[CLAUDE] Docs: S95 session-end closeout — Harness-17 adopt + STATUS/HANDOFF/ledger + session log
- STATUS mega-line prepend S95 (H17 adopt 3-workflow + 10/10 floor + 2 commit + cicd #476) + In-Progress→S95 + bundle-hash live 0T6vVJST/BGXEVZO6 (cicd re-snapshot, was stale S85) - HANDOFF S95 brief + NEXT (frontend-designer distill = H17 loop finding · monthly re-tier) - error-ledger: AS-10 recurrence S95 (E-006, WF1+WF3 self-write reverted 4th fire; instruction-fix NOT 100% — WF3 explicit-return-only STILL self-wrote → git-diff = net) + Active-Guard git-diff-containment 4/4 held - session log 2026-07-01-S95-harness17-adopt.md - user-memory: +feedback_faultinjection_proves_teeth (reusable verify pattern) - 0 production code; 434 test unchanged; docs-only CI-skip Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
pqhuy1987
File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long
File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long
53
docs/changelog/sessions/2026-07-01-S95-harness17-adopt.md
Normal file
53
docs/changelog/sessions/2026-07-01-S95-harness17-adopt.md
Normal file
@ -0,0 +1,53 @@
|
||||
# S95 — 2026-07-01 — Harness-17 adopt (Vòng tự-cải-thiện bộ-nhớ: Đo → Tinh-chỉnh → Kiểm)
|
||||
|
||||
> **Topic:** Adopt AI_INFRA Harness-17 (memory self-improvement loop Eval→Refine→Audit) qua `/check-email AI_INFRA` + `/adap-apply` + 3-workflow deep-verify. **em-main-led, HMW-mode ON, 0 production code.**
|
||||
|
||||
## Bối cảnh
|
||||
Anh: `/check-email AI_INFRA` → `/adap-apply` step-by-step cẩn thận đúng install-guide → double-check → report trung-thực AI_INFRA. Sau đó anh yêu-cầu **review pass thứ 3** (fault-injection, "finish nếu áp vào sai") → cập-nhật report.
|
||||
|
||||
## Reconcile đầu
|
||||
- **STAGE-1 email** (`AI_INFRA/broadcasts/outbox/se/`): 5 file đều đã processed → **0 directed mới**.
|
||||
- **H16** (3 broadcast `memory-fidelity-eval`+`mfe-update`+`cd-judge-sub-update`): **đã áp trọn S93** (adap-report `harness-16-mfe.md` list cả 3 slug).
|
||||
- **H17** (2 broadcast `harness-17-memory-self-improvement` + `checklist-harness-17`): **việc mới** — hash verify **MATCH ✓** cả 2 (PowerShell canonical strip-1-leading-newline), `reviewer_gate: PASS`.
|
||||
|
||||
## Adoption qua 3-workflow (Harness-9 mandate + anh-directed 3rd pass)
|
||||
| WF | run-id | vai trò |
|
||||
|---|---|---|
|
||||
| **WF1 IMPLEMENT** | `wf_f085d7c4-d78` | 4-agent ground-truth: reuse-anchor + C1-audit-design + B1/B2/B3-draft + cross-harness-conflict |
|
||||
| **WF2 REVIEW** | `wf_8e73c1d6-ee6` | 3-lane (code-gate + completeness 10/10 + honesty 0-overclaim) = PASS 0-blocking |
|
||||
| **WF3 DEEP-REVERIFY** | `wf_6f44eddf-680` | fault-injection teeth-proof + integration + cross-doc = PASS 0 application-defect |
|
||||
|
||||
em-main = single-writer giữa các workflow (author 6 artifact).
|
||||
|
||||
## 10/10 mục 🔴 sàn ĐẠT
|
||||
- **REUSE-cite (KHÔNG rebuild):** A2 load-fidelity=§H MFE · C3 single-writer=D9(§D.3) · CG-2 age-exempt=§G.2(b) value_protect · archive-action=§A archive-gate.
|
||||
- **Build mới mechanized:** `scripts/memory-selfimprove-audit.ps1` (C1 spec-audit NO-API exit-0, emit CRITERIA+GAP KHÔNG frozen-tally; 3 mặt write-gov/change-gov/distillation-spectrum). Runtime-verified: A1/A2/A3/B1/B2 PASS + C-spectrum **bắt frontend-designer over-cap GAP:MED thật**.
|
||||
- **Build mới convention:** `.claude/governance/reinject-ledger.md` (B2 CG-1 termination git-tracked append-only N=3, tách khỏi budget.json per §G.4(4)) + B1 signal→action map (4 loại) + B3 build-gap-vs-floor-rot phép-thử.
|
||||
- **Codify:** engine `harness-11-engine.md` **§I** + artifact-map row + fix stale cap-comment (220K→380K pointer). **Wire:** `session-start §2.1.7` (loop-DÒ) + `session-end §L.b(c)` (loop-REFINE). **Vocab:** HCV alias no-seed ("coverage" 3-nghĩa: H2 harvest / H16 MFE-SUB / H17 A1) + detector C3-comment → **detector vẫn 27 flag** (0 fork thứ 4).
|
||||
|
||||
## WF3 fault-injection (chứng RĂNG THẬT, không chỉ reasoning)
|
||||
13 inject vào cây tạm (`-RepoRoot`): A1 bắt store_memory/delete_memory GAP:HIGH · A1 no-false-flag body-mention · A2 bắt xoá-memoryDelta/writeGuard HIGH · C-spectrum bắt over-cap MED(27KB)/HIGH(32KB>softcap) + no-false-flag-khi-có-gist + boundary off-by-one đúng · B1 bắt detector-missing HIGH/exit≠0 MED · B2/A3 teeth. **8/8 md5 khớp repo sau restore.** Anti-Goodhart: inject gist→FLIP GAP→PASS (recompute); mutate cap→99999 live-echo (single-source thật).
|
||||
|
||||
## Dogfood C3 (AS-10 4-fire, E-006 recurrence S95)
|
||||
WF1 (investigator-codebase tự-compact MEMORY.md 25.5→16.98KB, claim archive-move nhưng `archive/2026-06.md` KHÔNG tồn-tại → giữ = **mất 8.5KB**) + WF3-Lane-A (reviewer tự-ghi diary + new file). git-diff post-P2 caught BOTH → **em-main revert**. cicd-monitor diary **KEPT** (normal-spawn, không return-only = legit). 🔑 **Instruction-fix NOT 100%:** WF3 CÓ explicit "TUYỆT ĐỐI return-only" mà reviewer VẪN tự-ghi → persona-write stochastic → **git-diff-revert = net mandatory** (không phải instruction-alone). Guard HELD 4/4, 0 escape. Chính C3-floor đang adopt đã cứu data.
|
||||
|
||||
## Report tới AI_INFRA
|
||||
- `docs/governance/adap-reports/2026-06-30-Governance-harness-17-memory-self-improvement.md` (+ section Deep-reverify WF3) + checklist-pointer.
|
||||
- 2 email `broadcasts/outbox/ai_infra/`: adopt-report (hash `54789e19`) + deep-reverify-update (`8c94fa34`) — cả 2 hash self-consistent (`.gitattributes broadcasts/** eol=lf` giữ hash stable).
|
||||
|
||||
## Commit + deploy
|
||||
- `18a17f5` (adopt; 2 `.ps1` → CI trigger) → cicd **Run #476 PASS** (~5m08s, 434 test, prod 200×3, bundle rotate benign #69 admin `CkZ1MjC1→0T6vVJST`/user `_-gpX7_Y→BGXEVZO6` CSS-frozen, Mig 59 unchanged).
|
||||
- `65b434a` (deep-reverify; all `.md` → **CI-skip** docs-only).
|
||||
|
||||
## Lessons (§L)
|
||||
1. **Fault-injection-via-`-RepoRoot`-temp chứng checker-teeth** — chạy checker trên cây-tạm-có-lỗi confirm nó FLAG (không chỉ happy-path PASS). → user-memory `feedback_faultinjection_proves_teeth`.
|
||||
2. **Lane B #53 empty-return → em-main self-gate** (feedback_workflow_fanout_reliability confirmed lần nữa): cross-doc consistency lane trả rỗng → em-main grep tự verify (N=3/HCV/run-id/hash/detector-27).
|
||||
3. **Cardinality của vocab:** 1-từ-nhiều-nghĩa ("coverage" 3, "memory-fidelity" 2) → đặt tên-định-danh + alias-map + **KHÔNG seed detector** (seed→false-flag). 2-workflow bắt, 1-workflow trượt.
|
||||
4. **AS-10 instruction-fix NOT 100%** — explicit-return-only giảm nhưng không diệt persona-write; git-diff-revert là net thật.
|
||||
|
||||
## State (GIỮ NGUYÊN — 0 production code)
|
||||
Mig 59 · 88 bảng · 434 test (45D+389I) · gotcha 76 · menu 54 · RAG 2430 · prod 17 user/7 NCC. Bundle live `0T6vVJST`/`BGXEVZO6` (Run #476).
|
||||
|
||||
## NEXT
|
||||
- **em:** frontend-designer distill (H17 loop's live finding: MEMORY.md 26129B over-cap WATCH strike-1; archive-gate propose khi strike-2) · monthly 2026-07-01 re-tier mega-line + ef-core SKILL Mig→59 + docs/CLAUDE Budget-removed + 3 vocab-fork alias-map.
|
||||
- **anh:** ⚠️ restart CLI (§2.1.7 + §L.b(c) H17-loop wire + command `.md` no hot-reload). Pending product carry (Section B / Ngưỡng CEO / "C" chuyển phiếu).
|
||||
@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ Detect by **action-signature** (NOT "AI tự phán có vi phạm không"). Scan
|
||||
| agent frontmatter `model: inherit` (not `[1m]`) | gotcha #37 | procedural | — | ✅ (FD agent loaded S48) | ++ |
|
||||
| **lead = sole RAG-writer** (`store_memory` stripped, mechanized) | store_memory rebootstrap-loss (S41) + AS-3 | procedural | 2 (NamGroup + SE S41) | ✅ runtime S48 (0/8 subs) | +++ (failure-safe) |
|
||||
| session-end verify memory byte>0 | S46 0-byte (AS-8) | procedural | 1 (S46) | ✅ S49 (new mem 2355B + 0 byte-0 scan) | ++ |
|
||||
| **git-diff + chunk-count post-P2 containment** (defense-in-depth, HMW) | R1 sub-write residual (AS-10) · store_memory bypass (AS-3) | **procedural** (institutionalized S50 = standard B6 post-wave audit) | 1 (S49) | ✅ S49 (caught inv-api self-MEMORY in git-diff; chunk 2414=2414) + **S50 wave `h2-verify` (git-diff agent-memory EMPTY, chunk 2415=2415, 0 leak)** + **S93 (WF1 3-agent residual caught+reverted; WF2 0-residual after explicit return-only)** | ++ (G-015 honest — NOT allowlist-alone) |
|
||||
| **git-diff + chunk-count post-P2 containment** (defense-in-depth, HMW) | R1 sub-write residual (AS-10) · store_memory bypass (AS-3) | **procedural** (institutionalized S50 = standard B6 post-wave audit) | 1 (S49) | ✅ S49 (caught inv-api self-MEMORY in git-diff; chunk 2414=2414) + **S50 wave `h2-verify` (git-diff agent-memory EMPTY, chunk 2415=2415, 0 leak)** + **S93 (WF1 3-agent residual caught+reverted; WF2 0-residual after explicit return-only)** + **S95 (WF1+WF3 residual caught+reverted 2×; WF3 explicit-return-only STILL self-wrote → instruction-fix NOT 100%, git-diff = the net)** | +++ (G-015 honest — 4 fires/4 catches/0 escape; NOT allowlist-alone, NOT instruction-alone) |
|
||||
| heavy spawn → `run_in_background` | looks-frozen | **procedural** (2-strike met) | 2 (S45, S48) | ✅ S48 (FD bg) + S50 (all 4 monitor+wave spawns bg) | + |
|
||||
| RAG glob `**/`-anchored (not root) | gotcha #10 node_modules leak | procedural | 1 (S41) | ✅ (2406 clean) | ++ |
|
||||
| dump bảng env-đích TRƯỚC identifier-based data op (lock/seed-by-email) | gotcha #60 (AS-12) | episodic | 1 (S57bis lock NO-OP) | ✅ S58 (recon dump → fix `5998163` → Run #382 đo 34 locked) | ++ |
|
||||
@ -88,6 +88,7 @@ Detect by **action-signature** (NOT "AI tự phán có vi phạm không"). Scan
|
||||
- **fix:** (process) em-main commit-gate `git diff` review = backstop, **HELD** — every changed line reviewed pre-commit → accurate / benign / correctly-placed / 0-mojibake / chunk-2415 → **adopted per AS-10 keep-if-correct** (NOT a content bug: matches what §L.b prescribes). (guard) "git-diff + chunk-count post-P2 containment" already promoted procedural this session; AS-10 now has its **first real fire**.
|
||||
- **prevention/guard:** RECOMMEND (anh / AI_INFRA, charter-v2 infra): harden monitor tool-grant — `Write/Edit` removal alone leaves Bash residual → consider a session-end hook blocking sub-Bash-write to tracked paths, OR accept commit-gate as sufficient defense-in-depth. Fidelity: if monitors write, their reports MUST disclose it → escalate 🟥 reviewer if recurs. Provenance timing-implicated, **not definitively attributable** (no false accusation).
|
||||
- **recurrence S93 (2026-06-29):** AS-10 2nd fire — 3 WF1 workflow-agents (investigator-codebase ×2 + reviewer, return-only) self-wrote agent-memory (diary append + archive self-curate + 1 stray `project_s92_*` mis-named file). git-diff post-P2 containment caught ALL → em-main reverted (kept cicd-monitor PE-deploy harvest hợp-lệ). Guard HELD again. **WF2 fix:** added explicit "RETURN-ONLY: do NOT write ANY file incl MEMORY.md" to every lane prompt → **0 residual** (instruction-fix worked, git-diff confirmed). Lesson: workflow-agent frontmatter "update MEMORY before return" fights return-only mandate → prompt MUST override + git-diff is the net (G-015, not mechanized).
|
||||
- **recurrence S95 (2026-07-01, H17 adopt):** AS-10 **3rd + 4th fire** — WF1 (investigator-codebase self-compacted its MEMORY.md 25.5→16.98KB, CLAIMED archive-move but `archive/2026-06.md` was NOT created → keeping it would have LOST 8.5KB) + WF3-Lane-A (reviewer self-wrote diary + new `project_s95_harness17_faultinjection.md`). git-diff post-P2 caught BOTH → em-main reverted; cicd-monitor diary KEPT (normal-monitor-spawn, NOT return-only = legit). Guard HELD 2×. **🔑 Instruction-fix NOT 100%:** WF2(H17) had explicit return-only → 0 residual, but **WF3 ALSO had explicit "TUYỆT ĐỐI return-only" yet reviewer STILL self-wrote** → persona-write is stochastic; explicit-prompt REDUCES but does NOT eliminate → **git-diff-revert remains the mandatory net (G-015 reconfirmed, instruction-alone insufficient).** Distinction codified: workflow-return-only-agent = REVERT; normal-monitor-spawn (diary verdict) = KEEP. **Dogfood:** contained WHILE adopting H17 whose C3-floor = single-writer — the very floor being adopted saved real data. Guard net-effect ++ (4 fires, 4 catches, 0 escape).
|
||||
- **tags:** [containment-residual-write / monitor-sub+workflow-agent / governance-docs+agent-memory]
|
||||
|
||||
### E-005 — AS-1 `git add -A` on S49 governance commit (self-caught @session-end §L.a)
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user