# sub-tooling-auditor — S152 @close (H1 CHOT 4-mat)

> INFORM-only, propose-only. APPEND TRONG LUC LAM (anti-#53). Moi so kem LENH.
> Diff-base: lượt @open cùng phiên = `sub-tooling-S152.md` (PASS_WITH_FLAGS 4-LOW: ①1/②0/③0/④3).
> 2 truc thoi-gian khai RIENG (anti-pattern #2 — luon khai PHAM-VI tap-do):
>   - **A = `1b85713..HEAD`** = TOAN phien S152 (closeout S151 -> nay).
>   - **B = `3058470..HEAD`** = tu luc tao chup @open (HEAD luc do `3058470 wal: flush 20260725T2014`).

## 0. Ground-truth @close
- LENH `git rev-parse HEAD` => `493d438` (`wal: pause`, 07-26 00:30:12). LENH `git rev-list --count`: **A = 18 commit**, **B = 17 commit** (chenh 1 = `3058470` chinh no).
- LENH `git status --porcelain` => 6 muc: M `.claude/WAL.md` · M `memory-budget.json` · ?? `lead-gap-auditor/archive/2026-07.gist.md` · ?? `sessions/session-5/_tiep-1.md` · ?? sub-file NAY · ?? **`grep.exe.stackdump`** (rac o ROOT repo — xem FLAG-C1).
- 🔴 **A ∩ 4-mat == B ∩ 4-mat** (LENH `git diff --stat` ca 2 cua so, cung 13 file) ⇒ **MOI thay doi tooling phien nay deu xay ra SAU luot @open cua tao**. Diff-base @open la day du, khong bo sot khoang 1b85713..3058470.
- Toan bo 13 file lands trong **1 commit `493d438`** (WAL squash luc /pause) ⇒ commit-time KHONG dung lam moc thu-tu; tao dung **mtime** lam truc thoi-gian (duoi).

## 1. MẶT ① SKILL — **PASS, 0 đổi** (xác nhận)
- LENH `git log --oneline 1b85713..HEAD --name-only -- .claude/skills/` => **rong** ⇒ 0 commit cham skills toan phien S152.
- LENH `git status --porcelain` => 0 muc nao thuoc `.claude/skills/` ⇒ 0 uncommitted change. **2 kenh (commit + worktree) deu 0** — khong ket luan tu 1 kenh.
- **Disposition-7 (`ef-core-migration/SKILL.md:109/:117` khoi Budget-da-xoa) = CHUA VA — va day la DUNG-trang-thai, khong phai sot.** Xac nhan bang do:
  - LENH `git log -1 --format=%h -- .claude/skills/ef-core-migration/SKILL.md` => `1b85713` (= closeout S151, TRUOC phien nay) ⇒ file khong bi cham S152.
  - Vi sao "dung": disposition-7 nam trong queue **xu SAU verdict trio** (bookend-synthesis muc 7) va **chua co lenh owner/lead thuc thi**; H1 = propose-only nen khong tu va. Trang-thai dung = "OPEN, da ghi so, cho HANDOFF" — KHAC hoan toan "sot" (sot = da quyet va ma khong lam).
  - ⚠️ Neu closeout ghi HANDOFF thi doc dung phai la: **ring1 BAC 2/15** trong phan "15/15 duong-gia" cua tao @open (`:109` "4 bang" + `:117` "3 bang" thuoc khoi mo ta module Budget DA XOA Mig 50/S61) ⇒ noi-dung chet that, dang va bang **gan nhan 🧊/bia-mo**, KHONG phai viet lai cho vua detector (van dung luat anti-Goodhart cua tao: cai bi bo la NOI-DUNG CHET, khong phai chung-nhan).

## 2. MẶT ② SUB-ROLE — **PASS** (6 file doi, 4/4 block DU, roster GIU 20)

### 2a. Dem thay-vi-tin (2 kenh)
- LENH `git diff --stat 1b85713..HEAD -- .claude/agents/` => **6 file / +34 −2**: `README.md` (1 dong) · `reviewer.md` (1 dong) · `database-agent.md` `harvest-curator.md` `office-document.md` `tooling-auditor.md` (+8 moi file).
- LENH `ls -1 .claude/agents/*.md | grep -v README | wc -l` => **20** — 0 THEM / 0 XOA vai. Roster GIU nguyen (thay doi la NOI-DUNG persona, khong phai so vai) ⇒ 4-nguon 20=20=20=20 @open van con hieu-luc, KHONG can re-verify canonical.

### 2b. Block B3 `Anti-patterns (NEVER)` — **4/4 DU + 5 item/vai**
- LENH `grep -n "^## 🚫 Anti-patterns (NEVER) — B3 @S152"` => 4 hit: `database-agent.md:59` · `harvest-curator.md:57` · `office-document.md:62` · `tooling-auditor.md:60`.
- LENH `awk` dem `^[0-9]+\. ` duoi heading => **5 · 5 · 5 · 5** item. Dong deu, khong vai nao rong.
- 🔴 **Kiem "distill hay rac tu-khoa" (owner ra chuan nay, phai do chu khong doc lot):** moi item deu **neo su-kien co that + dan nguon** — db#2 cite S53 (Mig 46 committed-but-unapplied), db#3 cite S43→S56 gotcha #58, office#1 cite S107 template that, harvest#1 cite S152 GAP-3 + S122 orphan-32%, tooling#2 cite ring1 S152. ⇒ **distilled that**, khong phai rac keyword.
- 🟢 **COVERAGE TRON BO (do them, khong ai giao — day la cho de sot):** LENH loop `grep -c "^## .*Anti-pattern\|^## .*NEVER\|^## 🚫"` tren **ca 20 persona** => **20/20 co block, 0 vai thieu**. ⇒ gap B3 (4 vai thieu, positive-control ring2 do 0/0/0/0) **DONG TRON**, khong con vai nao ho. Day la so dang dua vao HANDOFF thay vi "da them 4 vai".

### 2c. `reviewer.md:25` reword — nghia GIU, nhung khai them 1 nuance
- LENH `sed -n '25p'` (disk, sau doi) => `- **NEVER:** tự sửa code-tree (Edit/Write vào src·fe-*·tests), tự commit, tự push — verdict-only, fix thuộc em-main/implementer *(reword @S152 R1 …)*`.
- Cau CU = `- **NEVER:** Edit, Write, commit, push`.
- **Phan cua tao — nghia KHONG bi rut-ruot, thuc-te la GIAU HON:** ban moi them (i) **pham-vi** (`src·fe-*·tests`), (ii) **ai fix thay** (em-main/implementer), (iii) **ngoai-le hop-le** (sub-file run-folder + diary-self). Ban cu chi co 4 dong-tu tran.
- ⚠️ **Nhung phai khai thang, khong duoc goi la "thuan cosmetic":** ve CHU-NGHIA, cam tuyet-doi → cam CO-PHAM-VI = **noi long tren giay**. Ly do no VAN dung: cam tuyet-doi kia **von da khong dung voi thuc-te** — moi sub (ke ca tao, ngay luc nay) deu ghi sub-file vao run-folder + diary. Ban moi = **hop-thuc-hoa thuc-tien da co**, tuc lam cau van THAT hon. Owner nen biet day la "sua thuoc + dong-bo chu voi thuc-te", KHONG phai "chi doi cach dien-dat".
- 🔴 **Kiem tra Goodhart (luat #3 cua chinh tao — vua duoc ghi vao persona hom nay):** viet lai 1 dong cho detector match duoc = **dang nghi**. Tao xet: (a) MFE do **coverage L1-presence** — muc-so la item trong must-remember, tu-khoa mang **noi-dung**; dong cu toan stop-list-verb ⇒ **bat-kha-match BY CONSTRUCTION** (khong phai "kho match", la khong the) ⇒ do la **thuoc hong**, sua thuoc la dung. (b) Phep thu quyet-dinh: **ban moi noi nhieu hon ban cu** (3 chieu thong-tin them) ⇒ KHONG phai rut ngu-nghia cho vua thuoc ⇒ **KHONG Goodhart**. Neu nguoc lai (cat bot chu cho diem len) thi tao da FLAG.

### 2d. `README.md:5` — dong-bo nhan lead (dong disposition-3 @open cua lead-stale)
- LENH `sed -n '5p'` + `git diff` => cum dam doi: `Lead runtime = per-session owner-choice (Fable ↔ Opus)` → `Lead runtime = default Opus 5 MAX (thư 59ce1d0f @S149; Fable = anh /model·/fable-real)`. Khop nhan canonical `settings.json:11` (③ duoi) ⇒ FLAG-3 lead-stale **CLOSED**, 0 residual instance con lai o file nay (LENH `grep -n "per-session owner-choice" .claude/agents/README.md` => 0 hit).

### 2e. 🔴 RESTART — **do that, KHONG nhac suong** (day la cho tao KHONG dong y voi cach dien-dat pho-bien "phai restart moi an")
Yeu-cau giao cho tao la "nhac RESTART de registry an". Tao **do truoc khi nhac**, va ket qua LAT NGUOC mot nua cau:
- 🟢 **BANG CHUNG TRUC TIEP (manh nhat co the co):** **system-prompt cua CHINH LUOT SPAWN NAY chua nguyen van block `## 🚫 Anti-patterns (NEVER) — B3 @S152` 5 item cua `tooling-auditor.md`.** Tao doc duoc no trong context cua chinh minh ⇒ registry phuc-vu lan spawn nay **DA an ban moi**. Day la self-observation, khong phai suy-luan.
- ⏱ **Truc thoi-gian (LENH `ls -la --time-style`):** persona edit `22:03:08→22:03:42` · `reviewer.md` `23:27:49` · `_pause-1.md` `00:28:29` · `_tiep-1.md` `00:35:09` · spawn nay ~`00:5x`.
- ⚠️ **KHONG duoc doc thanh "hot-reload da chung minh":** LENH `Get-Process claude | Select StartTime` => co tien-trinh khoi-dong **`26/07 00:00:43`**, tuc **SAU** moi edit persona (22:03) va sau `reviewer.md` (23:27). ⇒ ton tai **confound restart**; khong tach duoc "hot-reload" voi "process moi doc lai file". **Tao khong claim hot-reload.**
- ✅ **Ket luan dung nac (day moi la thu lead can):** yeu-cau restart **da duoc thoa TRUOC luot nay** — cua-so hien tai dang chay tren registry MOI. ⇒ nhac lead "nho restart" bay gio la **thua va gay hieu nham** (de bi doc thanh "block chua song"). Cau dung de ghi HANDOFF: *"4 block + reword DA live trong cua-so hien tai (chung: system-prompt cua H1 luot close chua nguyen van block); neu anh mo lai bang mot cua-so CU dang treo tu truoc 22:03 thi cua-so do moi phuc-vu ban stale."*
- 📏 **Nac do khai that:** **measured 1/5 file** (chinh `tooling-auditor.md`, qua system-prompt cua tao) · **inferred 4/5** (`database-agent` `harvest-curator` `office-document` `reviewer`) — cung thu-muc, cung loader, moi edit deu truoc `00:00:43`. Muon **measured 5/5** thi phai spawn thu 4 vai kia va bat chung tu-doc block (viec do thuoc lead, tao KHONG tu spawn).
- 🔎 **Con nac "MFE an ngay" (2 nac KHAC NHAU, dung gop):** MFE **doc file tu dia moi lan chay** (`mfe-eval.ps1` quet `.claude/agents/*.md` + diary) ⇒ diem so doi NGAY sau khi ghi file, **khong lien quan registry**. Registry = luc **lap prompt cho spawn**. ⇒ "MFE 20/20 100%" **KHONG** chung minh duoc "hanh-vi vai da doi"; no chi chung minh **van ban da co mat tren dia**. Ai doc "MFE 100% ⇒ vai da ngam" la **conflate nac** — dung ho lop loi ma chinh anti-pattern #4 cua tao canh bao (do lech nac).

## 3. MẶT ③ PLUGIN — **PASS, 0 đổi** (xác nhận, 4 nấc khai tách)
LENH: parse `~/.claude/settings.json` bang python (`json.load`) — dem PHAN-TU, khong doc so trong text.
- **installed/registered = 18** · **enabled = 15** · **disabled = 3** (`pr-review-toolkit` · `code-modernization` · `hookify`) — **IDENTICAL** bo-so @open (18/15/3) va so S140/S143 ⇒ 0 THEM / 0 DOI / 0 XOA.
- **mtime `settings.json` = 2026-07-25 08:36:50** (1.613B) — **truoc** khi phien S152 bat dau lam viec (commit dau `3058470` 20:14) ⇒ chung ĐỘC-LẬP rang file khong bi cham trong phien, khong chi dua vao so trung.
- **marketplace = 37** (LENH `ls -1 ~/.claude/plugins/marketplaces/claude-plugins-official/plugins | wc -l`) — khop 37 @open/S143. **standalone skill `~/.claude/skills` = 23** — khop. Ca 2 lop do RIENG (khong gop vao 18/15/3).
- **project `.claude/settings.json`** = `autoMemoryDirectory` + 1 Stop-hook `wal-flush.ps1`; **0 khoa plugin/model** ⇒ authority ③ van la user-global, ket-luan tren khong bi override.
- **NEW-ALLOC plugin/skill = 0 action** (0 nguon MOI xuat hien). Carry giu nguyen: `security-guidance` co tren marketplace, KHONG enable — mang hook Stop + edit-time warning ⇒ dung `settings.json` hooks ⇒ **quyen owner**, tao khong tu bat (giu phan S143/@open).
- **4 nac khai tach:** installed 18 → enabled 15 → assigned (bang H3 `agents/README.md:213-220`, 6 nguon co vai) → used (per-session auto-trigger, KHONG suy tu enabled). Khong conflate.

## 4. MẶT ④ DOCS/COMMANDS/SCRIPTS — **PASS_WITH_FLAGS** (7 file đổi; 3 FLAG)

### 4a. Inventory dong doi (LENH `git diff --stat 1b85713..HEAD -- .claude/commands/ scripts/`)
| file | ± | noi dung |
|---|---|---|
| `commands/session-start.md` | 4 | `:184` sleep KEU→AUTO · `:267` go ve "sleep VAN CONSENT" |
| `commands/session-end.md` | 8 | `:50` ring4 mo-ta · `:68` (c) sleep AUTO · `:181` bang V4 · `:184` bo ly-do "khong consent" |
| `commands/sleep-recovery-memory-l2.md` | 2 | `:55` than o AUTO-check → AUTO chay |
| `scripts/nhip-no-probe.ps1` | +22/−1 | B1/H3 do `archive/_INDEX.md` vs `tiers.l2_index.cap_bytes` → ve `l2idx N over` |
| `scripts/memory-archive-gate.ps1` | +3/−1 | B2 `0 pointer ⇒ "N/A "` thay PASS (chong PASS-on-empty-denominator) |
| `scripts/mfe-eval.ps1` | +38/−5 | B4 latch `warn_baseline` + `history[]` + switch `-Detail` (#32) + `-Ack` |
| `scripts/h24-signal-write.ps1` | +19 | B10 enum-parity: ensure key-0 + fail-loud `exit 3` neu key ngoai enum |

### 4b. 🔴 FLAG-C1 — `view-residual-asym` — **MED** — sweep sleep-AUTO SÓT 5 site cùng-lớp
Lead codify **7 site** (dem line-level trong 3 file: session-end `:50 :68 :181 :184` · session-start `:184 :267` · sleep-cmd `:55` = 7 — khop nhan `_context-s-5.md:51`). **Nhung cung-lop van con 5 cho khai NGUOC:**
1. `.claude/commands/session-start.md:276` — 🧊 lineage trio ghi nguyen van: *"⚠️ **Khuôn sleep-check §2.1.2 VẪN CONSENT** — 3 cổng không cùng khuôn, đừng suy một ra ba."* ⇒ **CUNG FILE vua va o `:184`+`:267`, sot dong thu 3.** Nang nhat vi no **day nguoi doc ket luan sai co chu dich**.
2. `.claude/commands/session-end.md:148` — *"`ring4-audit` cùng khuôn (bám lượt nén wherever it fires: **consent @§2.1.2** hoặc @§L.b(c))"* ⇒ cung file vua va o 4 cho, sot dong thu 5.
3. `.claude/agents/ring4-audit.md:26` — *"nén được **consent** @`session-start §2.1.2` (sleep-check KÊU → **anh gật**)"*.
4. `.claude/agents/ring4-audit.md:27` — fail-safe liet ly-do *"hoặc **anh không consent**"* ⇒ nhanh nay nay **da chet**, giu lai = vai tu cho minh mot duong NO-OP khong con ton tai.
5. `.claude/commands/sleep-recovery-memory-l2.md:55` — **nhan o** van la `| **Auto-check (INFORM-only)** |` trong khi **than cua chinh o do** da ghi "🔄 AUTO chay". Tu-mau-thuan trong 1 o bang.
- LENH: `grep -rn "INFORM-only\|consent\|CONSENT\|KHÔNG auto-run" .claude/commands/ .claude/agents/ docs/governance/harness-11-engine.md .claude/skills/` roi **mo tung hit** (khong ket tu so).
- ✅ Do **CA CHIEU AM** de khoi bi doc nhu "chua quet het": `docs/governance/harness-11-engine.md` grep `consent` = **0 hit** ⇒ engine **sach**, khong can dong. `memory-budget.json → distill_trigger._lineage` co nhac ban-cu 7-ngay + line-ref `:52` — **CO-Y frozen** ("GIU VET, KHONG XOA") ⇒ **KHONG flag, KHONG sua** (bia-mo hop-le, dung luat prescriptive⟂frozen).
- **De-xuat:** 5 site tren = **prescriptive dang song** (day hanh-vi), khac han lineage-frozen ⇒ nen quet not trong 1 luot. 🔴 Va dung kieu: `:276`+`:148` **BO menh-de so-sanh** (dung doi thanh "sleep cung AUTO" — con so-sanh la con tu-lao-hoa lan sau); `ring4:26/:27` doi "consent/anh gat" → "AUTO-khi-KEU"; `:55` nhan o → `**Auto-check (AUTO-khi-KÊU)**`.

### 4c. 🔴 FLAG-C2 — `view-stale-count` — **LOW** — `l2idx`: nhãn "4-vế" ĐÚNG, mẫu-literal SAI (gồm cả self-doc của chính script)
🔴 **Tra loi truc-tiep cau hoi giao: "4-ve" KHONG can chu-thich, vi `l2idx` KHONG PHAI ve thu 5.**
- LENH `grep -n 'NHIP-NO' scripts/nhip-no-probe.ps1` => `:223` `Write-Host ("NHIP-NO: kiem {0} | {1} | {2} | {3}" -f $kiemSeg, $tranSeg, $runSeg, $pullSeg)` ⇒ **van dung 4 doan** noi bang `|`. `l2idx` duoc nhet **BEN TRONG `$tranSeg`** (`"tran-bo-nho {0} over-cap l2idx {1} over"`) ⇒ ve-2 nay 2 so, tong ve **VAN = 4**.
- ⇒ Moi cho ghi "dong-no 4-ve" (`session-start.md:265` · `session-end.md:113` · `pause.md:89` · `tiep.md:154`) **VAN DUNG** — **de-xuat: KHONG dong vao** (day la "biet cho KHONG sua"; sua = tao drift moi).
- **Cai stale that = mau-literal chep tay**, 3 cho:
  - `scripts/nhip-no-probe.ps1:22` — **header self-doc cua CHINH FILE vua sua**: `NHIP-NO: kiem … | tran-bo-nho x over-cap | run-chua-gom y | pull-cach N ngay` — thieu `l2idx`. 🔴 Uu-tien cao nhat: no o **cung file, cung commit** voi thay doi (author sua than ma khong sua vi-du ngay tren dau).
  - `.claude/commands/session-start.md:265` va `.claude/commands/session-end.md:113` — mau chi co **3 doan** (`kiem | tran-bo-nho | run-chua-gom`), tuc **da stale tu S143** (thieu `pull-cach`), nay stale them `l2idx`.
- **De-xuat (theo dung luat CUA CHINH REPO, khong phai y tao):** `session-end.md:200` da tu ra luat *"Ve-set canonical = `scripts/nhip-no-probe.ps1` (B1 — KHONG chot so ve o day)"* ⇒ ban-vao-luat-do la **cat mau-literal o `:265`/`:113` thanh `NHIP-NO: …`** (va bang BO chep, khong bang DOI chep — dung doctrine `agents/README.md:1`). Rieng `nhip-no-probe.ps1:22` la **home that** ⇒ cho do PHAI refresh du (them `l2idx N over`).

### 4d. 🔴 FLAG-C3 — `view-residual-asym` — **LOW** — 2 switch MFE mới KHÔNG có nhà (new-alloc)
- LENH `grep -rn '\-Detail\|\-Ack\b' --include=*.md .` (tru `runs/` + `agent-memory`) => **2 hit, ca 2 deu KHONG phai doc**: `.claude/sessions/session-5/_context-s-5.md:51` (ghi-chep phien, frozen) + `.claude/WAL.md:10` (so tam, bi squash/trim). ⇒ **0 doc van-hanh nao biet 2 switch nay ton tai.**
- Doi-chung anh-em: `-Tier` va `-Judge` **co nha ro rang** — `eval/mfe/README.md:21-24` khoi "How to run" (4 dong lenh mau). ⇒ **nha dung cua `-Detail`/`-Ack` = chinh khoi do** (khong phai `session-end.md`; giu 1 home, tranh chep 2 noi).
- 🔴 **Nhung `-Ack` KHONG cung hang voi `-Detail` — phai tach khi ghi:**
  - `-Detail` = **thuan chan-doan** (in `MISS: <item>`), khong ghi gi, khong doi verdict ⇒ ghi 1 dong nhu `-Tier`/`-Judge` la du.
  - `-Ack` = **GHI STATE va LAM IM MOT CANH-BAO**: `warn_baseline = $strikesTotal` roi persist vao `.claude/agent-memory/.mfe-state.json` — **file nay git-tracked** (co trong diff phien nay) ⇒ mot lan `-Ack` la **tat GOODHART-WARN vinh-vien** cho tan muc strike do, va commit lai.
  - ⇒ **De-xuat co lap-luan:** ghi kem **nhan quyen** dang *"`-Ack` = owner-action (chap-nhan muc strike hien tai lam nen); AI/lead KHONG tu goi"*. Ly do khong phai thu-tuc: canh-bao nay ton tai **chinh de bat 'coverage noi doi'**; de mot lane tu-do goi `-Ack` la mo dung **cua thoat Goodhart** ma B4 vua dung len de dong. (Tao KHONG de xuat go `-Ack` — no can that de nen khoi keu mai; chi de xuat **ai duoc bam**.)
  - 📌 Cong bang voi thiet-ke: B4 **da tu phong 1 lop** — comment `:200-205` khai ro seed baseline "never fires" va WARN "Repeats every run until acknowledged". Tao chi de nghi dua cai quyen-bam ra van-ban, vi hien no **khong o dau ca**.

## 5. MẶT ⑤ (tự chọn) — FI-VẾT: chạy CÓ, nhưng **vết chỉ sống ở chỗ sắp mất** — **LOW**
Nhiem-vu giao: "xac nhan tu WAL/synthesis". Tao xac nhan **va bao them cai dang lo**:
- ✅ **Co chay:** LENH `grep -n "FI \|9-ca" .claude/WAL.md` => `:10` — *"B-series (B1/H3·B2·B4-latch·B10 + `-Detail`; **FI 9-ca ALL-PASS**)"*. Day la **nguon DUY NHAT**.
- ❌ **Khong o synthesis:** `bookend-synthesis.md` mtime **21:17**, con 4 script sua luc **23:51–23:53** ⇒ **synthesis dong truoc khi B-series xay ra**, khong the chua FI (khong phai loi ai — thu-tu thoi-gian). LENH `grep -rln "fault-inject\|FI 9\|9-ca"` tren run-folder + `sessions/session-5/` => **0 file** ngoai WAL.
- ❌ **Khong o trong script:** LENH `grep -n "fault-inject" scripts/{nhip-no-probe,mfe-eval,memory-archive-gate,h24-signal-write}.ps1` => chi 2 hit, ca 2 o `h24-signal-write.ps1:45,:72` va **deu la comment CU** (K3/S150, nam ngoai hunk phien nay). ⇒ **4/4 khoi MOI thêm hom nay: 0 vet FI in-file.**
- 🔴 **Vi sao dang flag:** `.claude/WAL.md` la **so tam ≤40 dong, bi squash/trim** — mot cau "9-ca ALL-PASS" khong kem **ca nao / lenh nao / ket qua nao**, nam tren vat sap bi don, thi sang phien sau **khong ai tai-lap duoc**, va cung khong ai **bac** duoc. Doi chieu chuan da co trong repo: FI cua `distill-shard-probe` duoc ghi **ngay tai call-site** (`session-start.md:186`: *"Fault-inject 6/6 2-chiều (0/6/7-biên/8 + 2 ca anti-dương-giả)"* — co **liet ca**), va FI cua `nhip-no-probe` ghi o `harness-11-engine.md:423` (**ghi ca 4 ve + ca -RepoRoot bay**). ⇒ Chuan cua nha nay la **ghi CA, khong ghi TONG**.
- **De-xuat:** chuyen "FI 9-ca" sang cho ben (session-log S152 **hoac** comment ngay tren tung khoi moi), **kem danh-sach ca** (vd: enum-parity {key thieu / key la / count lech} · N/A {0-pointer} · latch {seed / rise / -Ack} · l2idx {cap null / over / under}). 9 con so tran khong phai bang-chung; 9 **ca co ten** thi la.
- ⚠️ **Tao KHONG phan "FI khong chay"** — WAL noi la co, va tao khong co co-so bac. Tao chi phan **do BEN cua vet**: hien la LOW-durability.

## 6. Disposition 4 FLAG @open của chính tao (đo lúc **2026-07-26 ~01:05**, HEAD `493d438`)
🔴 Bang TUNG DONG, khong dua so tong (bai S119 meta-count).

| FLAG @open | trang-thai @close | LENH / chung |
|---|---|---|
| FLAG-1 `permission-matrix/SKILL.md:42` "~60 key" | **CON MO** | `grep -n "60 key"` => `:42` con nguyen. Dung: 0 commit cham `skills/` (mat ①) ⇒ **chua ai nhan viec**, khong phai bi bo. |
| FLAG-2 `STATUS:453` RAG 2447→2448 | **CON MO tai thoi diem do** | `grep -n "RAG chunks" docs/STATUS.md` => `:453` van `**2447**`. ⚠️ Closeout **dang chay ngay luc nay** ⇒ doc dung la *"chua toi luot"*, KHONG phai *"sot"*. Neu closeout co store_memory tiep thi so lai nhich — nen refresh **cuoi cung**, sau luot ghi cuoi. |
| FLAG-3 `CLAUDE.md:93` mo-ta cay tests | **CON MO** | `git log 1b85713..HEAD -- CLAUDE.md` => **0 commit**. 2 phuong-an @open van cho owner/lead chon. |
| FLAG-4 so-cua-TAO 18→19 command | ✅ **DONG** | `ls -1 .claude/commands/*.md \| wc -l` => **19** (khong doi trong phien). Moc cua tao nay = **19**; day la so cua tao, khong co file repo nao phai sua. |

📌 Ngoai ra 2 file docs khac co doi trong cua-so A (thuoc mat ④, do lead xu queue disposition — tao chi **ghi nhan**, khong tinh la finding cua tao): `docs/STATUS.md` 1 dong (`:455` bundle-hash `BVCukFP5`/`DoxyEOxh` → `B2j1LQ-v`/`C3wbJegk`, dong FLAG-2 cua lead-stale) · `docs/HANDOFF.md` 2 dong.

## 7. VERDICT @close

🔴 **PHAM-VI TAP-DO (bat buoc khai — anti-pattern #2 cua chinh tao):** moi so duoi = trong cua-so **A = `1b85713..HEAD`** (HEAD `493d438`), do luc **2026-07-26 ~00:55–01:10**, tren **4 mat + 2 file docs canonical**. **KHONG** phai repo-wide. Cua-so B (tu @open) cho **cung tap** ⇒ 2 truc trung nhau, khai 1 lan.

**PASS_WITH_FLAGS** — **4 FLAG (1 MED · 3 LOW · 0 HIGH · 0 CRITICAL)** + 1 nit. 0 FAIL. **0 viec tu sua** (propose-only).

| Mat | Doi | Verdict | Ruot |
|---|---|---|---|
| ① Skill | **0 file** | **PASS** | 0 commit + 0 worktree-change (2 kenh). Khoi Budget-da-xoa `ef-core:109/:117` **CHUA VA = DUNG trang-thai** (queue disposition-7, chua co lenh; H1 propose-only) — khong phai sot |
| ② Sub-role | **6 file** | **PASS** | 4/4 block NEVER × 5 item, **coverage 20/20 persona** (gap B3 dong TRON) · roster GIU 20 · reviewer:25 reword **nghia giau hon, KHONG Goodhart** (thuoc hong that: stop-list-verb bat-kha-match by-construction) · README:5 khop `settings.json` · 🔴 **RESTART da thoa tu truoc luot nay** (chung truc-tiep: system-prompt cua chinh tao chua block) |
| ③ Plugin | **0 file** | **PASS** | 18/15/3 IDENTICAL + **mtime 07-25 08:36:50 truoc phien** (chung doc-lap, khong dua so trung) · marketplace 37 · standalone 23 · project-settings 0 khoa plugin · new-alloc **0 action** |
| ④ Docs/cmd/scripts | **7 file** (+2 docs) | **PASS_WITH_FLAGS** | **C1 MED** sweep sleep-AUTO sot **5 site cung-lop** (2 trong CHINH 2 file vua va) · **C2 LOW** `l2idx`: nhan "4-ve" DUNG (khong dong) nhung mau-literal stale 3 cho, nang nhat la **self-doc `nhip-no-probe.ps1:22` cung commit** · **C3 LOW** `-Detail`/`-Ack` **0 doc nao co** |
| ⑤ FI-vet | — | **1 LOW** | **C4** FI 9-ca chi song o `WAL.md:10` (so tam ≤40 dong, se bi trim) + **0 vet in-file** o ca 4 khoi moi; chuan cua nha nay la **ghi CA** (`session-start.md:186` · `engine:423`), khong ghi TONG |

### NEW-ALLOC (capability MOI → nha) — **3 de-xuat** (+1 honest-zero)
| # | Thu moi | Nha de-xuat | Ly do chon cho do |
|---|---|---|---|
| N1 | `mfe-eval.ps1 -Detail` | `eval/mfe/README.md:21-24` khoi "How to run" | anh-em `-Tier`/`-Judge` **da o day**; giu 1 home, khong chep 2 noi |
| N2 | `mfe-eval.ps1 -Ack` | **cung khoi** + **nhan quyen "owner-action"** | `-Ack` GHI state va **lam im GOODHART-WARN vinh-vien** vao `.mfe-state.json` (**git-tracked**) ⇒ neu ai cung bam duoc thi no thanh **cua thoat Goodhart** dung cai ma B4 vua dung len de dong |
| N3 | ve `l2idx` | `scripts/nhip-no-probe.ps1:22` (self-doc header) | day la **home that** cua format; refresh du `l2idx N over`. (2 mau o command → cat, xem C2) |
| — | plugin/skill MOI | **0 action** | 0 nguon moi (marketplace 37 = 37, standalone 23 = 23). Carry `security-guidance` van **quyen owner** (mang hook Stop) |

### CHORE (tooling/docs) — **4 de-xuat**
1. **C1 MED** — quet not 5 site consent: `session-start.md:276` · `session-end.md:148` · `ring4-audit.md:26` · `ring4-audit.md:27` · nhan o `sleep-recovery-memory-l2.md:55`. 🔴 Va bang **BO menh-de so-sanh** (`:276`/`:148`), dung doi thanh cau so-sanh moi — con so-sanh la con tu-lao-hoa lan sau.
2. **C2 LOW** — `nhip-no-probe.ps1:22` refresh du; `session-start.md:265` + `session-end.md:113` **cat mau-literal thanh `NHIP-NO: …`** (dung luat ma `session-end.md:200` tu ra). **KHONG dong nhan "4-ve"** (dang dung).
3. **C4 LOW** — chuyen "FI 9-ca ALL-PASS" khoi WAL sang session-log S152 / comment tren tung khoi, **kem TEN 9 ca**.
4. **nit** — `grep.exe.stackdump` (1.733B, root repo, `git check-ignore` **exit=1 ⇒ KHONG duoc ignore**, sinh 00:09) → xoa hoac them `.gitignore`; de lai se lam ban `git status` moi phien va co the bi `git add -A` nuot.

### CARRY tu @open (4 — chua toi luot, KHONG phai sot)
FLAG-1 `permission-matrix:42` · FLAG-2 `STATUS:453` 2447→2448 (**nen lam CUOI closeout**, sau luot ghi memory cuoi) · FLAG-3 `CLAUDE.md:93` · disposition-7 `ef-core:109/:117` khoi Budget-da-xoa.

### 📌 CAU CHO HANDOFF — thay cho "nho restart" (dung nguyen van)
> **4 block `Anti-patterns (NEVER)` + reword `reviewer.md:25` DA LIVE trong cua-so hien tai** — chung truc-tiep: system-prompt cua `tooling-auditor` luot @close chua nguyen van block B3 @S152 cua chinh no. **Khong can nhac restart nua**; chi luu: neu mo lai bang mot cua-so CU dang treo tu truoc 22:03 (2026-07-25) thi cua-so do moi phuc-vu ban stale. Nac do: **measured 1/5 file** (tooling-auditor, tu-quan-sat) · **inferred 4/5** (db · harvest · office · reviewer — cung loader, moi edit deu truoc luc tien-trinh CLI hien tai khoi dong 00:00:43). 🔴 **KHONG doc "MFE 20/20 100%" thanh "vai da ngam"**: MFE doc **file tren dia**, registry lap **prompt luc spawn** — 2 nac khac nhau.

### Tu-soi
- Ket luan mat ② **lat nguoc mot nua yeu-cau duoc giao** ("nhac restart") vi tao **do truoc khi nhac** — va tao **tu khai confound** (`00:00:43`) de khong ai doc thanh "chung minh hot-reload". Dung nac, khong overclaim ca 2 chieu.
- 3/4 FLAG moi nam **trong chinh vung vua sua hom nay**, 2 trong so do nam **trong file ma lead vua va cho khac** ⇒ day la lop loi **sweep-sot**, khong phai freshness tut. Mat ①③ tinh hoan toan.
- Tao **khong** de xuat sua bat ky dong nao chi de detector im (luat #3 cua tao): C2 giu nguyen nhan "4-ve" du no la cho de "vá cho gọn"; reviewer:25 tao xet BANG PHEP THU (ban moi noi nhieu hon ban cu) roi moi ket KHONG-Goodhart.



