# SYNTHESIS — bookend @open S192 (phien-LOGIC L16, cua-so 1) — 2026-08-13

> 5 vong + khoi CHAM chay TRON MOT LUOT (ONE-SHOT YC-018/YC-027). 12 vai spawn, 11 artifact, ~277 KB.
> HEAD @open `05ddefbd` · counter H24 65->66 · lead = Opus 5 MAX · HMW-mode ON.

## 1. VERDICT TUNG VONG

| vong | vai | verdict | byte |
|---|---|---|---|
| V1 | `tooling-auditor` (H1) | `PASS_WITH_FLAGS — 7 finding` (2 HIGH) | 19.848 |
| V1 | `harvest-curator` (H2) | `GATE-FAIL — 6 finding` | 20.721 |
| V1 | `ring1-audit` (KIEM) | **15D / 7T / 3KC** (25 claim) | 37.829 |
| V2 | `lead-stale-auditor` DEEP | `10 FLAG (SAN)` + 1 ESCALATE + 1 INFORM | 27.535 |
| V2 | `lead-gap-auditor` DEEP | `5 FLAG (2 HIGH)` | 22.123 |
| V2 | `ring2-audit` (KIEM) | **12D / 2T / 1KC** | 37.141 |
| V3 | `harness-eval` (nac 1) | `MIXED — 39 truc` | 39.311 |
| V3 | `harness-refine` (nac 2) | `2 action / 16 BAC` | 22.467 |
| V3 | `harness-audit` (nac 3) | **10D / 3T / 2KC**, falsify 17 phep **3 BROKE** | 46.623 |
| V4 | nen-ngu + `ring4-audit` | **KHONG chay** (shard-probe `12/15 => IM`) => ring4 **NO-OP pin-missing, KHAI** | — |
| V5 | floor/detector | may: detectors 58+29 · spec-audit 2 GAP · backfill · test 697 | — |
| P | `score-counter` (tang-2) | **5 MUC nhac>=2 / mau so 26** | 6.460 |
| P | `score-count-auditor` (tang-3) | **tang-1 SAI · tang-2 DUNG** | 20.792 |

## 2. BON PHAT HIEN CAU-TRUC (khong phai lech so le)

### (a) GHOST-WIRE x2 — cung ho "co SO, khong co DUONG DAN"
- `jump_on_class_repeat` — **0 reader that**. 2 hit deu la doi so thu 3 cua `Write-Flag` (chuoi goi-y-sua). `h24-signal-write.ps1` = **0 chu `jump`** — con may DUY NHAT biet tally tang thi khong bao gio so nguong. Control-duong: `light_every`/`deep_every` CO dereference that. SE tu khai lo nay @S180 => **12 nhan phien y nguyen**.
- `strikes_total=25` — bat dong **33 entry / 18,12 ngay**. Thuoc DUNG (nac-3 tu cong 16 row = 25). Cai hong: **0 script ghi `error-ledger`** (hit duy nhat trong comment `:1588`) => tin-hieu khong co cua di vao.

### (b) LOP LOI VO HINH HAI TANG — "sai LUC SINH, source khong stale"
3 ca cung luot cung hinh dang: `VALID_ROLES`=43 · tap slot-(89) · "React 18".
- **Enum `flag_classes` KHONG co o nao chua** (dinh nghia `view-stale-*` doi "source da doi").
- **Nguong JUMP khong may nao doc**.
=> vo hinh **ca khi dem lan khi kich**. Day la cau tra loi cho `ESCALATE-1`.

### (c) DAT-AO DO CAU TRUC — thuoc do SAI DAI LUONG
`nhip-no-probe` in `run-chua-gom 0/1` nhung do **su co mat cua file `*-synthesis.md`**, KHONG do **delta da ve so** (source `:156-182` khong cham `agent-memory`). => bao 0 trong khi **8 slot thung**. `ring5-audit` duoc **4 phep do cham xanh cung luc** (delta-0 · N/A · ok · folder-da-gom); phu instrument truc ve-so = **0/5**.

### (d) `git status` MU VOI 3 LOP RESIDUAL — backstop that bi rong-hoa
1. **thu-muc RONG** (git khong track): 5 dir `.claude/agent-memory/<ten-vai>/` tai sinh trong run-folder theo cwd tuong doi; don giua chung vo nghia (don 02:43, tai sinh 02:46, lan 6). Thuoc dung = `find -type d -empty`.
2. **bi Stop-hook nuot truoc khi soat**: `score-counter` tu ghi 2 file vao `agent-memory/` (MEMORY.md + `phep_dem_tang2.md` 2.710 B MOI) -> commit `7f64d472 wal:`. Thuoc dung = `git log --name-only` tren commit `wal:`.
3. file lead tuong chua ghi.

## 3. HAI SO NANG NHAT VE HARVEST (3 nguon doc lap, deu chi DUNG 2 lo)

| nguon | mau so | ket qua |
|---|---|---|
| `harvest-curator` | 12 | 10/12 = 83% — **mau so TRUOT** (loc bat-doi-xung: THEM `cicd-monitor` thung, BO `ctx-verifier` dat) |
| `harness-eval` | 11 | 9/11 |
| `ring1-audit` | 11/13 | nhat quan |
| `harness-audit` (nac-3) | 13 file -> 11 mang ten vai -> **9 ve so** | **CHOT** |

**2 lo dung ten:** `ring5-audit` (3.708 B) + `harness-audit` (8.191 B). 🔴 no-self-exempt: nac-3 **xac nhan chinh no la 1 trong 2 lo** (diary mtime 08-11, `S191`=0, `S19x`=0).

**No harvest that (H2 do, `ring1` cong lai khop byte):** `STATUS:517` khai ~306 KB — **that 113.993 B**, sai CA HAI CHIEU (S171 143.682 da dong tron van ghi treo · S168 khai 162.916/9-10 vai that 59.119/2 vai · S188+S191 54.874 B vang so).

## 4. LOI CUA LEAD — 6 ca, deu do vai doc lap bat, lead xac nhan lai bang phep do rieng

| lead khai | that | ai bat |
|---|---|---|
| cham diem tang-1 = 6 muc | **5** (`awk` cot 6, luat loai-tru cot 8 => ve cau truc khong ap noi luat) | tang-2 + tang-3 |
| `VALID_ROLES` = 43 | **29** (`ring2` qua 4 duong; H1 khai 32 cung sai) | `lead-stale` -> `ring2` |
| 9 mark Active-High | **11** row | `lead-stale` -> `ring2` |
| "2 be mat roster KHOP" | **TRUOT pham vi** — 2/7 mat, va la 2 mat dong-bien | `ring1` L-1 |
| `run-chua-gom 0` | **1** (anh chup cu) | `harness-eval` |
| canh bao "ring2 PROPOSE 2/2" | dung noi dung, **sai KY** (`warnFloor` chan `:198-206`) | `harness-refine` -> nac-3 DAT |

🔴 **Khuon chung (nac-3 phat bieu):** moi so lead **DO bang may** deu dung byte-exact; moi so lead **DEM VE MINH** deu sai. Dung lop `meta-count self-coverage blind-spot`.

🔴 **1 ca lead khen nham roi RUT:** F-B cua H1 ("thieu dung 2 root") — `ring1` chung so dung la **12 root · cay ve 8 · vang 4** (`Hrm`·`Off`·`Personal`·`HopDongCung`). Ap F-B nguyen trang se ghi so SAI va **xoa mat so DUNG cua S186**.

## 5. #53 — 8/9 first-return garble (chi `score-counter` sach)
- Mat **0 byte** 7/8 ca nho artifact-first. Rieng `lead-stale` mat that ~502s do (ghi header roi moi di do).
- 3 sub-class trong 1 luot: **cat-giua** · **nguoc-#53** (return = cau MO DAU) · **cau-garble-chua-finding** (H2: *"moved-marker, not an entry"*).
- 🔴 Bai: lenh "ghi tung muc ngay" phai noi ro **ghi TRUOC khi do cai tiep theo** — `lead-stale` hieu thanh "ghi header truoc" va mat viec.

## 6. VIEC CHO OWNER (khong tu quyet)
1. **Slot (89) dang hoi SAI CAU** — hong 2 cho: tap trinh anh **khong chua dinh** (n>=3 da la 6 NGAY TAI S188 theo `git show ef1d4fbb`), va nhanh (b) "doi nguong" = **no-op**. Nhanh (c) (khai JUMP = chi-bao nguoi-doc) la duong re va that nhat.
2. **ESCALATE-1** — mo enum cho lop "sai luc sinh" hay da sang `error-ledger`?
3. **residual-write `score-counter`** — lead quyet LT3 bac-2 = **GIU + khai**; anh co quyen bao revert.
4. **noi dung la trong tool-output** (khoi "MCP Server Instructions"/computer-use xuat hien trong output Bash cua `harness-eval`) — vai KHONG thuc thi, lead KHONG hanh dong theo. Bao de anh biet.
5. **E-017** (`score-count-auditor` de xuat) + RCA residual-write -> `error-ledger` @closeout.

## 7. VONG Ctx @open — `ctx-audit`: **DAT — 4 FLAG** (17.017 B)

Nhanh **FALLBACK HOI-TO** (phien 0-pause/0-tiep => `ctx-curator`/`ctx-verifier` chua chay lan nao; tu soi 1 lop, KHONG phai da-qua-3-tang).

- **K1 block-0 noi-dung THAT: DAT (manh)** — 5 manh khuon-khong-sinh-duoc.
- **K2-a carry be-mat lead khai: DAT 5/5** (lich su vai: 0/6 @S186 -> 2/4 @S189 -> **5/5**).
- **F-1 HIGH** — be-mat `_end` (lead KHONG khai): **2/7 slug MO COI** = `mind-dinh-chinh-mot-be-mat` + `du-cua-rule-khong-phai-phep-kiem`; 0 hit HANDOFF·WAL·block-0·error-ledger. Nha duy nhat = `session-15/_end` (**khong duoi `.md`** + phien dong = class **tang-hinh** F-1@S173). Ca 2 do CHINH vai nay de @S191.
- 🔴 **Dinh chinh 2 vai ban theo huong AN TOAN:** `lead-stale:155` + `ring2:116/118` bao *vang 4/7* — dung tren HANDOFF nhung chi do **1 nha**; hop 2 nha thi 2 slug duoc block-0 cuu => mo coi that = **2** (it hon nhung **nang hon**).
- **F-2 MED-HIGH** — §B suy giam: mat DIA CHI viec cho anh (prod GD3 + W8) thanh "cho giao viec product"; lech theo huong tran-an. **DA VA.**
- **F-3 MED** — §C tuyen *"6/6 ca"* = chinh no la so **dem-ve-minh**; **0/6 mon truy duoc** tu block-0 (`6→5` va `9→11` 0 hit ca 3 nha); §A **im hoan toan** ve loi lead. **DA VA** (thay bang bang 6 dong dich danh).
- **F-4 INFO/ESCALATE** — khoi *"MCP Server Instructions"* (computer-use) **tai xuat trong tool-output cua chinh `ctx-audit`**, sau ca dau @`harness-eval` => **>=2 ca, 2 vai, cung phien = TAI LAP DUOC**. Ca 2 vai KHONG thuc thi; lead KHONG hanh dong theo. Quyen phan cua owner.
- **K3 may: DAT** — vai tu re-chay `mind-check`, khop PIN byte-exact (lan dau sau 5 phien PIN stale). Dinh chinh: `co=1` la phep **(10) thu-tu**, khong phai phep (4); va artifact gay co do **chinh file vai** => cam dem 2 lan.
- **K4 moi-ngam: DAT** — gieo y §D `:71`; @close cham 2 ve. Khai ke: single-lead => moi chi kin **xuyen cua-so**.

**3 ban va lead DA AP ngay** (LT3 bac-1 *ro => tu va*): §B neu lai dia chi prod-GD3 · §C thay "6/6" bang bang 6 dong · §D them 2 slug mo coi. `mind-check` sau va: **dat=11 TRUOT=0 co=0**.

## 8. #53 TALLY PHIEN — 9/10 first-return garble
Chi `score-counter` sach. Mat **0 byte** 8/9 nho artifact-first; rieng `lead-stale` mat ~502s do (ghi header roi moi di do).
3 sub-class: **cat-giua** · **nguoc-#53** · **cau-garble-CHUA-FINDING** (H2 "moved-marker" · `ring1` "citation loop" · `ctx-audit` "regex nhat trich dan").
🔴 Bai moi: lenh "ghi tung muc ngay" phai noi **ghi TRUOC khi do cai tiep theo**.
