# sub-harvest-curator-open-S163 — H2 harvest-integrity 5-truc @open (phien-LOGIC L9)

> **INFORM-only / propose-only.** Em main = single-writer. File nay ghi TRONG LUC LAM (chong #53).
> Started: 2026-07-30 16:04 (local). HEAD tai luc bat dau = `6ba5cfe` (wal: flush 20260730T1514).
> Prev-baseline: `.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-30-S162-bookend-close/sub-harvest-curator-close-S162.md` (13.833 B).

## 0. Ke-hoach do (ghi truoc khi do, de doi chieu voi ket qua)
- A. Universe run-folder + orphan (folder-scan, khong dung ledger — ledger RETIRED H18-B S100)
- B. 3 orphan PIN: do NOI DUNG da harvest chua (khong do ten file) — bai S122 32% duong-gia
- C. Coverage: vai da spawn (S162 + S163-open) vs diary co delta moi
- D. F-01 no goc: vai "chay that ma 0 tu-ghi" (ctx-verifier 3 phien lead-seed)
- E. S162 GATE-FAIL 4 finding: con treo may mon
- F. Corruption census (U+FFFD byte-mode) — baseline S162 = 24 hit / 12 file
- G. Placement: `find .claude -type d -empty` + stray `.claude` lac cho (git MU thu-muc rong)
- H. Completeness 4-field + Fidelity-flag

---
## A. UNIVERSE + ORPHAN (folder-scan; ledger RETIRED H18-B S100)

**Lệnh (tái-lập được):**
```
find .claude/workflows/runs -mindepth 1 -maxdepth 1 -type d | wc -l          -> 76
for d in */; do [ -f "$d/run.md" ] || echo "$d"; done                        -> 4
for d in */; do [ -f "$d/run.md" ] && { found=0; for f in "$d"*-synthesis.md "$d"harvest/*-synthesis.md; do
    [ -f "$f" ] && [ -s "$f" ] && found=1; done; [ $found -eq 0 ] && echo "ORPHAN: $d"; }; done
```
- Universe **76 dir** (S162 do 75; Δ+1 = `2026-07-30-S163-bookend-open` = folder DANG MO cua chinh phien nay).
- Khong co `run.md`: **4** = 3 by-design cu (`S117-pe-approve-minmax-range`, `S117-pe-luyke-finalize` spec-only; `S144-bootstrap` co `bootstrap-synthesis.md`) **+1 = `S163-bookend-open` (IN-PROGRESS, chua sinh `run.md`)** -> KHONG orphan, nhung ghi nhan (anti-pattern #3: vang-mat khong doc thanh on).
- **Orphan THAT = 3 / 72** -- khop 100% brief PIN, khong hon khong kem:
  `2026-07-29-S159-bookend-open` · `2026-07-29-S159-tong-quan-pipeline-menu` · `2026-07-29-S160-khkk-dryrun-plan`.
- Δ vs S162: **0** (khong sinh orphan moi; `S162-bookend-close` da co `close-synthesis.md` 7.409 B -> DA DONG).

---

## B. 🔴 3 ORPHAN PIN — DO NOI DUNG, KHONG DO TEN FILE (bai S122: 32% duong-gia)

**Thuoc 2 lop** (mot lop se sai theo huong nguoc nhau nen phai dung ca hai):
- **Lop A (per-FILE pointer):** `grep -r -F -l "<basename>" .claude/agent-memory/` -> pointer nam o so vai NAO (owner-check).
- **Lop B (folder-name pointer):** `grep -r -F -l "<foldername>" .claude/agent-memory/`.

### B1. `2026-07-29-S159-bookend-open` (11 file, 235.969 B) -> 🟢 **NOI DUNG DA HARVEST 10/10**

| sub-file | so vai giu pointer | owner-check |
|---|---|---|
| `harness-audit-return.md` | `harness-audit/MEMORY.md` | ✅ dung nha |
| `harness-eval-return.md` | `harness-eval/MEMORY.md` + `harness-refine/MEMORY.md` | ✅ (cross-ref hop le) |
| `harness-refine-return.md` | `harness-refine/MEMORY.md` + `lead-gap-auditor/archive/2026-07{,.gist}.md` | ✅ |
| `sub-ctx-audit-open-S159.md` | `ctx-audit/MEMORY.md` | ✅ |
| `sub-harvest-curator-open-S159.md` | `harvest-curator/MEMORY.md` | ✅ |
| `sub-lead-gap-open-S159.md` | `lead-gap-auditor/MEMORY.md` | ✅ |
| `sub-lead-stale-open-S159.md` | `lead-stale-auditor/MEMORY.md` | ✅ |
| `sub-ring1-audit-open-S159.md` | `ring1-audit/MEMORY.md` | ✅ |
| `sub-ring2-audit-open-S159.md` | `ring2-audit/MEMORY.md` | ✅ |
| `sub-tooling-auditor-open-S159.md` | `tooling-auditor/MEMORY.md` | ✅ |

⇒ **10/10 sub-file co Evidence-pointer trong dung so cua vai so-huu.** Thu con THIEU **chi la lop cuon (`*-synthesis.md`)**, KHONG phai lop harvest.
🔴 **Phan loai lai: day la SYNTHESIS-orphan, KHONG phai HARVEST-orphan.** Neu goi chung mot ten se uoc-luong sai chi-phi phien sau (tuong phai doc 236 KB de gom; that ra chi phai cuon lai).

### B2. `2026-07-29-S159-tong-quan-pipeline-menu` (13 file) -> 🟡 **9/10 harvest, 1 LOTS**

| sub-file | so vai giu pointer |
|---|---|
| `cicd-verify-1a47a61.md` | `cicd-monitor/archive/2026-07.md` ✅ |
| `cicd-verify-2a72695.md` | `cicd-monitor/archive/2026-07.md` ✅ |
| `cicd-verify-ea962b1.md` | `cicd-monitor/archive/2026-07.md` ✅ |
| `cicd-verify-b5799fc.md` | `cicd-monitor/MEMORY.md` (L1, qua dinh-chinh S162) 🟡 |
| `cicd-verify-a2bbcb9.md` | `cicd-monitor/MEMORY.md` (L1, qua dinh-chinh S162) 🟡 |
| `sub-frontend-designer-tongquan.md` | `frontend-designer/MEMORY.md` ✅ |
| `sub-frontend-designer-dot4.md` | `frontend-designer/MEMORY.md` ✅ |
| `sub-reviewer-diff-dot4.md` | `reviewer/archive/2026-07.md` ✅ |
| `sub-reviewer-diff-dot5.md` | `reviewer/archive/2026-07.md` ✅ |
| `sub-reviewer-diff-tongquan.md` (16.761 B) | **0 hit toan bo `.claude/agent-memory/`** 🔴 |

🔴 **F-01 (S163) MED — `sub-reviewer-diff-tongquan.md` = luot DUY NHAT trong 3 folder khong duoc bat ky so nao tro toi.**
2 anh-em cung lop (`-dot4`, `-dot5`) deu co pointer trong `reviewer/archive/2026-07.md` ⇒ khong phai "reviewer khong bao gio ghi pointer", ma **lech dung 1 file** (dong lop bat-doi-xung m#-S150). Can doi chieu noi dung truoc khi ket "mat": co the noi dung da gop vao entry chung ma khong dan ten file.

### 🔴 B2-bis — TU SUA THUOC CUA CHINH TAO (truoc khi to nguoi khac)

Layer-A dung `grep -F "<basename>"` ⇒ **MU voi cite gop dau-ngoac-nhon**. Bang chung: `investigator-codebase/MEMORY.md:11` cite
`runs/2026-07-29-S160-khkk-dryrun-plan/sub-investigator-codebase-{1,2}.md` — dung 1 dong phu 2 file, ma `grep -F "sub-investigator-codebase-1.md"` ra **0**.
⇒ Layer-A mot minh sinh **AM TINH GIA**. Sua: them **Layer-A'** = grep theo **STEM** (`grep -r -o -F "<stem>"`) + Layer-B (folder-name) + Layer-C (noi-dung dac-trung).
Ket qua Layer-A' (stem): `sub-reviewer-diff` **2** · `sub-investigator-codebase` **1** · `sub-reviewer-anchor` **0** · `sub-reviewer-chot` **0** · `sub-reviewer-security` **0** · `sub-reviewer-wave-logic` **0** · `spec-wave-w` **0** · `plan-cha-dry-run` **0**.
Cite day du con song (regex `runs/2026-07-(29|30)-S1[0-9]+[a-z0-9-]*/[A-Za-z0-9_.{},*-]+\.md`) = **8 duong dan duy nhat**, trong do 1 la dang gop `{1,2}`.

### B3. `2026-07-29-S160-khkk-dryrun-plan` (20 file, 250.347 B) -> 🟢 **ORPHAN DO TEN (duong-gia), noi-dung DA harvest**

**(i) Nguyen nhan xep orphan — XAC NHAN gia thuyet cua lead, nhung chan doan phai noi chinh xac:**
folder CO synthesis that = `review-synthesis-clone-s160.md` **8.043 B**. Glob `*-synthesis.md` **neo o DUOI ten**; file nay con `-clone-s160` **SAU** chu `synthesis` ⇒ truot.
⇒ **orphan-do-TEN**, khac lop han B1/B2. `git mv review-synthesis-clone-s160.md review-clone-s160-synthesis.md` (giu nguyen ruot) la du. (Ghi chu: dieu nay S162 da ket, S163 tai-xac-nhan tren dia — de xuat VAN CHUA duoc ap.)

**(ii) Do noi-dung 20 file, chia 3 lop:**

| lop | file | trang thai harvest |
|---|---|---|
| **turn-record co pointer** | `sub-investigator-codebase-1/2.md` (24.2K+32.2K) | ✅ `investigator-codebase/MEMORY.md:11` cite gop `{1,2}` + engine-label + `#53 garble -> resume sach, dia mat 0 B` |
| | `review-synthesis-clone-s160.md` | ✅ `reviewer/archive/2026-07.md:181` cite dich danh |
| **turn-record KHONG pointer, harvest QUA SYNTHESIS (transitive)** | `sub-reviewer-4` `-5` `anchor-A/B/C` `chot-cuoi` `security` `wave-logic` (8 file) | 🟡 0 pointer per-file, NHUNG 2 entry noi-dung phu: `reviewer/archive:179` = **CHOT-CUOI** (`sub-reviewer-chot-cuoi-s160.md` GO-WITH-FIXES 12/13 landed) · `:181` = **review SPEC-BO 6 lane `/fable-clone`** cuon qua chinh `review-synthesis-clone-s160.md` ⇒ 6 lane vao so **giao-tiep qua lop cuon**, dung thiet-ke |
| **deliverable, KHONG phai turn-record** | 7 `spec-wave-w*.md` + `plan-cha-dry-run-*.md` + `src-RG-001-v02-ma-so-hd.txt` (9 file) | ➖ **khong thuoc dien harvest** — day la SAN PHAM (spec dau-vao cho wave sau), tieu thu boi `docs/`+HANDOFF, khong phai ban-ghi-luot |

**(iii) 🔴 1 file dang nghi — da mo RUOT (m#19: file nho = nghi van):**
`sub-reviewer-anchor-A-s160.md` = **312 B**, ruot = **SKELETON RONG**: `## VERDICT-pending / (chua chot...)`, `## FINDINGS / (append tung finding...)`, ket `END-placeholder (chua hoan tat)`.
⇒ **`skeleton-nac-2`** (byte>0 ma ruot toan heading) — dung sub-class da ghi trong `feedback_agent_return_garble_recover`. Anh-em cung lo anchor-B 21.059 B / anchor-C 18.866 B deu day ⇒ **lech dung 1 lane**. Khong phai gap harvest (khong co noi dung de gom) nhung la **chung tich #53 con nam tren dia**, nen ghi nhan de dung tuong lane-A da chay.

⇒ **B3 verdict: KHONG phai harvest-gap.** Viec con lai = 1 lenh `git mv` doi ten cho khop glob.

---

## B4. 🔴 CHOT F-01 (S163) — `sub-reviewer-diff-tongquan.md`: **MAT THAT**, khong phai "thieu con-tro"

Tao tu dat nghi van o B2 ("can doi chieu noi dung truoc khi ket mat"). Da lam nôt, 3 lop:

1. **Layer-A' stem:** `sub-reviewer-diff` = **2 hit** = `-dot4` + `-dot5`. Khong co dang gop `{tongquan,dot4,dot5}`. ⇒ 0 pointer, khong phai am-tinh-gia.
2. **Layer-B entry-map:** `reviewer` co dung **2 entry S159** (`archive/2026-07.md:175` + `:177`), map ro rang:
   - `:175` = **dot-4** — dan `fe-user 984+/337−`; do dia: **`984+/337−` chi co trong `sub-reviewer-diff-dot4.md:4`**; `tongquan` la **585+/143− (728 dong)**.
   - `:177` = **dot-5** (`PWF 10 FLAG 0H/4M/6L`) = `sub-reviewer-diff-dot5.md:152`.
   - ⇒ **khong entry nao la dot-1/tong-quan.**
3. **Layer-C noi-dung dac-trung** (7 FLAG cua tongquan): `a11y AA hai nut trung ten doc duoc` · `hai khoa cache cho cung 1 request` · `bao loi hien hai lan`. Grep toan `agent-memory/reviewer/`:
   `khoá cache` **0** · `hai khoá` **0** · `trùng tên` **0** · `a11y`/`aria-label` chi **1 hit o `archive/2026-06.md`** (entry cu, khac viec).
   ⇒ noi dung **KHONG duoc gop vao entry chung**.

**KET: MAT THAT** — luot review dot-1 (16.761 B, PASS_WITH_FLAGS 7 FLAG 0H/2M/5L, END-line hop le `<!-- END sub-reviewer-diff-tongquan · TOTAL=7 FLAG -->`) **chua tung vao so `reviewer`**. Nguyen lieu **con nguyen tren dia** (git-tracked) ⇒ **phuc hoi duoc** bang 1 entry distill (cung lop thiet-hai voi F-02/S162: mat lop CHUNG CAT, khong mat nguyen lieu).

### ⭐ m#25 (method moi) — **verdict trung khuon giua cac luot anh-em ⇒ verdict-match KHONG phai bang chung harvest**
`tongquan` va `dot4` co verdict **giong het**: `PASS_WITH_FLAGS — 7 FLAG (0H/2M/5L)`. Neu do coverage bang "so co dong verdict khop" thi entry `:175` se **an ca hai** ⇒ bao "da harvest" cho ca luot chua harvest = **duong-gia**.
Discriminator PHAI la **con so RIENG-BIET** (diffstat `984+/337−` vs `585+/143−`) hoac **bai hoc dac-trung**, khong phai verdict.

---

## C. COVERAGE — vai da spawn vs so co delta

### C1. Phien nay (S163 @open) — IN-PROGRESS, ghi nhan chu KHONG cham
`runs/2026-07-30-S163-bookend-open/` (16:12): `run.md` 4.118 B · `sub-lead-gap-open-S163.md` **1.302 B** · `sub-lead-stale-open-S163.md` 5.289 B · `sub-tooling-auditor-open-S163.md` 10.674 B · file nay.
- 🔵 **LIVE probe m#19 tren file 1.302 B:** da mo RUOT -> **KHONG phai skeleton-chet**: co header + enum dong 11 class + checklist 8 muc `[x]1/[ ]7` dang chay. ⇒ **IN-PROGRESS hop le**, khong flag.
- Folder chua co `*-synthesis.md` ⇒ **khong tinh orphan** (dang mo).

### C2. Phien truoc (S162) — 14 vai co artifact tren dia

| nhom | vai | artifact | entry S162 trong so? |
|---|---|---|---|
| bookend-close (10) | ctx-audit · harvest-curator · lead-gap · lead-stale · ring1 · ring2 · harness-audit · harness-eval · harness-refine | 9 sub-file | ✅ 9/9 co, deu nhan `[LEAD SEED ON-BEHALF @closeout M9]` |
| | **tooling-auditor** | `sub-tooling-auditor-close-S162.md` **15.517 B** | 🔴 **KHONG** |
| cay-4-folder (4) | ctx-verifier · frontend-designer · reviewer · cicd-monitor | 4 | ✅ 4/4 (ctx-verifier = seed hoi-to, dong F-01/S162) |

### 🔴 F-02 (S163) HIGH — `tooling-auditor` CHAY @S162 ma so KHONG co entry S162

- Artifact that: `runs/2026-07-30-S162-bookend-close/sub-tooling-auditor-close-S162.md` = **15.517 B**, mtime 07-30 14:27.
- `grep -c "S162" .claude/agent-memory/tooling-auditor/MEMORY.md` = **1** — nhung mo ra: hit duy nhat o **dong 55** la **stub moved-not-cut** (`… verbatim → archive/2026-07.md **@S162 moved-not-cut** …`), **KHONG phai entry ghi viec S162**.
- Entry MOI NHAT cua vai = **S153** (dong 3). ⇒ **thieu tron 1 luot**.
- 🔴 **Khong phai "file khong ai dung":** commit closeout `e5123ff` CO cham file nay (`tooling-auditor/MEMORY.md | 4 +-`) — tuc lead da **curate** so do @S162 nhung **quen seed entry**. 9 vai anh em cung dot deu duoc `| 1 +`.
- **Control-duong:** `ring1-audit/MEMORY.md:2` co dung khuon `- **S162 (07-30) … [LEAD SEED ON-BEHALF @closeout M9 — nguon: sub-ring1-audit-close-S162.md 17.231 B + return]`. ⇒ khuon ton tai, chi rieng tooling-auditor truot.

---

## D. NO GOC F-01/S162 (`ctx-verifier` 3 phien lead-seed) — 🔴 **TAO PHAN LOAI LAI CACH DAT VAN DE**

S162 ket: *"vai chua BAO GIO tu APPEND ⇒ hong khau GHI, khong phai phat hien"*. Do lai:

1. **11/23 vai la INFORM-only** (`grep -c "INFORM-only" .claude/agents/<role>.md` ≥1): ctx-verifier · ctx-audit · tooling-auditor · harvest-curator · ring1 · ring2 · lead-gap · lead-stale · harness-audit · harness-eval · harness-refine. Voi nhom nay **LUAT cam tu-ghi** (em main = single-writer, B3 VERIFY→APPEND) ⇒ **lead-seed la DUNG THIET KE, khong phai loi cua vai.**
2. **Frontmatter `tools:` cua ca 8 vai probe (ke ca `reviewer`, `cicd-monitor`) deu KHONG liet ke `Write`/`Edit`.**
   🔴 **Nhung day KHONG phai bang chung "khong the ghi":** chinh tao @S163 **da tao duoc file nay bang Write tool** luc 16:04 ⇒ **grant runtime ≠ frontmatter**. (Ghi nhan de khong ai suy ra ket luan sai tu frontmatter; con freshness cua frontmatter la dat cua `tooling-auditor` H1, tao khong lan.)
   ⇒ Ket dung: chan tu-ghi la **CHINH SACH**, khong phai **kha nang**. Cum tu "hong khau GHI" cua S162 do do **do sai dia chi**.
3. **Benh THAT nam o dau:** seeding la **diem don nhat phia lead** — moi phien no **rot dung 1 vai**:
   - S153 rot `ctx-verifier` (seed hoi-to) · S158 rot `ctx-verifier` (seed hoi-to) · **S162 rot `tooling-auditor` (VAN DANG HO)**.
   ⇒ Khong phai "1 vai hong", ma **1 buoc quy trinh co ty-le-rot ~1/10 moi luot**. Sua nguoi (bat ctx-verifier tu ghi) se KHONG chan duoc; sua duoc = **checklist doi chieu artifact-vs-entry ngay truoc commit closeout** (dung phep do C2 o tren, 3 lenh).

---

## E. 4 MON `GATE-FAIL` CUA S162 — NAY CON TREO MAY MON

| # | finding S162 | trang thai @S163 | bang chung |
|---|---|---|---|
| **F-01** ctx-verifier 0 entry S162 | ✅ **DONG** | `ctx-verifier/MEMORY.md` dong 3 = `- **S162 (2026-07-30) LUOT 3 @/tiep window-4 L8 — verdict CO-CO — 8 co [LEAD SEED ON-BEHALF @closeout …]`; commit `e5123ff` `+1` |
| **F-02** cicd "verbatim→archive" khai SAI (#422/#425) | 🟡 **NUA DONG — con treo phan NOI DUNG** | **Honesty DONG:** `cicd-monitor/MEMORY.md:9` nay co errata cong khai *"DINH CHINH @S162 (H2 F-02 HIGH) … #422 b5799fc va #425 a2bbcb9 CHUA TUNG vao archive"* + tro ve nguyen lieu. **Noi dung VAN HO:** `grep -c -F b5799fc/a2bbcb9 archive/2026-07.md` = **0** · `git log -S"b5799fc" -- .claude/agent-memory/cicd-monitor/archive/` = **0 commit** (RONG toan lich su, y het S162). ⇒ lop chung-cat chua duoc phuc hoi |
| **F-03** khuon END-line (`SHIP-READY` khong co tren dia) | 🟡 **CHUA THANH LUAT** | Do tren chinh folder S163: 3/4 `sub-*.md` dang chay **chua co END-line** (2 file da >5 KB). (Do luc 16:12, cac file con dang chay ⇒ **khong ket la vi pham**, chi ghi nhan luat chua co rang) |
| **F-04** thieu truong `Evidence:` (2/4 vai) | ✅ **DONG** | `frontend-designer/MEMORY.md:48` + `reviewer/MEMORY.md:3` nay deu co `Evidence:` NGAY TRONG entry S162; `cicd-monitor` van co |

⇒ **2 DONG · 2 con treo** (F-02 phan noi dung · F-03 chua thanh luat).
🔴 Cong them **1 mon MOI cung lop tai phat**: F-02/S163 (`tooling-auditor` thieu entry S162) — **cung ho so voi F-01/S162 nhung khac vai**.

---

## F. CORRUPTION — **PASS**, Δ = 0 so voi baseline S162

**Lenh (da kiem exit-code — bai F-09/S159 `grep -P` chet rc=2 im lang):**
```
find .claude -type f -name "*.md" | wc -l                                  -> 796 file (S162: 781, Δ+15)
find .claude -type f -name "*.md" -print0 | xargs -0 perl -ne \
  '$n=()=/\xEF\xBF\xBD/g; if($n){print "$ARGV:$.:$n\n"}'                   -> PIPE-EXIT=0/0
```
- **U+FFFD = 24 hit / 12 file** — **KHOP CHINH XAC baseline S162 (24/12), Δ = 0.**
- **Control-duong (bat buoc theo anti-pattern #2):** `printf 'x\xEF\xBF\xBDy'` -> `CTRL_HITS=1` ⇒ detector **CON SONG**, con so 24 khong phai "lenh chet doc thanh sach".
- 12 file mang hit: 3 file `harvest-curator/*` (self-quote co y) · 1 `cicd-monitor/archive/2026-06.md` · 8 file trong `runs/` (S144 · 4 file S152 · 2 file S159 · 1 h11-doublecheck) — **toan bo la MENTION** (trich lai ky tu hong lam bang chung trong chinh bao cao ve no) = **citation-trap doi-4**, da phan loai @S162.
- **0 file .md 0-byte.** `find .claude -type f -size 0` = **10 file, 100% la `.gitkeep`** (5 run-folder 06-18 dang `sub-md/`+`harvest/`) — y het S162.
- 🔴 **0 hit trong bat ky file nao sinh @S163.**
⇒ **CORRUPTION PASS · baseline ky sau giu nguyen = 24 hit / 12 file.**

---

## G. PLACEMENT — **PASS** (chay o buoc CHOT 16:15, bai S152 T-5/T-6)

git **MU voi thu-muc RONG** (m#13) ⇒ chay RIENG, khong doc `git status`:
```
find .claude -type d -empty | wc -l                                      -> 0
find . -type d -empty -not -path "./.git/*" -not -path "*/node_modules/*" -> 3
find . -type d -name ".claude"      -not -path "./node_modules/*" …      -> 1  (= ./.claude)
find . -type d -name "agent-memory" -not -path "./node_modules/*" …      -> 1  (= ./.claude/agent-memory)
find .claude/agent-memory -mindepth 1 -maxdepth 1 -type d | wc -l        -> 23  (khop so lead vua do)
```
- **`.claude` empty-dir = 0** ⇒ co S159 *"5→6 DANG TANG"* **VAN DONG** (S162 dong, S163 giu). Khong tai phat.
- 3 empty-dir repo-wide = `./.vs/sd` + `obj/Debug|Release/net10.0/staticwebassets` ⇒ **build/IDE artifact, KHONG phai memory-misland**. Ghi nhan de lan sau khong bao dong nham (chung khong nam trong `.claude`).
- **0 stray `.claude` long trong run-folder** (lop `agent-cwd-relative-memory-misland`) · **0 stray `agent-memory`**.
- **Containment (Harness-10, run-folder git-TRACKED):** `git status --porcelain` loc bo `{runs/, agent-memory/, governance/.session-counter.json}` -> **RONG** ⇒ **0 tracked-change ngoai vung**.
- **Delta mo-coi (chua APPEND):** 0 — moi thay doi deu la file dang chay cua phien nay + counter.

### G-bis. 🔵 Quan sat CO LOI cho chong-#53 (do duoc, khong phai suy luan)
`git log` trong luc tao dang chay: `77b1ad8` 16:08 · `6a34687` 16:12 · `302430d` 16:14 = **WAL flush tu commit run-folder moi ~2-4 phut**.
Bang chung truc tiep: `git cat-file -s HEAD:…/sub-harvest-curator-open-S163.md` = **10.740 B** trong khi dia = **17.412 B**.
⇒ artifact cua sub **da nam trong git TRUOC khi sub ket thuc**. Neu bi kill, thiet hai toi da = **1 cua so flush**, khong phai ca luot. Cung cố ket luan S158: chong #53 = **thiet ke ARTIFACT**, khong phai prompt.

---

## H. COMPLETENESS + FIDELITY

### H1. Completeness 4-field — **PASS-with-debt**
- 9/9 entry lead-seed @S162 co du `{task · verdict · learned · evidence}` + nhan nguon `[LEAD SEED ON-BEHALF @closeout M9 — nguon: <file> <byte> B + return]`.
- `Evidence:` (no F-04/S162) nay **DU o ca 3 vai** ⇒ dong.
- **No con lai:** khuon **END-line** (F-03/S162) chua thanh luat soi-duoc ⇒ van co the tai dien ca "verdict khong ton tai tren dia".

### H2. FIDELITY — **STRONG** (khong tu phan "bia"; chi cham truy-duoc-ve-dia)
Do byte-figure ma cac entry S162 TU TRICH, doi chieu `wc -c` that:

| cite trong so | disk | verdict |
|---|---|---|
| `sub-harvest-curator-close-S162.md 13.833 B` | 13833 | ✅ EXACT |
| `sub-lead-gap-close-S162.md 18.638 B` | 18638 | ✅ EXACT |
| `sub-lead-stale-close-S162.md 22.035 B` | 22035 | ✅ EXACT |
| `sub-ring1-audit-close-S162.md 17.231 B` | 17231 | ✅ EXACT |
| `sub-ring2-audit-close-S162.md 22.744 B` | 22744 | ✅ EXACT |

⇒ **5/5 byte-exact.** Cong 2 doi chung noi dung:
- `cicd-monitor/MEMORY.md:9` errata tro *"con nguyen o runs/2026-07-29-S159-tong-quan-pipeline-menu/cicd-verify-{b5799fc,a2bbcb9}.md"* -> dia: **9.930 B** va **9.860 B**, ton tai that ⇒ errata **trung thuc**, khong che loi.
- Entry S162 cua chinh tao khai *"baseline moi 24 hit/12 file"* -> do lai hom nay **24/12** ⇒ **tu-khop**.
- **0 ca nghi bia ⇒ KHONG escalate `reviewer`.**

---

## I. TONG KET — 6 FINDING + 3 phan-loai-lai

| # | muc | do | trang thai |
|---|---|---|---|
| **F-01** | `sub-reviewer-diff-tongquan.md` (16.761 B, PWF 7 FLAG) **CHUA TUNG vao so `reviewer`** — MAT THAT lop chung cat (3 lop do deu 0) | **HIGH** | MO |
| **F-02** | `tooling-auditor` chay @S162 (artifact 15.517 B) ma **0 entry S162**; file DA bi cham trong `e5123ff` ⇒ curate co, seed quen | **HIGH** | MO |
| **F-03** | F-02/S162 con treo phan NOI DUNG: #422/#425 chua re-distill (`git log -S -- archive/` = 0 commit) | **MED** | NUA DONG |
| **F-04** | Khuon **END-line** (F-03/S162) chua thanh luat soi-duoc; 3/4 sub-file dang chay chua co | **LOW** | MO |
| **F-05** | `sub-reviewer-anchor-A-s160.md` **312 B skeleton-nac-2** con nam tren dia (VERDICT-pending, END-placeholder) — chung tich #53 | **LOW** | GHI NHAN |
| **F-06** | `git mv review-synthesis-clone-s160.md -> review-clone-s160-synthesis.md` (de S162, chua ap) — con lam glob bao orphan gia | **LOW** | MO |

**3 phan-loai-lai (dong gop chinh cua luot nay):**
1. **SYNTHESIS-orphan ≠ HARVEST-orphan** — `S159-bookend-open` co **10/10 sub-file da co pointer trong dung so cua vai so huu**; thu thieu chi la lop CUON. Chi phi phien sau: **cuon lai**, KHONG phai doc 236 KB de gom.
2. **`S160-khkk-dryrun-plan` = orphan-do-TEN**, noi dung da harvest (2 entry reviewer + 1 entry investigator-codebase, 6 lane vao so qua lop cuon). Chi can 1 lenh `git mv`.
3. **F-01/S162 do sai dia chi:** 11/23 vai la INFORM-only ⇒ **luat cam tu-ghi**, lead-seed la DUNG thiet ke. Benh that = **buoc seed phia lead rot ~1 vai/luot** (S153 ctx-verifier · S158 ctx-verifier · S162 tooling-auditor). Sua = **checklist artifact-vs-entry truoc commit closeout**, khong phai "bat vai tu ghi".

**5 truc:** Coverage **FAIL** (F-01 + F-02) · Completeness **PASS-with-debt** · Fidelity **STRONG** (5/5 byte-exact, 0 nghi bia) · Placement **PASS** · Corruption **PASS** (24/12, Δ=0, control-duong song).

**PROPOSE cho em main (propose-only, VERIFY→APPEND; da DEDUP — khong trung entry nao dang co):**
- P1 (HIGH) seed entry S162 cho `tooling-auditor` tu `sub-tooling-auditor-close-S162.md` 15.517 B, nhan `[LEAD SEED ON-BEHALF @S163 — phat hien boi H2, S162 seeding pass sot]`.
- P2 (HIGH) distill 1 entry `reviewer` cho luot dot-1 tu `sub-reviewer-diff-tongquan.md` (7 FLAG: a11y AA trung ten · lot tieng Anh · 2 khoa cache · bao loi 2 lan).
- P3 (MED) re-distill #422/#425 tu `cicd-verify-{b5799fc,a2bbcb9}.md` -> `cicd-monitor/archive/2026-07.md`, roi sua stub dong 9.
- P4 (LOW) `git mv` doi ten synthesis S160 cho khop glob neo-duoi.
- P5 (LOW) chot luat END-line + them buoc do C2 (artifact-vs-entry) vao closeout.

END harvest-curator-open-S163 — VERDICT=GATE-FAIL — TOTAL=6 — COVERAGE=8/8 truc
