audit cả Part A (Harness-9 memory, S70) + Part B (adap 2-workflow) + Part C (run-trace) đúng-nấc THẬT trên đĩa, tìm MỌI gap/incompleteness/over-claim/residual → em-main hoàn chỉnh.
- **checkpoint:** APPROVED (anh giao trực tiếp, HMW-mode ON)
- **L1 @P1:** prior 3 run CLOSED, 0 orphan ✓
- **opened:** 2026-06-18 09:41 +07
- **status:** OPEN → running
## Agents (3× reviewer adversarial, read-only ∥, map mỗi checklist item → đĩa)
| # | scope | verify |
|---|---|---|
| R1 | **Harness-9 Part A (A1-A9 memory archive)** | budget.json (keys+measured khớp script) · measure-script chạy · gist additive+distill-gen · `_INDEX` pointer resolve count=1 · `.ragignore` · A7 budget-audit trong session-start · A8 gist-command separation (tailored?). Nấc THẬT mỗi item. |
| R2 | **Harness-9 Part B (B1-B4) + Harness-10 Part C (C1-C8)** | 2-workflow mandate codify (adap-apply) · run-folder 3-phần ×4 · ledger 2-nhịp + orphan-def · 3-layer L1(em-main@P1)/L2(session-start)/L3(session-end idempotent) wired · C3 tracked+committed (git ls-files) · C7 caveat · C8 migration · hmw.js engine intact. |
| R3 | **Cross-cutting + residuals** | containment model đồng-bộ MỌI file (4 owning + agents/README + commands) · frozen-evidence còn intact (git log) · 2 over-cap MEMORY (reviewer 33.8/inv 29.8 — gap completion?) · over-claim/doc-drift còn sót H9+H10 · user-memory có cần entry Harness-10 lesson? |
## Output → `harvest/finalize-synthesis.md` (em main @P3) — gap-list + em-main hoàn chỉnh từng cái

View File

@ -9,3 +9,5 @@
| 2026-06-18-h10-invest | Harness-10 adap — INVESTIGATE | 2026-06-18 08:29 +07 | 2026-06-18 08:42 +07 | 4× investigator-codebase (read-only ∥) | ✅ PASS — B+C+D strong, A stub-fail (B covered hmw.js) · `wf_9c2cd2cd-2e7` | `harvest/invest-synthesis.md` ✓ |
| 2026-06-18-h10-implement | Harness-10 adap — IMPLEMENT | 2026-06-18 08:42 +07 | 2026-06-18 08:52 +07 | 3× general-purpose (text file-disjoint ∥) + em-main single-writer (gitignore/hmw.js/READMEs cluster) | ✅ PASS — 3/3 agent DONE, containment CLEAN, wording đồng-bộ 4 file · `wf_e4e46725-231` | `harvest/implement-synthesis.md` ✓ |
| 2026-06-18-h10-review | Harness-10 adap — REVIEW | 2026-06-18 08:52 +07 | 2026-06-18 09:01 +07 | 3× reviewer (adversarial ∥) | ✅ PASS sau-fix — R1 PASS · R2/R3 bắt C5 L1 over-claim (high-conf, đã fix path-a) · `wf_636bc95b-939` | `harvest/review-synthesis.md` ✓ |
| 2026-06-18-h910-finalize | Harness-9+10+checklist — FINALIZE double-check (anh giao) | 2026-06-18 09:41 +07 | 2026-06-18 09:52 +07 | 3× reviewer (R1 Part A / R2 Part B+C / R3 cross-cutting) | ✅ GAPS-FOUND, 0 code-defect — R3 thorough (R1/R2 no-StructuredOutput → self-gate); 3 gap (G1 over-cap curate · G2 stale-claims · G3 H10-memory) + 1 minor · `wf_73de399d-753` | `harvest/finalize-synthesis.md` ✓ |
| 2026-06-18-h910-curate | Harness-9 curate G1 — reviewer+investigator L1→L2 | 2026-06-18 09:52 +07 | 2026-06-18 10:05 +07 | 2× general-purpose (1/file, file-disjoint, NO same-file race) | ✅ PASS — reviewer 36.7→24.8KB (moved 10) + inv 29.8→23.2KB (moved 3), both <25600 cap; archive +N -0 (0-byte-loss, grep-Fxf 10/10 + md5sum verified); em-main +reviewer-gist gen:2 + budget re-measure · `wf_f32987b8-03f` | `harvest/curate-synthesis.md` |