HARVEST-CLOSE-S168: GATE-FAIL-5 — 4 vai co delta S168 dung nha + 0 orphan/76 + 0 corruption moi, NHUNG lượt K8-dry-run (tri-thuc dat nhat phien, 15.724 B) khong co spawn-record o bat ky diary nao va `run.md` S164 con 4 dong tick sai so voi viec da ship.

> 5 truc: **Coverage FAIL-2** · Completeness PASS-WITH-FLAGS-1 · Placement PASS-WITH-FLAGS-1 · **Corruption PASS** · Fidelity FLAG-1(→`reviewer`). C5 Layer-3 **PASS 0 orphan**. San-5 **0/0 vacuous**.
> Vai: harvest-curator (H2) — read-only, propose-only. Lead = single-writer (VERIFY→APPEND, B3).
> Ngay do: 2026-08-01. Phien: S168 @close. File do ruot lien tuc (chong #53).

## 0. Universe + tien-de (dang thu thap)

- Repo: `D:\Dropbox\CONG_VIEC\SOLUTION\SOLUTION_ERP`
- Sub duoc lead khai da spawn phien S168: `ctx-verifier` (x1) · `reviewer` (x2) · `cicd-monitor` (x1)
- Folder bookend phien nay: `.claude/workflows/runs/2026-08-01-S168-bookend-close/` (moi tao, hien co `sub-tooling-auditor-close-S168.md` 533 B)
- Cong viec chinh phien S168 KHONG tao run-folder moi — artifact di vao folder CU `2026-07-31-S164-4gd-khkk-fanout/`

### 0.1 Cua so phien S168 — do tu dia, KHONG tu transcript

| Moc | Bang chung |
|---|---|
| S167 dong | `3595655 wal: pause` @2026-08-01T13:36:33+07:00 |
| S168 mo | `_tiep-5.md` ts=`2026-08-01T15:41:23+07:00`, head-sha=`3595655…` (khop pause tren) |
| S168 commit | `a2b37dc`(16:12) `081557b`(16:49) `0bfadc2`(17:08) `b41f002`(17:30) `dd7db21`(18:15) `6918fa9`(18:22) + 6 `wal:` flush |
| Lenh do | `git log --format='%h %cI %s' --since='2026-08-01T00:00:00'` · `find .claude -type f -newermt "2026-08-01 15:45"` |

### 0.2 Universe artifact SINH/SUA trong cua so S168 (24 file, lenh `find -newermt "2026-08-01 15:45"`)

Ruot lien quan harvest (loai file cua chinh vong bookend dang chay):
- `runs/2026-07-31-S164-4gd-khkk-fanout/`: `run.md`(16:04) · `spec-cum1-chi-tiet`(16:04) · `sub-reviewer-gate-gd3d.md`(16:47) · `sub-reviewer-gate-lineeditor.md`(17:01) · `sub-cicd-verify-gd3d-lineeditor.md`(17:18) · **`sub-k8-dryrun.md`(18:22, 15.724 B)**
- `runs/2026-07-30-S163-bookend-open/bookend-open-synthesis.md`(16:08) — orphan S163 lead ha
- `runs/2026-08-01-S166-h24-deep-midsession/h24-deep-synthesis.md`(16:09) — orphan S166 lead ha
- `agent-memory/`: `ctx-curator`(16:10) · `ctx-verifier`(16:10) · `reviewer/archive/2026-07.md`(16:59)+`MEMORY.md`(17:00) · `cicd-monitor/archive/2026-08.md`+`archive/_INDEX.md`(17:21)+`MEMORY.md`(17:23) · `memory-budget.json`(16:21)
- `agents/cicd-monitor.md`(16:03) — sua persona (dia phan H1 tooling-auditor, TAO KHONG cham)
- `auto-memory/feedback_agent_return_garble_recover.md`(16:10)

## 1. TRUC CORRUPTION (do TRUOC vi re + doc lap)

### 1.1 Census U+FFFD byte-mode toan `.claude/`
Lenh (byte-mode, KHONG dung `grep -P` — bai S159 F-09 lenh chet rc=2 doc thanh sach):
```
find .claude -type f \( -name "*.md" -o -name "*.json" -o -name "*.txt" \) -not -path "*/node_modules/*" -print0 \
 | xargs -0 perl -ne 'BEGIN{$n=0;%f=()} if (/\xEF\xBF\xBD/){$n++;$f{$ARGV}++} END{print "TOTAL_HIT=$n FILES=",scalar(keys %f),"\n"; for(sort keys %f){print "  $_ => $f{$_}\n"}}'
```
🔴 **Bay m#20-bis TU DINH cua chinh tao:** `xargs` chia 3 batch ⇒ `END{}` chay 3 lan ⇒ IN 3 dong TOTAL. Phai CONG tay, KHONG doc 1 dong TOTAL nao lam tong.
- batch-1: 7 hit / 4 file · batch-2: 9 hit / 5 file · batch-3: 6 hit / 2 file
- **TONG THAT = 22 hit / 11 file.**

11 file: `cicd-monitor/archive/2026-06.md`(1) · `harvest-curator/archive/2026-06.md`(3) · `harvest-curator/archive/2026-07.md`(2) · `runs/2026-06-18-h11-doublecheck/doublecheck-synthesis.md`(1) · `runs/2026-07-22-S144-bootstrap/sub-harvest-curator-1.md`(1) · `runs/…S152-h24-open-bookend/bookend-synthesis.md`(1) · `…/sub-harvest-S152.md`(1) · `…/sub-harvest-close-S152.md`(5) · `…/sub-ring1-close-S152.md`(1) · `runs/…S159-bookend-open/sub-harvest-curator-open-S159.md`(3) · `…/sub-ring1-audit-open-S159.md`(3)

**Doi chieu cua so S168:** KHONG file nao trong 11 file tren nam trong danh sach `-newermt "2026-08-01 15:45"` ⇒ **0 corruption MOI sinh trong phien S168**.
**Delta vs baseline S162 (ghi trong diary tao: "24 hit/12 file"):** giai quyet o 1.2.

### 1.2 Truy delta — bang `git grep` 2 moc (tai-lap duoc, khong doan)
```
git grep -c -F $'\xef\xbf\xbd' e5123ff -- .claude   # e5123ff = closeout S162, 2026-07-30T15:13:18+07:00
git grep -c -F $'\xef\xbf\xbd' HEAD     -- .claude
```
- @`e5123ff` (S162): **FILES=12 HITS=22**
- @`HEAD`: **FILES=11 HITS=22**
- `comm` 2 danh sach:
  - MAT: `agent-memory/harvest-curator/MEMORY.md` (1) · `agent-memory/harvest-curator/archive/2026-07.md` (1)
  - THEM: `agent-memory/harvest-curator/archive/2026-07.md` (2)

🔴 **TU DINH CHINH BASELINE CUA CHINH TAO:** diary S162 ghi *"baseline moi 24 hit/12 file"* — **HIT that = 22, khong phai 24** (lan 2 tao sai kieu nay; lan 1 da tu sua @S153). Nguyen nhan gan nhu chac chan = **m#20-bis** (xargs chia batch, cong nham dong TOTAL). Baseline DUNG cho ky sau = **22 hit / 11 file**.
- Con so file 12→11 = **moved-not-cut LANH cua chinh diary tao**: 1 self-quote U+FFFD roi tu L1 xuong `archive/2026-07.md` (1+1=2 truoc → 0+2=2 sau) — **tong bao toan 22**. Day la vet cua "moved-not-cut @S164 refine A2" ghi trong L1. ⇒ KHONG phai mat du lieu.

### 1.3 Moved-not-cut trong phien S168 (2 vai tu curate)
| Vai | Hanh vi | Kiem chung | Ket qua |
|---|---|---|---|
| `reviewer` | L1 18.518 B (17:00) — 5 dong stub `[→ archive/2026-07.md … verbatim ĐÃ PROBE moved-not-cut]`; archive 119.085 B (16:59) | `grep -n "S168" archive/2026-07.md` → **3 hit**, trong do `## @S168-curate — verbatim moved from L1` (:236) + 2 entry day-du (:238 GĐ3-D, :240 K8 Lines-editor) | ✅ **MOVED-NOT-CUT XAC NHAN** (archive ghi TRUOC L1 1 phut = thu tu an toan, dung bai m#S119 append-BEFORE-trim) |
| `cicd-monitor` | L1 17.236 B (17:23); `archive/2026-08.md` NEW 5.912 B + `archive/_INDEX.md` (17:21) | Doi chieu **loi hua trong `_INDEX`** vs ruot archive, bang chinh substring `_INDEX` khai: `S167 (08-01) \`1c6d77a\` K6` → **1 hit** trong `2026-08.md` / 0 trong `2026-07.md` · `S167 (08-01) \`aaed699\` K7` → **1** trong `2026-08.md` · `S166 (08-01) verify \`88e7ecf\`` → **1** trong `2026-07.md` | ✅ **3/3 loi hua CO HANG THAT**, dung file `_INDEX` tro |

🔴 Doi chung co y: day chinh la class **F-02 @S162** (cicd khai "verbatim→archive" ma `git log -S` RONG toan lich su). Ky nay **do lai bang cung phep** ⇒ **KHONG tai dien**. Ghi nhan tich cuc, khong im.

### 1.4 Mojibake / shell-baked — 2 DUONG-GIA do CHINH THUOC CUA TAO (tu bat)
- `cicd-monitor/MEMORY.md:96` in ra `⚠️ gi<?>` va `archive/2026-08.md:13` in ra `2221. <?>` ⇒ trong y het corruption.
  Do lai KHONG cat: `sed -n '96p' … | perl -ne 'print "FFFD_IN_LINE=", (()=/\xEF\xBF\xBD/g)+0'` → **FFFD_IN_LINE=0**. Cau day du lanh: *"⚠️ giữ luật: script sửa MEMORY phải build chuỗi XONG → temp → `os.replace` → verify byte>0."*
  ⇒ Thu pham = **`cut -c1-260` cat giua UTF-8 multibyte** (Method #6 cua chinh tao, tai-hien LIVE 2 lan trong 1 phien). **Bai: moi lan bao mojibake ma cau do vua di qua `cut`/`tail -c`, phai do lai khong-cat truoc khi ho.**
- Shell-baked (`$VAR` bi expand vao van ban): khong phat hien ca nao trong 24 file cua so S168.

**VERDICT TRUC CORRUPTION: PASS** — 0 corruption MOI trong phien S168; 22/11 la ton du lich su nguyen trang; 2 nghi-an deu la artifact-do cua chinh tao.

## 2. TRUC PLACEMENT

### 2.1 Empty-dir + stray `.claude` long
```
find .claude -type d -empty                      → 0
find . -type d -name ".claude" -not -path "./node_modules/*" -not -path "./.git/*"
   → ./.claude          (canonical)
   → ./fe-user/.claude  🔴 STRAY
find .claude/agent-memory -mindepth 1 -maxdepth 1 -type d | wc -l   → 23 role-dir
```
🔴 **F-PLACEMENT-1 (LOW, khong mat du lieu):** ton tai `fe-user/.claude/agent-memory/reviewer/` — **chuoi 3 thu-muc RONG, 0 file**, mtime **2026-08-01 10:53** (cua so S166/S167, quanh gio lane K5/K4c chay trong `fe-user`). Day la chu ky **cwd-relative mis-land** (`feedback_agent_cwd_relative_memory_misland`, S54).
- Vi sao truoc gio khong ai thay: `.gitignore:118` co luat **`fe-*/.claude/`** — **CO CHU DICH**, comment `[S76] Guard cwd-misland …` tro dung memory tren; lineage `e33481e`. Xac nhan `git check-ignore -v` → `.gitignore:118:fe-*/.claude/`.
- ⇒ **Guard dap tieng on NHUNG cung lam mu detector**: `git status` (ke ca `--ignored` mac dinh cua ta) khong bao gio hien class nay; cong them **git mu thu-muc rong** (Method #13) ⇒ **hai lop mu chong nhau**. Detector con lai DUY NHAT = `find . -type d -name ".claude"`.
- Lan nay **0 delta bi mat** (thu muc rong, khong file nao dap xuong). De xuat: (a) lead `rmdir` chuoi rong; (b) them 1 dong `find` nay vao san-do dinh ky. **Khong tu xoa** (propose-only).

### 2.2 Delta co vao dung nha khong
| Vai chay S168 | Nha canonical | Trang thai |
|---|---|---|
| `ctx-verifier` | `agent-memory/ctx-verifier/MEMORY.md` | ✅ dung nha, 11.798 B @16:10 |
| `ctx-curator` | `agent-memory/ctx-curator/MEMORY.md` | ✅ dung nha, 5.229 B @16:10 |
| `reviewer` | `agent-memory/reviewer/MEMORY.md` + `archive/2026-07.md` | ✅ dung nha ca 2 tang |
| `cicd-monitor` | `agent-memory/cicd-monitor/{MEMORY.md, archive/2026-08.md, archive/_INDEX.md}` | ✅ dung nha ca 3 tep |

**VERDICT TRUC PLACEMENT: PASS-WITH-FLAGS 1** (F-PLACEMENT-1 LOW — stray dir rong + 2 lop mu detector).

## 3. TRUC COVERAGE (0 silent-miss)

### 3.1 Doi chieu 3 vai lead khai vs dia
| # | Vai | Artifact tren dia (mtime) | Diary S168-hit | Ket luan |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | `ctx-verifier` | `.claude/sessions/session-9/_tiep-5.md` 353 B @15:49 — 5 truong may + **dong 6** `ctx-verifier: CO-11-co (…)` | **1** (dong 3, `[LEAD SEED ON-BEHALF]` khai ro) | ✅ CO |
| 2 | `reviewer` ×2 | `sub-reviewer-gate-gd3d.md` 19.266 B @16:47 · `sub-reviewer-gate-lineeditor.md` 16.977 B @17:01 | **5** (tu ghi; 2 entry S168 + dong 101 tu khai vuot cap) | ✅ CO |
| 3 | `cicd-monitor` | `sub-cicd-verify-gd3d-lineeditor.md` 9.423 B @17:18 | **2** (tu ghi) | ✅ CO |

Bonus (lead khong khai nhung co delta): `ctx-curator` diary +1 entry S163→S167 gop-seed (LEAD SEED ON-BEHALF, khai ro) ⇒ **dong 3 orphan-lượt cu duoc dong**, khong phai silent-miss.

### 3.2 Quet NGUOC — artifact co ma khong ai nhan (chong anti-pattern #1: do noi dung, khong do ten vai)
Universe = 24 file `-newermt "2026-08-01 15:45"`. Loc ra artifact kieu `sub-*`:
- 3 file cua 3 vai tren → da khop.
- 🔴 **`sub-k8-dryrun.md` 15.724 B @18:22** — file thu 4 mang tien to `sub-`, **KHONG nam trong danh sach lead khai**. Xem muc 3.3.

### 3.3 F-COV-1 (MED) — `sub-k8-dryrun.md`: co artifact, KHONG co spawn-record o bat ky diary nao
- `grep -l "K8" .claude/agent-memory/*/MEMORY.md` → chi **2 vai** trung: `ctx-verifier` (nhac chuoi lượt, khong phai K8-dry-run) va `reviewer` (**"gate K8-blocker Lines-editor"** = viec KHAC, la gate vá Lines-editor). ⇒ **0 diary nao ghi lượt K8 DRY-RUN E2E**.
- Noi dung file = cong viec RAT nang tren PROD: backup 27.877.888 B, tao 3 user TEST, 2 project, PE A/052-A/054, KHKK 001-003, HĐ ZZTEST DaPhatHanh, ban cung. Do la **lượt sinh tri-thuc dat nhat phien** (8 thuoc-thu guard, bug script "2 writer 1 file", `$env:PROD_DB_PASSWORD` khong ton tai ca 3 scope, `scripts/backup-sql.ps1` default `D:\` VPS khong co o D).
- **KHONG tu phan la sub hay lead-solo** (thuoc Fidelity, muc 5). Nhung du ai chay: **tri-thuc nay chua vao nha ai** ⇒ dung dinh nghia **silent-miss cap-lượt**, cung class **F-01@S162 / GAP-3 lop-LUOT** (da tai dien 6 lan truoc).
- De xuat cho lead: APPEND spawn-record 4-field vao **`agent-memory/cicd-monitor/`** (gan nhat ve dia phan: verify tren prod/deploy) HOAC nha vai that neu lead biet ro; nguon = `runs/2026-07-31-S164-4gd-khkk-fanout/sub-k8-dryrun.md`.

### 3.4 F-COV-2 (MED) — `run.md` S164 la BAN DO MU: 3 dong tick sai so voi viec da SHIP
`run.md` mtime **16:04**, trong khi viec ship luc **16:49 / 17:08 / 18:22** ⇒ khong duoc cap nhat sau do. Bang chung nguyen van:
- `:29` `| 4.GĐ3 | … | 🔴 **BLOCKED-SẠCH** @S167 (0-file-chạm) …` — nhung GĐ3-D **DA SHIP** `081557b` @16:49 + gate PWF-10.
- `:30` `| 4.K8 | Build K8 dry-run theo build-order B3 | hmw | ☐ chờ K8-prep …` — nhung K8 **DA CHAY XONG PASS** @18:22.
- `:31` `| 5 | Dry-run E2E toàn trình (K8) | theo spec-cum3 | ☐ chặn bởi B0-form 14 người |` — rao can **da go** (B0 PASS 16:2x).
- `:40` `- [ ] B4 — fan-out build **7/8**` va `:41` `- [ ] B5 — dry-run E2E` — thuc te **8/8** (WAL tu khai "8/8 WAVE").
🔴 Dang chu y: chinh `run.md:40` co ghi *"ledger cập-nhật @S168 theo ctx-verifier cờ②, trước đó B4 ghi '3/8 @S165' + 0-row-GĐ3 = **bản-đồ mù việc-đang-mở**"* ⇒ **benh vua duoc vá luc 16:04 da TAI PHAT ngay trong cung phien** (4 dong moi). WAL thi dung; run.md thi khong.

**VERDICT TRUC COVERAGE: FAIL-2** (F-COV-1 + F-COV-2).

## 4. TRUC COMPLETENESS (4-field {agent · task · nac · evidence})

| Vai | agent | task | nac (verdict) | evidence | Du 4? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| `ctx-verifier` | ✅ (ten muc) | ✅ 3 lượt S165/S167/S168 | ✅ `CO — 11 cờ`, "return CLEAN 0-garble" | ✅ tro `_tiep-5`, `_context-s-9:164`, `_mind-s-9` MIND-3 §E | ✅ |
| `ctx-curator` | ✅ | ✅ 3 lượt PAUSE-1/3/4 | ✅ `SUA — 9/10/8 điểm` | ✅ `_context`:70/:134/:165 | ✅ |
| `reviewer` (GĐ3-D) | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ `PASS-WITH-FLAGS 10, 0 blocker` | ✅ **`Evidence:` … `sub-reviewer-gate-gd3d.md`** (trong archive) | ✅ |
| `reviewer` (K8 Lines-editor) | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ `PASS-WITH-FLAGS 8, 0 blocker` | ✅ **`Evidence:` … `sub-reviewer-gate-lineeditor.md`** | ✅ |
| `cicd-monitor` | ✅ | ✅ `a2b37dc..0bfadc2` | ✅ `PASS 6/6` (#444) | ⚠️ than entry co `#444`/bundle-hash/gate-644 nhung **KHONG co dong `Evidence:` tro file** ⇒ xem F-CMP-1 |

### F-CMP-1 (LOW) — `Evidence:` chi song o TANG ARCHIVE cua `reviewer`
`grep -c "Evidence:" MEMORY.md` tren L1: `cicd-monitor`=0 · `reviewer`=0 · `ctx-verifier`=0 · `ctx-curator`=0.
- Voi `reviewer`: **khong phai thieu** — L1 co y giu **digest**, `Evidence:` nam trong ban verbatim o `archive/2026-07.md` (:238/:240 deu co `**Evidence:** .claude/workflows/runs/…`). Thiet ke 2 tang, chap nhan duoc.
- Voi `cicd-monitor` + 2 vai `ctx`: ref nam **trong than cau** (so run #444 · `_context`:NNN) chu khong o truong `Evidence:` chuan hoa. **Truy nguoc duoc**, nhung khong dong nhat khuon. Carry tiep tu F-04@S162 (khi do 2/4 vai thieu) — **nay do lai: van chua dong**.

**VERDICT TRUC COMPLETENESS: PASS-WITH-FLAGS 1** (5/5 lượt du {agent·task·nac} + evidence truy-duoc; khuon `Evidence:` chua chuan hoa).

## 5. TRUC FIDELITY-FLAG (neu, KHONG tu phan)

1. **FID-1 — `sub-k8-dryrun.md` khong xac dinh duoc TAC GIA tu dia.** File mang tien to `sub-` (quy uoc = san pham sub-agent) nhung `run.md` row 4.K8 ghi vai = `hmw` va van con `☐`; giong noi trong file la giong lead (*"em KHÔNG có kênh Zalo/email"*). ⇒ **Neu la lead-solo ghi vao file ten `sub-`** thi dat ten gay hieu nham nguon; **neu la sub** thi thieu spawn-record (F-COV-1). Tao **KHONG phan**, chuyen `reviewer`.
2. **FID-2 — 2 diary `ctx-*` la LEAD SEED ON-BEHALF.** Ca hai **tu khai ro rang** trong ngoac `[LEAD SEED ON-BEHALF @closeout-nợ; nguồn = …]` va co nguon truy-duoc (`_tiep-5.md` dong 6 ton tai that, `_context-s-9.md` cac dong da tro). Theo tieu-chi S143 (truy-duoc-ve-dia + khai nguon) ⇒ **on-behalf HOP LE, khong phai bia**. Ghi de doi chieu, khong escalate.
3. **FID-3 — `ctx-verifier` van CHUA BAO GIO tu APPEND.** Diary tu khai `carry ctx-verifier-no-self-append **lần 4**`. Trung khop chan doan F-01@S162 cua tao ("hong khau GHI, khong phai phat hien"). **Khong phai loi cua vai** (INFORM-only bi cam tu ghi) ⇒ day la **van de THIET KE kenh**, khong phai fidelity. Neu ra de lead/`harness-refine` quyet, khong escalate reviewer.
4. **Spot-check do that (chong anti-pattern #2):** claim `cicd-monitor` "gate 644 = 45D + 599I" va claim `reviewer` "642 = 639 + 3 Fact" — 2 con so **lech nhau 2** giua 2 vai cung phien. Da doi chieu: reviewer do **truoc** vá cuoi (642 @17:01), cicd do **sau** khi push (644 @17:18) — WAL cung ghi 644. ⇒ **khong mau thuan, la 2 moc thoi gian khac nhau**; cả hai đều khai moc. KHONG phai finding.

**VERDICT TRUC FIDELITY: FLAG-1** (FID-1 → `reviewer`; FID-2/FID-3 ghi nhan, khong escalate).

## 6. CLOSE-GATE C5 Layer-3 (DUAL-ACCEPT) — moi `runs/<id>/` co ban-ghi-ket-qua chua

Lenh (dual-accept: `*synthesis*.md` HOAC `*-return.md` HOAC `sub-*.md`, **maxdepth 2** de bat cau truc cu `harvest/`):
```
for d in .claude/workflows/runs/*/; do … find "$d" -maxdepth 2 \( -name "*synthesis*.md" -o -name "*-return.md" -o -name "sub-*.md" \) -size +0 …
```
- **TOTAL_DIR=79 · WITH_run.md=76 · ORPHAN=0**
- 3 dir khong co `run.md` (**khong tinh orphan**, khop ho so S153): `2026-07-14-S117-pe-approve-minmax-range/` · `2026-07-14-S117-pe-luyke-finalize/` (spec-only) · `2026-07-22-S144-bootstrap/` (co `bootstrap-synthesis.md`).

🔴 **TU BAT — vong 1 cua chinh tao BAO NHAM 5 ORPHAN.** Lenh dau dung `-maxdepth 1` cho `*synthesis*` ⇒ 5 folder `2026-06-18-*` (h10-implement/invest/review, h910-curate/finalize) bi ho oan; mo ruot ra thi **ca 5 deu co `harvest/<ten>-synthesis.md` 1.653–4.461 B**. Day dung la **anti-pattern #1 cua chinh tao** (do bang ten/glob thay vi noi dung) va la bai **dual-accept** tao da ghi tu S153 — **tai vap**. Con so cong bo = **0 orphan**, lay tu vong 2.

### 6.1 Folder sinh trong phien S168 (do bang commit DAU TIEN, khong dung mtime)
- `2026-08-01-S168-bookend-close/` — `git status` cho `??` (**chua co commit nao**) ⇒ sinh trong phien nay, **DANG CHAY** (vong bookend hien tai: `run.md` 4.515 B @19:31 + `sub-tooling-auditor-close-S168.md` + `sub-lead-stale-close-S168.md` + file nay). **KHONG tinh orphan** (IN-PROGRESS), nhung **ghi nhan** de lead dong cuoi phien.
- 🔴 **Bang chung live:** vong-1 quet do `WITH_run.md=75`, vong-2 (~5 phut sau) do **76** — chenh dung 1 = `run.md` cua folder bookend **vua duoc lead tao luc 19:31, giua 2 phep do cua tao**. Ghi lai lam vet mtime-chain, khong phai loi do.
- Cong viec CHINH phien S168 **khong sinh run-folder moi** — artifact di vao folder CU `2026-07-31-S164-4gd-khkk-fanout/` (dung nhu lead khai). ⇒ C5 khong co ca ho.

**VERDICT C5: PASS** (0 orphan / 76 folder co `run.md` / 79 dir; 1 folder IN-PROGRESS ghi nhan).

## 7. SAN-5 HAU-KIEM (informational)

```
grep -c "run=" .claude/WAL.md                    → 0        (chay voi || true, KHONG || echo 0)
grep -rn "wf:.*run=" .claude/WAL.md docs/changelog/sessions/2026-08-01-1800-S168-*.md   → 0 dong
grep -n "run=\|wf:" docs/changelog/sessions/2026-08-01-1800-S168-*.md                   → 0 dong
```
- **San-5 = 0/0 dang ky.** Phien S168 **khong sinh run-folder cho viec chinh** (dung khai cua lead) ⇒ khong co `run=<id>` de dang ky ⇒ **vacuous, KHONG phai vi pham**.
- Doi chieu lich su: @S153 WAL cung `run=` 0 toan so va session-log ganh 4 dong `wf:`; ky nay **ca hai deu 0**. Ghi nhan xu huong: **kenh San-5 dang o trang thai chet-lam-sang** (khong ai ghi, cung khong ai kieu). Neu lead con muon giu San-5 lam thuoc thi phai co it nhat 1 nguon ghi; neu khong, nen khai retired (giong `_ledger.md` @S100) thay vi de PASS-rong moi ky.

## 8. CHORE-MEMORY (canh bao suc khoe, propose-only)

| Vai | L1 byte | Nguong | Trang thai |
|---|---|---|---|
| `reviewer` | 18.518 | self-target 17.100 | ⚠️ **VUOT** — chinh vai tu khai o `:101` *"@S168-K8 đo lại: 18.3KB — VƯỢT cap 17.1KB ⇒ spawn sau curate NGAY"*; da curate 1 vong trong phien ma **van vuot** ⇒ nợ chuyen ky sau |
| `cicd-monitor` | 17.236 | 17.100 | ⚠️ **VUOT sat** (+136 B) — vua curate 21.3KB→~16.6KB @17:23 roi **lai vuot ngay** vi append tiep entry #444 |
| `harvest-curator` (TAO) | 18.781 | 17.100 | ⚠️ **VUOT** — nợ self-compact tu S153/S162, **chua tra**. 🔴 Nhac lai canh bao S162: `harness-refine` da BAC thuoc `self_target_bytes` cua tao (**0 hit tren dia** = chua duoc duyet) ⇒ **KHONG dung con so nay lam menh lenh**, chi la canh bao |
| `ctx-audit` 14.442 · `ring2-audit` 20.062 · `investigator-codebase` 22.452 · `tooling-auditor` 20.332 · `lead-stale-auditor` 19.342 | — | — | ghi nhan de lead xep uu tien; `investigator-codebase` 22.452 B lon nhat |

- 0-byte memory: **0 ca** (23/23 role-dir co `MEMORY.md` byte>0).
- Delta chua commit luc do: `M .claude/WAL.md` · `M .claude/auto-memory/MEMORY.md` · `?? .claude/auto-memory/feedback_dryrun_finds_promised_but_unlanded.md` (memory MOI, lead viet) · `?? docs/changelog/sessions/2026-08-01-1800-S168-…md` (9.385 B) · `?? runs/2026-08-01-S168-bookend-close/`. ⇒ **de lead commit cuoi phien**; khong phai finding.

## 9. BANG FINDING (5) — muc do + de xuat

| # | Muc | Truc | Noi dung 1 dong | De xuat cho lead |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| **F-COV-1** | MED | Coverage | `sub-k8-dryrun.md` 15.724 B — lượt sinh tri-thuc **dat nhat phien** (backup prod 27,8 MB · 3 user TEST · PE A/052-054 · KHKK 001-003 · HĐ dau tien tren prod · 8 thuoc-thu guard · bug "2 writer 1 file") ma **0/23 diary co spawn-record** | APPEND 4-field vao `agent-memory/cicd-monitor/` (hoac nha vai that), nguon = chinh file do |
| **F-COV-2** | MED | Coverage | `run.md` S164 mtime 16:04 → **4 dong tick sai**: `:29` GĐ3 con "BLOCKED-SẠCH" (da ship `081557b` 16:49) · `:30` K8 con `☐` (PASS 18:22) · `:31` row-5 con "chặn bởi B0" (B0 PASS 16:2x) · `:40/:41` B4 "7/8" + B5 `[ ]` (that = 8/8). Benh "**bản-đồ mù**" vua vá 16:04 **tai phat trong cung phien** | Cap nhat 4 dong `run.md` truoc khi dong phien (WAL da dung, chi run.md lech) |
| **F-PLACEMENT-1** | LOW | Placement | `fe-user/.claude/agent-memory/reviewer/` = chuoi thu-muc **rong, 0 file**, mtime 08-01 10:53 (cwd-misland S54). `git` mu **2 lop**: `.gitignore:118 fe-*/.claude/` (guard S76 co chu dich) + git mu thu-muc rong (m#13) | `rmdir` chuoi rong + them `find . -type d -name ".claude"` vao san-do dinh ky |
| **F-CMP-1** | LOW | Completeness | Truong `Evidence:` = **0 hit tren L1 ca 4 vai**; `reviewer` co du o tang archive (thiet ke 2 tang, OK), `cicd-monitor`+2 `ctx` chi co ref **trong than cau**. Carry chua dong tu F-04@S162 | Chuan hoa 1 dong `Evidence:` cuoi moi spawn-record (re, dong duoc ngay) |
| **FID-1** | FLAG→`reviewer` | Fidelity | `sub-k8-dryrun.md` mang tien to `sub-` (quy uoc = san pham sub-agent) nhung `run.md` row 4.K8 ghi vai `hmw` + con `☐`, giong van trong file la giong lead ⇒ **khong xac dinh tac gia tu dia**. Lead-solo ghi vao ten `sub-` = gay hieu nham nguon; sub that = thieu spawn-record | Chuyen `reviewer` phan; **tao KHONG tu phan** |

**Khong tinh la finding (ghi de khoi soi lai):** ① lech 642 vs 644 giua `reviewer` va `cicd-monitor` = **2 moc thoi gian**, ca hai deu khai moc — HOP LE. ② 2 diary `ctx-*` la lead-seed on-behalf — **khai ro + nguon truy-duoc tren dia** ⇒ hop le theo tieu-chi S143. ③ `ctx-verifier` chua bao gio tu APPEND (lan 4) = **thiet ke kenh INFORM-only**, khong phai loi vai; de `harness-refine`/lead quyet.

## 10. PROPOSE-DELTA cho lead (propose-only — lead VERIFY→APPEND, B3)

🔴 **DEDUP da chay TRUOC khi de xuat** (chong double-APPEND vi harvest chay ca per-turn lan close-gate): doi chieu substring `S168` trong tung `agent-memory/<vai>/MEMORY.md` → `reviewer`=5 hit, `cicd-monitor`=2, `ctx-verifier`=1, `ctx-curator`=1 ⇒ **4 vai nay DA CO delta S168, KHONG de xuat APPEND lai**.

**CHI 1 de xuat APPEND** (cho o trong that su):
- **Nha:** `agent-memory/cicd-monitor/MEMORY.md` (hoac nha vai that neu lead biet ro tac gia — xem FID-1)
- **Nguon:** `.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-31-S164-4gd-khkk-fanout/sub-k8-dryrun.md` (15.724 B, 3 khoi END: `:95` DRY-RUN PASS TOAN TRINH · `:122` END-FIXTURE · `:137` END-FX3)
- **4-field goi y** — *lead phai tu doc file va viet lai bang chu cua vai, tao KHONG viet ho ruot*:
  - `agent:` k8-dryrun (tac gia can lead xac nhan)
  - `task:` K8 dry-run E2E toan trinh 2 nhanh tren PROD @S168
  - `nac:` PASS toan trinh (GĐ1 PE 2 phieu · GĐ2 KHKK 2 phieu qua endpoint line MOI · K7-bridge → GĐ3 HĐ DaPhatHanh · GĐ4 ban cung · QĐ9 4/4 · B15 so-ID) + **1 blocker THAT phat hien-vá-ship trong phien**
  - `Evidence:` `.claude/workflows/runs/2026-07-31-S164-4gd-khkk-fanout/sub-k8-dryrun.md`

**KHONG de xuat gi khac.** Khong tu ghi bat ky file nao ngoai chinh file bao cao nay.

## 11. NO CUA CHINH TAO — 3 lan tu vap trong 1 phien (ghi that, khong giau)

1. **Bao nham 5 orphan** vi dung `-maxdepth 1` cho `*synthesis*` ⇒ 5 folder `2026-06-18-*` co `harvest/<ten>-synthesis.md` bi ho oan. **Chinh la anti-pattern #1 cua tao** (do ten/glob thay vi noi dung) va la bai dual-accept tao tu ghi @S153 — **tai vap**. Con so cong bo lay tu vong 2.
2. **Bao nham 2 mojibake** (`cicd/MEMORY.md:96`, `archive/2026-08.md:13`) vi `cut -c1-260` cat giua UTF-8 multibyte. **Method #6 cua chinh tao**, tai-hien LIVE 2 lan.
3. **Baseline corruption tao ghi @S162 ("24 hit/12") SAI** — `git grep` 2 moc cho **22/22**. Lan thu 2 tao sai kieu dem nay (lan 1 sua @S153). Baseline dung ky sau = **22 hit / 11 file**.
4. **L1 cua tao 18.781 B** — nợ self-compact tu S153/S162 van chua tra. (Kem canh bao S162: nguong `self_target_bytes` **0 hit tren dia**, chua duoc duyet ⇒ la canh bao, khong phai menh lenh.)

**Bai chung:** ca 3 ca deu la **thuoc do cua chinh tao hong**, khong phai nguoi khac sai. Giu luat: nghi ngo thuoc cua minh TRUOC khi to nguoi khac.

## 12. BASELINE CHUYEN KY SAU (S169)

| Chi so | Gia tri chot @S168 | Lenh tai-lap |
|---|---|---|
| Corruption U+FFFD | **22 hit / 11 file** (toan `.claude/`, gom run-folder cu) | `git grep -c -F $'\xef\xbf\xbd' HEAD -- .claude` |
| Run-folder | **79 dir · 76 co `run.md` · 0 orphan** (dual-accept maxdepth 2) | vong lap muc 6 |
| Dir khong `run.md` (khong tinh orphan) | 3: 2× S117 spec-only + `S144-bootstrap` | — |
| Role-dir agent-memory | **23** | `find .claude/agent-memory -mindepth 1 -maxdepth 1 -type d \| wc -l` |
| Empty-dir trong `.claude` | **0** (co S159 "5→6 dang tang" van DONG) | `find .claude -type d -empty` |
| Stray `.claude` long | **1** (`fe-user/.claude`, rong) | `find . -type d -name ".claude" -not -path "./.git/*"` |
| San-5 | **0/0** (vacuous — phien khong sinh run-folder viec-chinh) | `grep -c "run=" .claude/WAL.md \|\| true` |
| L1 vuot 17.1KB | `reviewer` 18.518 · `cicd-monitor` 17.236 · `harvest-curator` 18.781 · `investigator-codebase` 22.452 · `ring2-audit` 20.062 · `tooling-auditor` 20.332 · `lead-stale-auditor` 19.342 | vong lap muc 8 |

END sub-harvest-curator-close-S168 — VERDICT=GATE-FAIL-5 — TOTAL=5 — COVERAGE=5/5 truc + C5 + San-5


---

## 🔴 LEAD DISPOSITION @S168 — kèm ĐÍNH-CHÍNH-CỦA-ĐÍNH-CHÍNH (nguồn: `ring1-audit` B3/B4)

| F | Xử |
|---|---|
| F-COV-1 | 🔸 **KHÔNG phải silent-miss** — K8 dry-run do **LEAD chạy solo bằng script**, 0 spawn ⇒ không có spawn-record là ĐÚNG. Đã khai tác-giả ngay đầu `sub-k8-dryrun.md` (đóng luôn FID-1). Bài học K8 (8 thuốc-thử guard) đưa vào session-log + diary `cicd-monitor` @closeout. |
| F-COV-2 | ✅ **VÁ** — `run.md` S164 tick 4 dòng sai (GĐ3 · K8 · row-5 · B4/B5) sẽ cập nhật ở lượt ghi sổ Phase 2 (run.md nằm trong bề-mặt-đo C1 ⇒ ghi SAU verdict cuối, đúng luật). |
| F-PLACEMENT-1 | ✅ **VÁ** — `rm -rf fe-user/.claude/agent-memory` (stray cwd-misland S54); `find -type d -empty` sau dọn = 0. |
| F-CMP-1 | 🔸 GHI NỢ — trường `Evidence:` 0 hit L1 4 vai; carry từ F-04@S162. |
| FID-1 | ✅ **ĐÓNG** — tác-giả = LEAD, đã khai verbatim đầu file (vai từ chối tự phán, ĐÚNG luật). |

### 🔴 ĐÍNH-CHÍNH-CỦA-ĐÍNH-CHÍNH — nợ tự-khai ③ của H2 là **SAI CHIỀU** (ring1 bắt, lead xác nhận nguyên-tắc)

H2 tự nhận *"baseline corruption S162 ghi 24 hit/12 file là SAI, đúng = 22/11"*. **`ring1-audit` chứng ngược: 24 vốn ĐÚNG** — `git grep -c` đếm **DÒNG** (22), `git grep -o | wc -l` đếm **LẦN** (24); đo tại `e5123ff` lẫn `HEAD` đều ra **22 dòng / 24 lần / 11 file**. Hai con số **cùng đúng, khác ĐƠN-VỊ**.

**Lead đo độc lập nguyên-tắc** (pattern khác, cùng tập `.claude/agent-memory`): `git grep -c` → **93 dòng** · `git grep -o|wc -l` → **104 lần** ⇒ **dòng ≠ lần, chênh thật**. ⇒ nguyên-tắc ring1 nêu **đứng vững**.

🔴 **Hệ quả nếu để nguyên:** baseline giao S169 = "22/11" **không khai đơn-vị**; kỳ sau ai đo bằng thước đếm-LẦN sẽ đọc thành **"+2 corruption ảo"** rồi đi truy một sự cố không tồn tại. ⇒ **baseline chuyển giao PHẢI ghi kèm đơn-vị**: `22 dòng / 24 lần / 11 file @e5123ff`. Đây là **đời-3 của class "cùng tên khác đơn-vị"** (D-4 @S159 tally · S153 H2 · nay S168) — cùng họ với bài `feedback_absence_looks_like_clean`.

*(Ghi nhận phần H2 làm tốt: 3 nợ còn lại tự khai thẳng, và class F-02@S162 **không tái diễn** — 3/3 lời hứa `_INDEX` có hàng thật.)*
