# Reviewer Agent — Persistent Memory

> **Persistent diary cross-session.** Auto-injected first ~200 lines at spawn (L1 HOT).
> Update BEFORE every stop. Tiered Memory v1: L1 HOT cap ~17KB (hook 24.4KB read-limit) · L2 `archive/` on-demand · L3 RAG `search_memory` just-in-time. Keep entry ≤ 1.5K chars (gotcha #53).
> Full verbatim history pre-S40 → git `d2f52ba` + `archive/2026-05-q1..q2.md`; S51→S76 detail → `archive/2026-06.md` (S69/S70/S71/**S80** curate). Archive map: `archive/_INDEX.md` + per-period `.gist.md`.

## 📁 Area memory (L2 on-demand — Read khi review vùng tương ứng)
- [S62 PE budget soft-warning](project_s62_pe_budget_soft_warning.md) — PASS: hard-block→soft-warning; submit-guard intact + validator giữ `BudgetPeriodAmount>0`, row8 negative-safe (additive-only). Validator class `PurchaseEvaluationFeatures.cs:317`.
- [Wire/mirror claim verification anchors](feedback_wire_claim_verification_anchors.md) — sha256 twin-file · `git diff -U0` isolate true-adds · `allowNegative` bleed check · guard-still-intact grep.
- [S89 PE budget-sectionB review](project_s89_pe_sectionb_review.md) — 3/3 upheld + CAUGHT MISSED #70 race: Block B PRO row3/row8 share adjustMut + cross-echo stale + NO `||peFetching`. authz-lens ≠ concurrency-lens.
- [S89 PE ends-before-CEO PLAN review](project_s89_pe_endsbeforeceo_plan_review.md) — CONCERN: BE design sound but FE gap — 4 PeUrgentChips render-sites, plan covered only 2 (missed InboxPage:290 + wrong ListPage path).
- [S89 finalize-note PLAN review](project_s89_finalize_note_plan_review.md) — CONCERN: plan ground-truth 100% accurate; gaps = note omits intermediate-approvers-still-sign + skipToFinal-last-level corner + Dev DB 9 migs behind.
- **S101 H18/H19 WF2 governance re-run + LANE-C** — PWC/PASS; detector fault-inject 4/4; 4 hash recompute MATCH (hex→SHA strip/no-strip proves content-hash ≠ commit-SHA); lesson: exact-token sweep misses paraphrased labels → widen concept-phrase khi retire named artifact; #53 garble recovered. → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- [S103 H20+crystallized-backfill review](project_s103_h20_crystallized_backfill_review.md) — WF2 PASS; 6/6 hash recompute MATCH + 4 already-met verified. Lesson: multi-axis warning phải nằm trong OUTPUT của script (reader chạy inline), không chỉ doc.
- [S111 PE sign-off 6-decision design review (schema/history lens)](project_pe_signoff_history_schema_review.md) — GO-WITH-ADJ; Decision-5 opinion-history: RECOMMEND append-only table, REJECT version-col (drops UNIQUE + breaks UPSERT). Hook @ ApproveV2Async UPSERT :784-790. Decision-3 caller-safe (SlaExpiryJob=Contract-only). A1 breaks 4 bypass tests.
- [PE multi-NCC per-hạng-mục cardinality#3 review](project_pe_multiwinner_perhangmuc_review.md) — PASS_WITH_ADJ; 6 BE read-site inventory COMPLETE (grep 1:1). 2 MUST: giaTri isSingle/detailsSum silent-financial; seed sets IsSelected never IsWinner → empty names + CreateContract throws. Lesson: derived src-of-truth = EVERY write-path re-derive.
- [S113 Supplier import v2 close-review (owner anh Kiệt)](project_s113_supplier_import_v2_review.md) — GO-WITH-ADJ 2 must-fix: consumers (PeDetailTabs:2222 + ContractCreatePage:321 ×2app) DON'T pass published=true → drafts leak into pickers (R4/R6 "ẩn" undelivered) + CreateSupplier:86 missing IsPublic=true. Dedup/publish/mig/authz SOLID. Lesson: "filter added" ≠ "drafts hidden" — grep-all-consumer + create write-path.
- [S114 PE per-hạng-mục BE-financial review](project_s114_pe_multi_ncc_perhangmuc_financial_review.md) — NEEDS-FIX: 6 financial-SUM→IsSelected (0 sót) but DeleteQuote:396 + DeleteDetail:262 KHÔNG re-derive IsWinner → stranded winner → phantom HĐ GiaTri=0. Lesson: derived-invariant re-establish MỌI mutation kể cả DELETE.
- [PE per-hạng-mục spec review (winner-truth lần 3)](project_pe_multi_ncc_perhangmuc_specreview.md) — PASS_WITH_ADJ. MUST: CreateContract isSingle→detailsSum (`:76-90`) over-count 1-winner≠cả-gói. Lesson: grep write-path field-NGUỒN (IsSelected) không chỉ field-đọc; cite-range bọc branch-decision.
- [S114 PE per-hạng-mục IMPL review (flip lần 3)](project_s114_multi_ncc_perhangmuc_impl_review.md) — NEEDS-FIX. CAUGHT: DeleteQuote (`...Features.cs:371-397`) KHÔNG re-derive IsWinner → xóa quote cuối (nút Xóa FE:2897) VỠ invariant → phantom winner + HĐ giá 0. Lesson: cardinality grep-consumer PHẢI gồm Delete-handler field-nguồn; spec-enum writer KHÔNG đáng tin. SOLID: 5 SUM + non-tautology test + hash ae3788e9.
- [PE negative-quote FE-only spec review (correctness-wire)](project_pe_negative_quote_correctness_review.md) — PASS_WITH_FIXES. R1/R2 no-op verified accurate (CreateContractFromEval:88-100 no-clamp · BE Sum()<=0 :206 + FE :201). MUST: sign-loss — form.thanhTien read DIRECT at POST :2232/:2875+gate :2226; toggle phải re-sign field-chung KHÔNG chỉ flip neg-flag (VndInlineEdit defer-parse-at-own-save không có ở 2 dialog). Consumer inventory COMPLETE 0-break (fmtMoney/toLocaleString neg-safe). Lesson: defer-parse widget→shared-form dialog = sign phải tới field-chung ở MỌI mutation incl toggle.

---

## 🎯 Role baseline

Adversarial pre-commit reviewer SOLUTION_ERP. Read-only verify + live curl prod UAT (`*.solutions.com.vn`). Tools: Read, Grep, Glob, Bash (curl + git diff + sqlcmd read) + 5 RAG MCP. Skills: `dependency-audit-erp` + `contract-workflow` + `permission-matrix`. Output: PASS/FAIL + concrete issues file:line. NEVER write code.

---

## 🚨 Recurring bug patterns (catch priority)

- **#44 Silent 403 class-level Authorize quá strict** — Drafter dropdown empty silent (TanStack catch silent → UI empty). Grep `\[Authorize\(Policy=.*\)\]` class-level + curl non-admin expect 200. Fix: class-level `[Authorize]` only (any authenticated); POST/PUT/DELETE giữ `[Authorize(Policy="X.Create")]`.
- **#43 Step.Order ≠ index 0-based** — `Where(s=>s.Order==i)` wrong row. Fix: EF query → in-memory `OrderBy(Order).ToList()` → index.
- **#42 Dual schema V1/V2 — Service phải branch** — `if (entity.ApprovalWorkflowId is Guid awId) ApproveV2Async else V1Legacy`.
- **Wire BE claim** — grep diff `// Mock`/`alert(`/no POST-PUT-DELETE call + live curl expect 2XX. Severity CRITICAL block.
- **#70 FE absolute-set stale-echo race** — N fields cùng-cột share 1 mutation + echo sibling từ server-snapshot (`bs`) + `invalidate()` fire-and-forget (không await) → lưu 2 ô liên-tiếp đè mất. Window mở SAU `isPending=false` (btn re-enable), KHÔNG lúc in-flight. Catch: đếm field-cùng-cột share mutation + check invalidate awaited; fix = `useIsFetching` gate nút Lưu tới khi refetch land.
- **#71 enum proxy-predicate pollution** — thêm enum value vào entity dùng-chung → UI/guard phân-loại theo PROXY-predicate (`supplierId===null`) thay vì enum tường minh → value mới lẫn nhầm phân-loại + false-pass guard. Catch: grep mọi field-proxy predicate, loại value mới tường minh; build-verify TỪNG app.
- **Cross-module security mirror (S29 Smart Friend)** — khi mirror entity/Command cross-module (PE→Contract→Budget V2), focus data-shape MISS security guard. Pattern: `aw.ApplicableType == ExpectedType` validate ON Create BEFORE instantiation (mirror `PurchaseEvaluationFeatures.cs:62-77`). Attack: Drafter forge POST với `approvalWorkflowId` của module khác → FK Restrict chỉ check Id-existence NOT ApplicableType → wrong-scope pin. Re-verify `IsActive`+`IsUserSelectable` server-side. Password ≥12 chars. Severity MAJOR.
- **#17 EF migration 3-file** — `git diff --name-only | grep Migrations/` expect 3 (target + Designer + Snapshot).

---

## 📋 6-category checklist (EVERY review)

- **Cat 1 Wire BE/feature claim:** grep mock markers diff + `await api\.(post|put|delete|patch)\(` + live curl POST/PUT/DELETE if deploy claim + status matrix.
- **Cat 2 Schema integrity:** 3-file rule Mig + column types vs entity def. Reference `docs/gotchas.md` (71 active).
- **Cat 3 Security:** `[Authorize]` class-level ALL new controllers + per-action policy admin-scoped (gotcha #44) + FE PermissionGuard + menuKeys.ts mirror BE MenuKeys.cs + FluentValidation + EF parameterized.
- **Cat 4 Code quality:** `dotnet build SolutionErp.slnx` 0 err + `npm run build` × 2 app (TS6 strict) + tests baseline **354 PASS** (Phase 9 UAT exception OK) + no `--no-verify` + anti-fiddle (scope drift >20% LOC = FAIL) + mirror 2 FE app §3.9.
- **Cat 5 Test coverage:** new helper → xUnit · new endpoint → integration · bug → regression test-before-fix. Phase 9 UAT test-after default OK (`feedback_uat_skip_verify`). Baseline 354.
- **Cat 6 Writing-quality (Harness-7, S64):** outward text (verdict gửi anh / report) = tiếng Việt câu hoàn-chỉnh đủ dấu đúng ngữ-pháp; describe issue + acceptance criteria, NOT code edits. Escalate disagreement explicit.

---

## ⚠️ Anti-patterns + 🛡️ Smart Friend guard

1. ❌ Recommend code edits (only describe issue+criteria) · 2. ❌ Skip live curl if deploy claim · 3. ❌ Accept "wire" without grep proof · 4. ❌ Defer to em main authority (escalate explicit) · 5. ❌ Skip MEMORY · 6. ❌ **Lower bar match em main** (Smart Friend Cognition anti-pattern).

**Smart Friend (Cognition):** NEVER lower bar. Em main code fine → PASS. Em main issues → FAIL with specifics regardless social pressure. "Quality ceiling set by primary, not escalation." Value = raise quality through catch.

---

## 🧠 SOLUTION_ERP review essentials (S80 verified — re-ground từ docs/STATUS.md canonical)

- **Tests baseline:** **354 PASS** (45 Domain + 309 Infra · 0 fail/skip). Must increase khi feature added (§7); Phase 9 UAT exception (`feedback_uat_skip_verify`).
- **Gotchas:** **71 active** (`docs/gotchas.md`, format `### N.`). Latest: #69 bundle-hash non-determ (deploy rebuild-FE-uncond rotate) · #70 FE stale-echo race (useIsFetching gate) · #71 enum proxy-predicate pollution · #66 Tailwind v4 unlayered `h1-h4` color thắng utility · #58 EF read-modify-write lost-update→ExecuteUpdate atomic.
- **Migrations:** **57 latest `AddPeSuggestedPriceNotes`** (path `src/Backend/SolutionErp.Infrastructure/Persistence/Migrations/`). PE-budget: Mig 50 `PeWorkItemBudgets` per-gói-thầu (DROP module Budget cũ) · Mig 54 giá-đề-xuất PRO/CCM + giá-chốt · Mig 55 CcmNote · Mig 56 ProInitial/ProAdjust split · Mig 57 ghi-chú-giá PRO/CCM.
- **Endpoints:** ~253 · **88 SQL tables**.
- **Identity password ≥12 chars** (reject 11-char). Test creds: admin `admin@solutions.com.vn/Admin@123456` (full) · UAT `nv.test@solutions.com.vn/TestUser@123456` (Drafter CCM).
- **Prod:** api/admin/eoffice.solutions.com.vn. Bundle live admin `CsJetgZH` / user `BVS0ApIm` (Run #330). **Pin:** MediatR `12.4.1` (flag `Version="14`) · Swashbuckle `6.9.0` · Node CI `20.x`.
- **Conventions:** `docs/rules.md` (§1.1 outward writing, §3.9 mirror 2 FE, §5.2 commit, §6.5 docs narrative, §7 test timing, §2.8 pin).

---

## 📅 Recent activity (compressed — full verbatim → `archive/2026-06.md` + `archive/2026-07.md` via `archive/_INDEX.md`)

- **S117 (2026-07-13) PE negative-quote FE-only spec-review (financial-invariant-owner lens) — PASS (0 blocking, 1 confirm + 2 test-notes):** budget-intact VERIFIED — UpsertQuote (`PurchaseEvaluationDetailFeatures.cs:282-366`) writes 0 budget fields; quote ThanhTien flows ONLY into read-only display aggregates (currentProposalTotal/prevSelectedTotal :911-926 + winnerQuoteTotal :1188) — NEVER mutates PeWorkItemBudget. #81 IsWinner + S114 multi-winner SAFE: winner-derive keyed on `IsSelected` boolean, sign-agnostic (negative ThanhTien irrelevant). R1 baked (ContractFeatures.cs:46 GiaTri>=0 untouched=manual path; CreateContractFromEvaluation:88-90 no-clamp=PE-inherit). R2 FE:201/BE:206 BOTH `SUM(ThanhTien where IsSelected)<=0` = IDENTICAL algebraic sum → 0 divergence from negatives. CONFIRM raised: enterable-negatives OPERATIONALIZE net-value driving CEO-escalation gate (winnerQuoteTotal<CeoApprovalThreshold→CCM skip-CEO) — governance, not display; owner sign-off. T3 note: `SeedWinnerWithQuoteAsync` seeds 1 quote/winner → "mixed net>0 submittable" half needs multi-quote seed. **Lesson: 2-tier guard divergence check = compare SUM EXPRESSION not just comparator; derived-flag safety = trace what flag is KEYED-ON (IsSelected≠ThanhTien); "budget intact" true for RECORD but quote-sum still flows to display+governance aggregates.**
- **S116 (2026-07-13) outward-email GATE se→ai_infra H-22 WAL restart runtime-verify — PASS (0 over-claim/3 minor):** 6/6 ground-truth re-run MATCH (#5+#6 EXACT: archive-gate 12/12 sub<25.6KB + A7 246/246 pointers; crystallized 382713B/380K-tok/252K headroom). Caveat STRONG+prominent (defers real-persist→S111). Minor: (a)-persist WEAK — `.claude/WAL.md` git-committed 0-drift → survives-restart = git property NOT WAL-mechanism. Lesson: persist-claim on git-tracked WAL → verify tracked+0-drift; mechanism-proof lives at Stop-hook run. → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- **S115 (2026-07-13) `/fable-real` spec-review presence-not-age adopt — PASS-WITH-FIXES (0C/2M/5m):** M1 acceptance-grep can't detect its OWN deliverable's miss (narrow regex 1/3 doc-lines → false-PASS; fix bare-token+classify). M2 skip-element on contiguous-prefix cut = correctness-inversion. Lesson: verify EACH regex-alt vs EACH target-line by hand; `parallel()` runtime-builtin robust-under-both = endorse-with-caveat. → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- **S101 H19 fable-clone WF2 Lane-A (toggle) — PWC, CONCERN closed @S102:** marker WRITE-ONLY dead artifact — persist-claim cần CẢ reader-side (verify consumer exists, not just producer); reader BƯỚC 0.5b wired S101-cuối. → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- **S100 H18 WF2 synthesis + Lane-B — PWC 0-blocking:** ledger revert-clean + ratio-band + 6/6 🧊; anti-pattern HELD: stale WF2 run-id NOT stamped. → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- **S98 (2026-07-02) 3 verify-lane — PASS (minor):** fidelity-gate 3-lớp (verbatim+pointer-arith+ground-truth-code); Windows byte-verify = .NET ReadAllBytes/`wc -c`/`od -c` (MSYS strip `\r` báo sai). → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- **S97/S97-bis (2026-07-01) PE finalize UAT ×2 + EndsBeforeCeo Mig 60/61 — PASS:** default-flip byte-mirror SHA256 ×2; RUNTIME-flag 1/5 DaDuyet grep-all + 4-projection; backfill-LIKE VN false-pos MINOR. → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- **S93 (2026-06-29) Harness-16 MFE adopt (WF2 3-lane) — PASS 0-blocking:** code-gate re-derived denom-29; READ-ONLY-budget 1 write-op; WF1 caught vocab-fork H6.7≠H16. → adap-report + _INDEX.

- **S92 (2026-06-29) PROD-security hide 5 menu-groups admin-only (uncommitted) — PASS (1 note):** A-E upheld; CatalogManager Danh-mục stripped (by-spec, 0 users). → [project_s92_admin_only_modules_revoke.md](project_s92_admin_only_modules_revoke.md).
- **June-2026 archived digest (detail → `archive/2026-06.md` + `_INDEX`; S89/S90/S91 PE = FROZEN do-not-touch):** S91 create-contract 1→N multi-winner (codegen mid-loop flush ONLY seq-row; positional DTO 3-site; 419 PASS). S90 stability D1 (Block B re-key IsWinner; CEO-notify never-flush fix; #70 ||peFetching). S89-bis AREA-6 joint-winner DEAD-END (FE `some(isWinner)` vs BE `SelectedSupplierId is null`). S89 AREA-4 HoSoLink #73 clear-on-partial + 2nd call-site PeDetailTabs:817. S88 fidelity-gate FAIL: merge-distill fabricates false-specificity (QUALITY gate AFTER presence). S86 PE Section B authz byte-mirror NotFound→Forbidden fail-closed. S82 Harness-15-v2: sha=self-declared frontmatter NOT recompute. S76 PE budget: #70 useIsFetching gate + spec-scope-framing can be FALSE (read changed-set). S72 Mig 54: fail-closed guard BEFORE DaDuyet + server-recompute no-trust-client. S71 Harness-10: TRACKED=check-ignore(eligible) vs git-ls-files(committed). S69 Office re-skin: grep byte-equal + public-grant root NOT inherit-root. S65: upgrade MUST MUTATE row NOT skip-existing; menu-hide ≠ API-lock.

- **S108 (2026-07-10 first-real-run H19) — FAIL (1C+4M+6m):** email claim "đã sửa comment" khi hmw.js chưa sửa. Lesson: outward-claim "đã sửa X" phải cat X trước gate; grep stale-claim theo CLASS sau fix đại diện. → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- **S109 (2026-07-10 fidelity-gate 2 gist L2) — PASS_WITH_FIXES (3):** gist meta-count 15≠disk 14; delta tự-tính +8.8KB = self-computed false-specificity; N/A-just over-claim → fact-claim trong N/A verify như content. → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- **S111 (2026-07-12 H22 WAL adopt) — PASS_WITH_FIXES (0C/1M):** fault-inject 2-ca PASS; CATCH CAVEAT "STAGED" còn khi N.3 nâng VERIFIED-RUNTIME = nâng-nấc-quên-sync cùng-diff; live-witness>forensics (commit GIỮA review = chứng hook fire). → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- **S110 (2026-07-11 H21+MTv3 adopt) — PASS_WITH_FIXES (0C/5M):** doc "VALID_ROLES 12" nhưng code=10 → claim-về-code grep lại kể cả reword; supersede trỏ adap-report chưa tạo = dangling. → `archive/2026-07.md`.
- **S112 (2026-07-12) `[fable-real-single]` close-reviews + FINAL bundle — GO 0-must-fix:** (import) Import btn reuses Suppliers.Create guard but endpoint=Admin/CatalogManager → dead button → derive guard from ENDPOINT authz not sibling-menu; (PE sign-off) EDGE-5 terminal-lock sót admin-override SVC:290 → gác FROM-state ở ĐỈNH method KHÔNG per-branch; A1 mở CEO-skip. FINAL 6-axes PASS + 30 ExpectedHeaderTokens byte-identical NFC. Lesson: self-flip token-test = internal-consistency NOT external-file-accept; byte-diff token-array TAY. → [topic](project_s112_supplier_import_review.md), `archive/2026-07.md`.

---

## 🔄 Curate trigger
- Hook-cap **>17.1KB** (24.4KB read-limit — đổi từ ~30KB cũ, S109) → archive recent → L2 `archive/<period>.md` (append additive) + `_INDEX.md` substring pointer. Stale >3mo → remove.
- **S116 curate (self, 2026-07-13, hook 21.4KB→<17.1KB):** moved S115+S116 verbatim → `archive/2026-07.md` (move-not-cut, batch-marker) + digest in L1; MERGED 12 June bullets (S65-S91) → 1 consolidated digest line (detail `archive/2026-06.md`+`_INDEX`); trimmed 4 PE-per-hạng-mục + S89-trio + S111 Area-pointers (detail in topic files on disk).
- **S113 curate (self, 2026-07-12, hook 21.3KB→~16KB):** compressed 4 verbose S112 entries (2 close-review lines→1, BE-close+FINAL→1) + this curate-log in-place; NO file-move (lessons preserved inline). digest kept L1. **+review-lane addendum:** 4 verbatim ALSO moved → `archive/2026-07.md` + 4 `_INDEX` pointer (move-not-cut) + trimmed 2 digest.
- **S109 curate:** moved 4 verbatim S100/S101 → `archive/2026-07.md` +4 pointer.
- **S102 recovery (em-main):** cut-not-moved ×5 @`f229b07` recovered từ git. **Lesson: L1-shrink kèm claim "Detail→archive" = BẮT BUỘC grep moved-not-cut TRƯỚC khi trust digest.**
- **Prev curates:** S80 (moved 13 S65→S76 →archive/2026-06), S71 (moved 10), S70 (built `_INDEX`+`.gist`), S40.
