# RUN — S124 adap wave reply + 4 broadcast (fable-clone reviewer @MAX)

- **run-id:** 2026-07-15-S124-adap-wave-reply
- **engine:** `/fable-clone reviewer` @MAX (owner-invoked S124) — ENSEMBLE tier-2, 3 lane reviewer @`model:opus` @`effort:max`, RETURN-small + disk-write (garble-resilient S123 lesson).
- **lead:** Opus 4.8 owner-choice (H23-precedence DEFER — lead=Opus không phân-biệt spawn-param⟂frontmatter).
- **spec:** `spec-adap-wave-reply-15-07-2026.md` (bản plan reviewer refute).
- **HMW-mode:** ON.

## Đề-bài
Adap 1 directed reply (`reply-wave-s122`, pulled+verified STAGE-1) + 4 broadcast mới `outbox/all` (erratum-h8 · h17-cadence-bookend · do-token · bon-vong) + reconcile push-guard/presence. Reviewer rà bản PHÂN-LOẠI in-frame ⟂ owner-gated.

## Ground-truth đã verify (lead, trước review)
- STAGE-1 hash: whole-file + body `7fca0deb…` MATCH.
- push-guard vế N: SE ĐÃ adopt `session-end §5.0/§5.2` (TRAILING-K, ca(2) no-deadlock) — grep-verified.
- 🔴 **Nuance lead tự-bắt:** TRAILING-K refinement = **nguồn của "57 wal: lọt origin/main" S119** (sandwiched-keep §5.0:178) = **trade-off owner-accepted** (no-rewrite > zero-leak, owner-4 "KHÔNG dọn 57"), KHÔNG phải thuần "ahead-of-broadcast". Reviewer L2 kiểm framing này.
- agent frontmatter toàn roster = `model: inherit` (all-inherit H8) — erratum-h8 E-1 nói floor = worker-tier-pin.
- `h24_cadence` = 6/15/3 trong `memory-budget.json` (config, detector đọc key) — h17-bookend supersede scheduler.

## taskList snapshot
| # | lane | role | tier | effort | lens | disk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | L1-scope | reviewer | opus | max | in-frame ⟂ owner-gated authority | sub-reviewer-1.md |
| 2 | L2-fidelity | reviewer | opus | max | đọc-đúng-source? already-done? TRAILING-framing? | sub-reviewer-2.md |
| 3 | L3-honest | reviewer | opus | max | nấc G-011 / overclaim / do-token real-N logic | sub-reviewer-3.md |

## Synthesis — ✅ DONE
→ `review-synthesis.md`. Verdict PASS_WITH_FIXES: SCOPE 0 over-reach · 4 framing-overclaim FIXED pre-ship (push-guard "ahead"→diverge-looser · do-token 26075→**70892** · bon-vong "AHEAD"→n=0 · h17 verified→agreed · +R5-dropped meta-count · E-2 single-probe caveat).
- L3 return #53-garbled → recovered from `sub-reviewer-3.md` disk (garble-resilience validated).
- 6 adap-report written `docs/governance/adap-reports/` (4 new + 2 reconcile). STAGE-1/2 done. 4 owner-decisions surfaced.

## Owner-decisions — 🔴 OWNER OVERRODE reviewer "KHÔNG apply" → LEAD APPLIED (S124)
Reviewer khuyến "surface KHÔNG apply"; anh chốt 4 quyết-định → em APPLY (uncommitted, cần commit @closeout):
1. **E-1 model-tier — APPLIED:** 14/14 frontmatter `model:inherit→opus`+`effort:max` (worker-tier-pin) + hmw.js 7-spot comment sync. 🔴 **restart để ăn runtime.** 🔴 **H23-precedence NAY testable ở lead=Opus** (spawn tier:'fable' → resolved fable-vs-opus) — nếu frontmatter thắng ⇒ `/fable-real` NO-OP (mark H21 AH). **Test phiên kế post-restart.**
2. **h17 — APPLIED giữ-counter** (default-valid §6.4 + vai n=0). adap-report ghi `agreed`.
3. **do-token — measured, cap GIỮ** (anh chốt): STATUS 70892 / HANDOFF 32254 / 27.1% budget — ghi do-token adap-report. Re-tier mega-line = carry (chưa làm).
4. **r6 relocate — APPLIED:** `settings.json autoMemoryDirectory` + copy 50 file → `.claude/auto-memory/` (old backup). 🔴 **UNTRACKED — R6 goal (git-track) CHƯA đạt tới khi COMMIT** (omission-auditor catch). restart+workspace-trust+runtime-verify.

## H24 dogfood — FIRST-EVER real run (2 vai, 0-garble, cả 2 giá-trị THẬT)
- **lead-view-auditor** (`sub-lead-view.md`): 9 flag (8 view-residual-asym + 1 view-stale-count) — bắt trọn doc-sync all-inherit→worker-tier. ĐÃ vá: session-start/fable-clone/README/ultra-on. CLEAN-verified: marks (0 all-inherit, đã annotate) · memory-budget. Corrected lead: marks KHÔNG cần sửa body (P4/P8).
- **lead-omission-auditor** (`sub-lead-omission.md`): 4 gap (2 dropped + 2 sunk) + 1 INFORM. Bắt: R6-untracked · /fable-real-NO-OP-no-durable-record · 4-decision-no-record (FIXED bởi block này) · h24-2vai-chua-chay-falsified. gap-owner-specifics=0 (effort:max captured). 🔴 **INFORM escalate:** gap-carry-aged STRUCTURALLY VACUOUS — HANDOFF tiering (2-3 session) cap carry-lines dưới M=6 ⇒ detector KHÔNG BAO GIỜ fire (S121-known, W3-fix chưa giải). → owner: hạ M, hoặc track carry-age ở ledger KHÔNG-tiered.

## 🔻 CLOSEOUT CHECKLIST (auditors demand — chống re-stamp propagate stale)
- [ ] **COMMIT** `.claude/auto-memory/` (R6 goal = tracked; hook KHÔNG cover path này).
- [ ] HANDOFF carries UPDATE (KHÔNG blind re-stamp): `usermem-outside-repo`→resolved-relocated-need-commit · `h24-2vai-chua-chay`→RAN-S124-both-clean · `h23-precedence-fable`→now-testable-postrestart-Opus · counter 2→3.
- [ ] STATUS §Sub-agents / do-token real-N record + STATUS:6 model-tier "12/12→worker-tier-pin" (mega-line FROZEN-narrative — split per-occurrence, KHÔNG blanket-edit; = re-tier carry territory).
- [ ] auto-memory `project_harness4_two_tier_model.md` + MEMORY.md:45 — update superseded H4→H8→S124 (auto-inject stale).
- [ ] Remaining doc: HANDOFF:5 all-inherit (verify frozen-brief vs live).
- [ ] Hub adap-report email (chờ owner go).
- [ ] Update `.session-counter.json last_audit.light_at_counter=3` (audit ran).
- [ ] Optional: trim effort:max → heavy-roles-only (owner cost-decision).
